My girlfriend and I agreed to dog sit a 3 month old black lab for a few weeks while the owner moved. Days turned into weeks, and weeks to months. Very little communication from the owner. Then we get a letter in the mail from her lawyer.

This all started back in October of 2019. My girlfriend’s friend’s boyfriend’s cousin needed a place for her puppy to stay while she moved. This distant relation should’ve been a red flag, but after meeting her, she seemed like a genuine person.

Our first mistake was not getting anything in writing. The original agreement was $50 a week and the owner provided food, toys, and anything else the pup needed. She said that it would hopefully only be a couple days maybe a week. Alright no big deal. She pays us (via app) and leaves saying she’ll be back tomorrow to come visit. She set a time up and made plans with us. She never showed up and didn’t really communicate much.

A couple weeks go by and she comes to pick her up to get some shots. She mentioned this previously so it was no surprise. That all goes as planned and she picks her up and drops her off no problem. She continued to have very little communication with us for the next couple of weeks, but she kept paying us. We received a total of 3 payments to cover 4 weeks.

Then the pup ran out of food. So we asked her if she could drop some off or send some money. I don’t recall what happened, but she did neither. So we started buying her food, as well as everything else she needed. The owner was not easy to get ahold of, and was having money problems and would pay us later. (Snapchat stories showed that she would go out to the club quite often).

We decide that, at this point, we need to just take care of this puppy. We want her to grow up healthy. So that’s what we focus on. And at this point, she is bonding with the four of us in the house, and our two dogs we already have.

The puppy is about 7 months now. And we got a letter in the mail from a law office. “RE: Demand for Return of Property”. The property in question? One “Puppy”. It said we entered an agreement of a flat payment of $ and one puppy from the pup’s future litter. This was something we never agreed upon. We have texts messages of the owner agreeing to the real agreement from above. The letter DEMANDS that we return the pup in 7 days. If not they will take legal action including filing a lawsuit to recover stolen property, and all that jazz.

Should we be scared? We have proof that she is lying about the agreement. She never even asked if she could come pick the pup up. She never once came to visit. She didn’t pay us for 6-7 months. 3ish Months

Would this be something that would go to small claims court?

What actions can I take to prepare us? We already have all the receipts and vet bills ready.

Posted Jan 17, 2020, 12:55 AM UTC · edited

17
TheCatGuardianQuality Contributor•

She didn’t pay us for 6-7 months.

This all started in October 2019 so at most the puppy has been with you 3.5 months.

She may owe you money for whatever she agreed to pay (i.e. the $50/week plus food) but you need to return the puppy to her.

What were the vet bills for?

2
Max877OP•

I’m sorry the puppy is 6-7 years. You’re correct. I didn’t mean to say she’s been with us that long.

The vet bill was to get her deflead, because she was completely riddled with fleas. The second one was to get her mandatory shots that her owner would not take her to get.

2
TheCatGuardianQuality Contributor•

You can try to recover thoe costs as well, but you do still need to return the dog so just contact her and tell her to come pick it up. You can sue her for the money she owes if she hasn't paid you, if she has no real moeny you may not ever get repaid.

1
Max877OP•

She won’t communicate with us whatsoever. Can we not take it to court? We know she’s lying about the agreement. She’s showed zero interest in the dog. Never asked to come get her. Never even came to visit. She broke the agreement we had is that not worth anything?

1
TheCatGuardianQuality Contributor•

You can sue her for the money she owes you. You don't have to agree to any new deal but you do have to give the dog back.

2
ohnoimcaught•

You mention the age of the dog several times, while calling it a puppy. You say you want it to grow up healthy, and that its 7 months old. But then in your comments you say its 6 to 7 years old. I'm confused.

2
NomNomRabies•

I’m assuming they meant to say months.

1