Sliding patio door - Security film or security screen door?

We're in a new single-story house in a fairly dense housing development. Our nextdoor neighbors apparently went on vacation, and somebody broke into their house around 7:30 tonight by smashing their sliding glass patio door in the back.

I've been looking into ways to protect that back door, and was considering security film for this back window, but a coworker suggested I look into the security screen doors from Unique Home Designs instead.

I don't think I yet have the budget for both. If you had to pick one, which would provide the best security for us?

Posted Jan 13, 2020, 8:06 AM UTC

35
[deleted]•

Two things I know about crime victims....they tell the whole world they are going on vacation on social media and they had not even a cheapie security camera with cloud upload.

I can’t see the film stopping them as much as they could just go 15’ over to the next window with no film. A slide locking steel bar system is a real deterrent which forces them to kick the front door if they intend to carry anything out.

8 Wyze cams for $200 to cover the house, steel security at the front for $119 and rear sliding cage for. $480 is a great start for $800 total.

Force them to come through the window and they’ll go next door because you have double key lock for entry points they’ll have to climb out carrying stuff...not likely the trouble.

3
winkers•

The security film and security screen will make it only more difficult to enter, not prevent entry. I’ve looked at a few products in person. Also my neighbors have gotten broken into via their sliding doors. In my head I could get through a filmed sliding door in about 3 minutes with a hammer (which is what local have been using) but I’d make a lot of noise doing it. With a screen it would take me slightly less time if I knew what tool to bring and i could cut it more quietly.

I opted for security films on the glass doors as well as harder-to-uncouple bolt locks for the sliding doors. This made it more difficult for the intruder as they typically would break the glass, unlock the door, and slide it open. With my setup they couldn’t break the glass as easy and when they do... they still can’t open it due to the deadbolt on the slider. That being said, it’s just a minor deterrent and they can still enter. But now my family has ~2 minutes to call for help, arm themselves, and get to safety.

2
AudiGuy3point0•

I recently upgraded the lock on my sliding glass door and at first I was a little displeased that it required a key not only to get in, but get out at as well. Reading things like this make me glad it's keyed both ways. I will also be doing security film sometime soon as well.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
winkers•

It’s been a while since I wrote the comment. If you’re asking why I think I could get through the screen easily in a few minutes?

In my area, people breaking into houses, garages, and stealing bikes in the area. I’m very involved withy neighborhood watch group and always examine how they attacked the security. About 1/3 of the break-ins look like the intruders prepared beforehand. I had two neighbors with security screen doors and their video cameras caught how the break-ins occurred so quickly. The thieves used a cordless grinder (like https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-18-Volt-ONE-Cordless-4-1-2-in-Angle-Grinder-Tool-Only-P421/100519983) to cut the screen. Took only a few seconds.

I asked for a sample of the material from the broken screens. It’s tough. Unlikely to tear. Even cutting with shears or a knife was difficult. But a very thin grinding blade on my own corded grinder cut it easily and relatively quietly. When I pick a security feature I’d like it to only be defeated by also making significant noise to alert me or my dogs.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
winkers•

It’s still a good product. Anything that slows down an intruder is a good thing. For me though I’ve been opting for security items that will require the intruder to make substantial noise.

3