r/anime•
Suavacious

I’ve never seen an MC force you to watch a show as hard as Miu in the new 22/7

Discussion

I went into the first episode expecting a 5 minute drop because it’s an A1 Pictures promo anime for I think a virtual idol group or something like that, the most bland, unexciting shit imaginable. But Miu’s opening monologue immediately hooked me in, right through the cheek, as her words painted an Edvard Munch portrait of a black pilled, cynical, introverted, idol antichrist (“I don’t worry about world peace, so my world is at peace” aside from being fucking BARS, when was the last time you heard a line like that in an idol anime). Instantly relatable, instantly lovable.

Her actions during the rest of the episode were super accurate to this initial characterization as well. A lesser anime character would just immediately roll with the weird anime premise, but not Miu. Of course she’d nope out of some sketchy idol draft, but her resolution to muster up some ambition and become an idol after some shit happens was GAR as fuck! It’s impossible not to root for her.

I recently finished reading Lucifer and the Biscuit Hammer (great manga btw), and the start of this show is very reminiscent of Yuuhi’s process of reluctantly yet resolutely accepting the story’s call to action.

I really hope this show keeps this up. I’ve seen every first episode this season, and this is my second favorite. Really excellent stuff so far. I highly encourage anyone that read this and became interested to check it out. I don’t know if I stan 22/7 yet, but I definitely stan Miu.

Posted Jan 17, 2020, 4:32 AM UTC

515
r-point•

im with you on this one. The fact that Miu is so uncofindent of herself and how she looks, which is clearly shown by how she carries herself, makes me want to root for her. Like, I'll think to myself, how is she gonna overcome this. And for some reason, when I heard her voice, yeah, could tell it was a newbie seiyuu voicing her. Normally I shouldnt like it, but theres this raw aspect to her voice, and that actually makes me like it, dk why could just be me. Anyways, Miu is someone that will make me root for her. And she's my favourite in the whole idol group

3
Mynameisyeffer•

SOUNDS AWESOME.

2
siklonav•

I guess it works both ways, because never did a MC force me to drop a show as quickly as Miu, her voice actress is so bad sounding and amateur that I literally couldn't get past that fact.

I get it, her seiyuu is an idol and not a voice actress, but there should be a minimum standard for voice acting, and she clearly fell behind...

1†
IXajllhttps://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii•

I honestly thought her voice was very refreshing to listen to exactly because she does not sound like your typical everyday-seiyuu.

8
siklonav•

I can understand that, in fact I knew there's gonna be people who like it because of that, but her voice aside - which I also don't like, I'm more into cute voices than deep and raspy woman voices any day),, which I can understand is pretty subjective, and some people might find said voice even better than the usual - her ACTING was objectively very poor.

I'll give the show another chance once we have enough episodes to know how the plot is like, and if the plot turns out to be interesting rather than trainwreck, I'll see whether I can tolerate it, or if she gets better at the acting part.

-1†
IXajllhttps://myanimelist.net/profile/ixajii•

Fair enough, even though I don't quite understand how you can say the acting was "objectively" very poor. Personally I didn't mind it too much and I feel like you have to be a native japanese speaker to make such a statement.

7
siklonav•

I'm not a native japanese speaker by any means, but I did learn to speak and understand Japanese to an extent where I can at least watch little children's shows without needing subtitle. But I think you can notice how the voice actresses here are all amateurs even without knowing much of Japanese, but Miu sadly happens to be the worst at acting, BY FAR so far.

-1†
samanthajoneh•

I get it, her seiyuu is an idol and not a voice actress, but there should be a minimum standard for voice acting, and she clearly fell behind...

No, it isn't, do a better research about the project. All the girls on 22/7 had training on being VA along being idol after being approved in the audition. The project literally began for all the girls on the audition to be both.

5
siklonav•

I'm pretty sure she got a pass because she was a good idol candidate, but yet, they are amateurs at being VAs, this is literally their first role, so what the hell are you talking about? And it's really, REALLY obvious how some of them are not meant to be VAs, with Miu being the worst offender. Guess that VA training can't make everyone decent at it, so I'm not sure what research you did, but apparently it wasn't good enough to go against some facts.

3
samanthajoneh•

Unlike you, I know this group from day one and the very project. I'm not just watching an anime.

I'm pretty sure she got a pass because she was a good idol candidate, but yet, they are amateurs at being VAs, this is literally their first role, so what the hell are you talking about

Ah yes, she and the others passed because of one thing when the project is about being real idols and VA on an anime. Makes total sense. Even more when Akimoto, Aniplex and Sony Music are involved.

And no, this isn't the first role of them. All of them had minor roles before, with some even having main ones.

In the documentary from the group with the beginning, you literally have one part about them taking classes for VA, not even counting that some already did it before the audition: https://vimeo.com/270376281

4
siklonav•

Well then Miu's VA clearly has no talent for voice acting. Because her acting IS bad. Like really, really bad. If I can tell, and a lot of other people notice it, then there's something to think about. I'm sorry that it's the truth you have to face, even if you're invested in the group as idols or something - Miu's VA is bad enough to seriously damage the anime. And until now I had some hopes that she keeps improving, but if she already had training, then I guess it's hopeless and she's just not cut out for that. At least she probably can sing very well, so that's something.

2
generalmillscrunch•

It’s not bad acting. It’s just not the usual overacting you get from VAs who are trying to match the over-the-top art style for moe girls. The fact that it’s a more grounded performance clashes with almost every other performance in the show, but that is obviously the director’s choice, and is most likely done purposefully to illicit a reaction similar to the OP’s. It’s comparable to the acting in an anime movie where they sometimes cast actual actors and actresses over known TV industry professionals. Ghibli has done this for literal decades. It’s a shame that the directors artistic vision isn’t as cohesive, or it wouldn’t come across so jarring to the average otaku. But it certainly isn’t “bad acting”.

5
siklonav•

Sorry, but you won't convince me. I know what you're getting at, but it just doesn't work for me. She sounds awkward, doesn't articulate properly, and can't get her voice to sound clean. Top that off with a deep voice that I really dislike to begin with, and I got myself a voice and acting that is enough to ruin the show.

2
generalmillscrunch•

That all sounds like personal preference to me, and has no bearing on the actress talent, or the quality of the performance itself. Her articulation is adequate, what you may be hearing is the mix of the audio itself. It’s a bit low compared to the usual anime volume, probably to accentuate the background music, which makes sense for a music show.

I know I won’t convince you otherwise, but I think it’s disingenuous to blame the voice actor on choices the director made.

6
siklonav•

If you enjoy it, it's all good. Of course I'm putting my opinion here, I genuinely think it's the VA who can't convey her lines in an enjoyable fashion, but whatever. I'm over it, as I dropped the series over a week ago, and it's not like I wanna disencourage any people from continuing. I just had to get my disappointment out.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1