Is decreasing the importance of gifts the way to balance them?
Personally I'm getting really sick of all the discussion over Protect and Accel and how to balance them. I'll admit a big part of this is the fact that I tend to favour Accel clans, and I instinctively fear over-correction and Accel and Protect basically swapping spots in the meta.
That got me thinking: What if the problem isn't the specific gifts themselves, but rather the gift system as a whole? Before IGs were a thing, clans were still always unbalanced, but a clan's place in the meta was always subject to change based on the support that the clans got; Granblue might not be as good as Pale Moon one moment, but that could change as soon as a new set released. With gifts, however, it's almost like thanks to the sheer impact the gifts have on games, clans have been given "modifiers" on their strength. So going back to the previously mentioned clans, Pale Moon always has a higher modifier than Granblue, since it just straight up has access to better gifts, so Granblue would need much stronger cards to compensate, and deliberately making some clans' cards stronger is a slippery slope to creating a broken deck. In a sense, gifts have added a "point of failure" to the meta. If they're not balanced, the meta probably isn't healthy. Problem is, balancing them is really, really hard.
The solution then? Make gifts less relevant, like in Premium. Ignoring the obvious outlier in Wonder Ezel, gifts are far less impactful in premium, thanks to the wider card pool, strides and G-guards. They're still important in most decks, but what gift a deck has isn't the main factor in determining its strength. The commonly accepted top 3 decks in premium (not stating whether I agree or disagree)? GP, NN and DI. One Accel, one Force, and one Protect. The gifts in Premium decks (again, Wonder Ezel as the exception) don't dictate whether or not a clan can be good, thanks to the comparative power of everything else.
The downside of this? Everything needs to be powercreeped. Powercreep is a painful process in general, but on this scale, and with many clans getting only a set of support a year, the powercreeping process would hurt a lot.
What do you guys think? Should gifts just become less important? Or is there another way to balance the game?
Posted Jan 13, 2020, 4:29 PM UTC
I'm going to be honest, I really dislike the gift system (or at least how it's been implemented). Outside of the very obvious going first complaint and the points you made, I always felt like it kinda homogenized decks at least during y1 of standard.
Now the issue I have with getting rid of gifts is that I feel like the current power level of standard rn is fairly high. Cards like riv and angerblader can kill on turn 3 and we have cards like hyuga that enable so many combo pieces, just spreading 30-50k worth of power to a board and have a free board wipe built into it. I think the power level you would have to reach to creep out gifts would not be appreciated by a lot of people.