Upgrading CPU went weird

Hello everyone. Turned out to be quite a long post, but I thought every detail could be necessary to get the whole picture.

4 months ago I built a PC using the following components:

  • mobo ASRock Fatal1ty X470 Gaming-ITX/ac
  • memory VENGEANCE LPX 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR4 DRAM 3200MHz C16
  • cpu 3400g
  • cooler Noctua NH-L9i
  • m.2 ssd 970EVO 500GB
  • sata ssd Kingston A400 960GB
  • case inWin Chopin (later upgraded to Node 202)
  • psu Chieftec CSN-450c 450 watt 80+ gold
  • gpu MSI GTX 1660 SUPER VENTUS XS OC (bought it 2 months later along with the new case) ((the card doesn't fit in the case well btw))

I also have 2 monitors, both 1080p, 144hz + 75hz. Gaming keyboard and mouse.

Everything was working fine, but I wasn't quite content with the cpu performance – any rts or building game caused the rig to struggle, and the overall gaming performance was noticeably calling for an upgrade (not to mention poor cooling due to L9i's height)

So I saved up a bit and bought:

  • 3600x
  • cooler ID-Cooling IS-60
  • cpu fan Noctua NF-12x15 to replace the cooler's fan

Yesterday I swapped the 3400g with the new CPU, along with the cooler, which was a total pain in the ass.

I put the cooler the the wrong way and the case cover wouldn't go on its place due to the dust filter's clips, so I had to unscrew the cooler, and then when i pulled it, the cpu went out of the socket, and was totally glued to the cooler.
I eventually managed to tear it off, re-apply thermal paste, and screw the cooler in againI put the whole system together, not expecting that anything would go wrong (ofc it would), connected the peripherals and tried to boot.

Usually, the cpu fan would start spinning right away, but not this time.
It literally spinned around 1 time and stopped, while the system was trying to boot. Then the system powered off, and it spinned 1 more time. Then the system tried to reboot. Repeat.
It was an actual shock to me, as it didn't make sense at all: gpu fans and the case fan started spinnig, which at least meant I would have access to BIOS, right? And the fan thing is a nonsense as well.

Sooo I had to take everything apart again and check if the 3400g worked to make sure the socket was alright (which it was), then went to MOBO support page and checked newer BIOS drivers. Turned out, the 3400g required more latest driver version to work than 3600x, but I downloaded the latest one anyway and updated the BIOS.

There was one more thing: since m.2 with an OS was directly connected to MOBO, I decided not to connect the other ssd, and the system said there was no bootable device. Then I connected that other ssd and it worked just fine. Can anyone explain what that's about? I'm positive the OS is located on the m.2

Had to assemble everyghing again. At first nothing changed. Fan does 1 spin around and stops. Does 1 spin after the system shuts down. System reboots. Fan spins 1 time. Then it's just working. And the system boots. 'What the fuck' I said. Checked if everything was detected correctly, then shut the system off and put everything back in the case.

Now everything works (to an extent), but on boot the cpu fan still makes 1 spin, and a few seconds after starts working adequately.

Now I can play a game and watch a stream without FPS drops, which I was just doing. And the system just froze: the game, and the browser. I was able to open the task manager, which said the cpu and the memory were both utilized 44%, but no numbers on the whole page had been changing. Then I clicked on the 'performance' tab and the task manager froze as well. Had to reboot to get things work again.

I googled a bit and the only good guess for that behavior was that the PSU couldn't take it anymore.

So now finally to the point:

  1. Is a 450 watt gold-rated PSU sufficient to power my components?
  2. If so, what can cause the whole system to freeze?
  3. Why didn't the new cpu work at first?
  4. Why does the fan behave like that now?
  5. What's with that situation with ssd's?

Thanks for reading, and even more so for any help!

upd: forgot to mention the memory lol

Posted Jan 17, 2020, 4:30 PM UTC · edited

111
sanjosalien•

My best guess is your probably under with a 450w psu. I could be wrong.

5
TurnipZombie•

450W is enough, that’s not the problem here

1
Emo_Playz•

Have you even reinstalled windows? Like wtf its the first step as it can cause bullshit like this

1
LSD_Ninja•

You shouldn’t have to reinstall Windows from scratch after only replacing a CPU. Hell, I haven’t reinstalled Windows on one of my machines in something like 2 years and it’s had something like 5 CPUs and 4 GPUs (5 technically, but I’m pretty sure the Radeon predated the first SSD, which was the only time I ever reinstalled Windows from scratch on it since I built it in 2017), among other things. About the only component that really warrants a Windows reinstall after replacing it is motherboards, even if they use the same socket/chipset.

3
Emo_Playz•

Good for you, its a small probability but it can really fuck with your driver updates leading to locked bios on gpus or bricked mobos cause of wrong cpu instructions, happened to friends of mine

1
LSD_Ninja•

Driver screwiness I get, that’s why you reinstall it after changing the motherboard - even if it’s the same socket/chipset - but everything else sounds like a coincidence. That said however, there’s never really been a situation where a single socket has supported quite as many individual CPU families and architectures as AM4 so that possibly changes things.

1
ThatExactGuyOP•

I didn't reinstall windows after putting a new cpu in. The situalion with reinstallation happened way before that :D

1
ThatExactGuyOP•

Yes I have. The first time it happened I (or something) fucked something up and I couldn't use search in windows anymore. Couldn't fix it either, so the only option was to reinstall the whole system.

Which didn't go well eigher: after I formatted the ssd in windows installer, it threw an error and said the drive can't be used to install windows or something.

Didn't understand what happened. Somehow fixed it and installed the OS.The OS didn't boot though. It just went to windows installer over and over, even when I specifically chose a boot device. Then I tried to reinstall windows again, and just when it turned off to reboot, took the flash drive off. System did boot after that.

Total bullshit, I aggree. They say that there should only be 1 drive connected to a MOBO for a clean windows installation, and at the time I had both of them connected. Could be that.

1
Emo_Playz•

Dont think so, still try installing on a ssd while its the only one connected

1
Meddx•

If you think it can come from the PSU, you can try to remove the gpu, boot and check if it still behave the same.

1
fearnotofthecool•

A friend of mine had a somewhat similar issue. I'm not familiar with how XMP may work on non-Asus boards, but if you have XMP enabled in your BIOS, try turning that off and see if it helps.

If it does, re-enable XMP and up your RAM speed from 2133 to 2400, then 2600, 2933, 3000, 3200 until the problem presents itself. You may also need to provide more voltage to your RAM if it's not set to run at 1.35 V already.

Also before trying the above, just reset everything in your BIOS as a precaution, then see if the problem persists.

1