Weird Text, wondering if a neat trick exists..

Rules

So, my question is on the following card (Sudden Substitution). The text is as follows, "Instant: Split Second- Exchange control of target noncreature spell & target creature. Then the new spell's controller may choose new targets for it."

During Combat Phase[Declare Blockers/Damage], as Player B is defending from Player A's attack, say A had a|4/4|& a|2/1| & B had 2 |2/2s| all are attacking/blocking one each.

Player A uses an instant to make their |2/1| into a |5/5|, Player B responds when they gain priority with Sudden Substitution, exchanging the |2/2| blocking the |2/1| to take A's instant & make their remaining creature into a |5/5| thus overwhelming the |4/4|.

Is the |2/1| still going to be blocked by the |2/2| that was exchanged due to Assign Blockers already happened even though the opponent now owns the creature & would effectively be blocking themselves?

If so, did Player B essentially wipe out Player A's creatures & is left with a |5/5|, making a for pretty neat trick?

Sorry about the trouble of asking, I spent a good deal of time looking up rulings & similar situations, but didn't find much on the subject so I don't know if exchanging control allows for Blockers/Attackers to be switched to not Attack/Block. Thanks Again in Advance!! : 3

Posted Jan 14, 2020, 4:18 AM UTC

07
Natedogg2Level 2 Judge•

Changing controllers causes the creature to be removed from combat - it won't be attacking or blocking anymore. If you exchange control of their spell and your blocking 2/2, your 2/2 won't be blocking anymore since it was removed from combat when your opponent gained control of it (and thus won't deal or receive any damage in combat). The net result here is that the 4/4 dies, and the other three creatures survive (their 2/1 and new 2/2 didn't deal any damage, and your 2/2 survived combat due to the pump spell).

7
TheFettest_Fett•

Rule 506.4 if you were curious

2
tbdabbholm•

Creatures that change control are removed from combat, Rule 506.4

1
Shadow_KitOP•

Okay, thank you, I couldn't find that! Hmm, next best thing would to replace with something that goes away at the end or the turn then.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Shadow_KitOP•

That's my guess? It seems like a rather OP move in that specific scenario because of Split-Second not letting you react to it happening. Also, you could exchange a defending 1/1 token that will die anyway effectively allowing you to steal a card for free(mana cost aside). It's not specified, so you could literally take an enchantment, aura/equipment, etc & give them nothing in return.

HECC TAKE THEIR PLANESWALKER WHILE YOU'RE AT IT.

I smell a ban in the future since I don't think anyone spotted that or maybe it's intentional?

-1
TheFettest_Fett•

When an attacking or blocking creature changes controllers it is removed from combat

1
Natedogg2Level 2 Judge•

fox112 was incorrect. Changing controllers causes the creature to be removed from combat. If you have a blocking creature, then give your opponent control of that creature, it's removed from combat and is not blocking anymore.

1