Is decreasing the importance of gifts the way to balance them?

Discussion

Personally I'm getting really sick of all the discussion over Protect and Accel and how to balance them. I'll admit a big part of this is the fact that I tend to favour Accel clans, and I instinctively fear over-correction and Accel and Protect basically swapping spots in the meta.

That got me thinking: What if the problem isn't the specific gifts themselves, but rather the gift system as a whole? Before IGs were a thing, clans were still always unbalanced, but a clan's place in the meta was always subject to change based on the support that the clans got; Granblue might not be as good as Pale Moon one moment, but that could change as soon as a new set released. With gifts, however, it's almost like thanks to the sheer impact the gifts have on games, clans have been given "modifiers" on their strength. So going back to the previously mentioned clans, Pale Moon always has a higher modifier than Granblue, since it just straight up has access to better gifts, so Granblue would need much stronger cards to compensate, and deliberately making some clans' cards stronger is a slippery slope to creating a broken deck. In a sense, gifts have added a "point of failure" to the meta. If they're not balanced, the meta probably isn't healthy. Problem is, balancing them is really, really hard.

The solution then? Make gifts less relevant, like in Premium. Ignoring the obvious outlier in Wonder Ezel, gifts are far less impactful in premium, thanks to the wider card pool, strides and G-guards. They're still important in most decks, but what gift a deck has isn't the main factor in determining its strength. The commonly accepted top 3 decks in premium (not stating whether I agree or disagree)? GP, NN and DI. One Accel, one Force, and one Protect. The gifts in Premium decks (again, Wonder Ezel as the exception) don't dictate whether or not a clan can be good, thanks to the comparative power of everything else.

The downside of this? Everything needs to be powercreeped. Powercreep is a painful process in general, but on this scale, and with many clans getting only a set of support a year, the powercreeping process would hurt a lot.

What do you guys think? Should gifts just become less important? Or is there another way to balance the game?

Posted Jan 13, 2020, 4:29 PM UTC

179
NervousPit•

I'm going to be honest, I really dislike the gift system (or at least how it's been implemented). Outside of the very obvious going first complaint and the points you made, I always felt like it kinda homogenized decks at least during y1 of standard.

Now the issue I have with getting rid of gifts is that I feel like the current power level of standard rn is fairly high. Cards like riv and angerblader can kill on turn 3 and we have cards like hyuga that enable so many combo pieces, just spreading 30-50k worth of power to a board and have a free board wipe built into it. I think the power level you would have to reach to creep out gifts would not be appreciated by a lot of people.

8
noirpoet97Link Joker•

My personal take on the problem based on some play testing is that introducing Gift II’s was not only a terrible idea in itself, but the support that came with it; not only did Accel II specifically fix an issue that Accel clans generally had (which was card draw, if I remember correctly), but they also had cards built in that fixed the issue already like Dorianne in Pale Moon. Protect I in itself was already a strong gift, and Protect II was a strict downgrade, especially because little to no Protect clans got much helpful support to aid the new gift like giving grade 2s Resist or grade 1s that can intercept from back row and are not limited by null-interceptors (at least from what I can tell in Standard). Force I was fine, but Force II enables too much game ending potential when obtained against someone still on Grade 2, especially since card draw isn’t very good in Standard until you get to Grade 3. Tbh, I’d feel better if they removed the Gift II’s cause the cards themselves are already getting better and are adapting just fine with the first gifts, but having Gift II just made the game too fast and as we’ve seen, unbalanced. It might not fix every problem, but I think it’d help balance things a bit

5
NikodariusAngel Feather•

Yeah, Gift II were rushed and need to either change or go away. PII is susceptible to every form of removal, making it basically useless with the exception of particular matchups and AII is just so much better than AI that no one uses it anymore where I play as Accel decks are more than capable of power-upping like nuts.

A possible change to II (which can be errated at no cost as Gift are printed in every set) would be no power up for AII, limiting it to just draw and PII back to hand with a progressive shield which goes up the more attacks your opponent does (maybe with a cost and/or sentinel attached to it)

Another way of dealing with the weaknesses of clans I would have liked instead of Gift IIs would have been clan specific gift with more restrictive rules applying to them (like limiting them to the player with less gifts and more damage), making them a named card (which could be easily banned if it ever becomes too strong). They could also serve as draw PGs replacements as highly wanted cards at RR cards, since lately we've seen lots of uninspired card at that and RRR rarity that would be better suited at a lower level (looking at you Scanning Operator, Thermometry Angel and basically all the Genesis RR bunch in BT07).

2
Xshadow1OP•

The problem with the Doriane example is that not every clan has a Doriane, and not every clan has a Luquier either. Take Aqua Force as an example: you need to re-ride at least once for Glory Maelstrom, so you need the draw on your first ride to draw into Glory Maelstrom, otherwise your deck doesn't really do anything, so having an extra chance to see your re-ride or have cards to guard till you get there really helps.

The speed of the I think isn't due to the gift IIs. Riviere uses Force I, and clans like Tachikaze and Gold Paladin can just go Accel I on turn 3 if they want to win that turn.

1
noirpoet97Link Joker•

Appreciate you mentioning that not every Accel clan has cards that draw easily like Dorianne since I can only build and own so many decks and therefore can’t learn every deck possible yet. However, the thing about the Glory Maelstrom example is that the problem you mention is a problem most decks would normally have. Like I mainly use Messiah, but the deck has the same problem of needing to ride the correct Grade 3 to make the deck work with no way of searching Harmonics Messiah out except for drawing it (with an admittedly fairly decent draw engine in Lady Battler and Ghastly Nail).

As for Riviere, I can only say that Bushi just did a shitty job balancing the card, while I don’t know enough about Tachikaze to have an opinion on it. And Ezel... Well, you got me there, I guess

1
Xshadow1OP•

Your Messiah example is great because it demonstrates what a re-ride dependant clan can be like without Accel II. Messiah has had pretty much no tournament results to speak of since V-BT05 came out. What's even worse is that both normal Maelstrom and G3-in-soulless Glory Maelstrom are practically useless. No extra card draw, no or negligible power increase and either a near impossible to actually use restand or a useless guard restrict.

I was actually more referring to Agravain for GP. Ezel really wants Accel II, since it needs to see all the Ezel for its superior ride. Plus Ezel in premium is the deck that abuses Accel II the most.

1
khinzawNova Grappler•

I think that important win con skills need to be restricted to having a grade 3 in soul or your opponent needing to be on grade 3. Case in point, how bullshit Riviere is since it'slive while youropponent is on grade 2. This makes going second something you might actually chose to do, while slower clans get an extra turn to build up and acquire more gifts.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
UltimaEpochMurakumo•

Not sure about how practical this is, but I've always wanted for older gimmicks in Vanguard to get rotated around, rather than being left to die. As Yugioh does it, introducing a new summoning mechanic, but still printing new cards utilizing old gimmicks, I'd have liked Vanguard to do the same, and it'd be a great way to reduce the reliance on gifts.

Imagine if a player is given full access to good cards and all of the gimmicks, Breakriding, Striding, Legion, and IGs, and the only stipulation is that a player can only chose to utilize one gimmick per turn, I'd think it will be a fun way to reduce the reliance of IGs on the meta, and keep some of the interesting ideas that Bushi has thought of over the years.

(Also, clan specific IGs would be so cool. Probably never going to happen, but would be so cool. It would be like strides again.)

2
YaBoiBoiBoiBoiDimension Police•

Gifts have always been a heavily flawed system I never really liked.

1