r/belgium•
imalps

Can you receive a speeding fine by an officer who is simply on guard?

Just curious as they would not have any way to know how fast you were actually going.

Posted Jan 18, 2020, 6:17 PM UTC

439
Bitt3rSteelTraffic Cop•

Yep

18
imalpsOP•

Would they make an effort to stop you or just record your plate?

2
Bitt3rSteelTraffic Cop•

Depends

6
Millennial_TwinkFlanders•

Now I’m interested. What if they write you up for doing 70 in a 50 zone, does the police officer get the last word if it would get to court? There’s no evidence on both sides, except for the police officers eyes/testimony. Would this mean an angry, corrupt officer could just write up random cars at random moments if they feel like it?

6
Bitt3rSteelTraffic Cop•

The assumption is that an officer has nothing to gain by making up wrongful fines against random citizens. He can only lose.

The purpose of reversed burden of proof in traffic is to prevent virtual impunity in traffic because many, if not most offences boil down to he said/she said or quite large privacy issues in case of recordings.

This would usurp so many court and police resources as every case would require testimonials by the officer who made the report.

The punishments are considered low enough that the benefits outweigh the risk

15
chief167French Fries•

Correct me if I am wrong, but I thought you could indeed get a fine for 'unadjusted speed' if they see you driving clearly over the limit, instead of just guessing however fast you were going.

Or can a cop actually claim he guessed you were driving 75 instead of 50 and that defines your fine? Because it can be a lot more or less expensive with just a few km/h difference

1
Bitt3rSteelTraffic Cop•

Can't cite for exact speed, just 'inappropriate speed'

3
AdrenalineRushh•

My sister in law received a ticket for ‘bellen achter het stuur’ according to an officer who spotted her. Now she has handsfree calling in her car so obviously uses that and her phone is always in her handbag while driving. The officer also wrote in his statement that he was on foot and noted this while she was driving past. We checked her phonebook history and she did not have an incomming or outgoing call around the time the officer spotted her. She took it to court with all of these arguments but still lost the case and ended up paying 5x more than the ‘minnelijke schikking’. She thinks she might have been scratching her ear/face and that the officer mistook it for calling..

16
friedchicken4you2•

Damn, I'd be so angry if that happened to me.

3
chief167French Fries•

That is indeed a shitty story, but how is this relevant to this post?

0
fredoule2kCuberdon•

It's relevant that while I agree that we should suppose that officers wouldn't lie (after all they are sworn in), the risk to be able to overrule honest mistakes from the initial testimony is too high

3
chicken__soupBeer•

Yes, an officer's statement is presumed as factual, it's up to you to prove otherwise. You know the old saying: guilty untill proven innocent

10
41C_QED•

So to be safe we'd need to have a dashcam with speed overlay ourselves? They can tell if you're speeding sure, but who is to say they don't overestimate the transgression by a few kph?

5
chicken__soupBeer•

Who's to say you didn't manipulate the dashcam?

7
[deleted]•

It's really hard to do it well (framerates), close to impossible if there are people walking, redlights cycles etc in the video.

The judge would likely give you the benefit of the doubt.

What is really really easy is estimate the speed from the movie.

2
chicken__soupBeer•

Do you think that

(1) a judge, or someone the judge trusts, can differentiate between 28km/h and 32km/h, based on dashcam information, knowing that tampering is possible (such as changing framerate)?

​

(2) doing (1) would be cheaper than paying for the settlement ('minnelijke schikking')?

1
41C_QED•

Then how are you supposed to prove it?

Say I'm going 88 in a 70, which happens sometimes as I still forget from time to time no sign means 70 nowadays (thx Weyts), and the road feels 90-worthy. What can I realistically do to defend myself if they'd try to pin a 95 or 100 on me?

1
chicken__soupBeer•

I'd suggest to pay the settlement (minnelijke schikking), as defending yourself will turn out more expensive.

1†
imalpsOP•

Exactly. Does 28 look like 32. Dashcam should be good enough proof...

4
Bitt3rSteelTraffic Cop•

You must always adjust your speed to the circumstances. The sign denotes the max speed, not the safe speed at that very moment

5
drughi1312West-Vlaanderen•

Safe speed is very subjective, what's safe for Vettel is not safe for my grandma.

3
MrFingersEUFlanders•

Yes. They can guesstimate how fast you were going (it's fairly obvious to even a civilian when someone is doing 70 in a zone 50).

https://www.hln.be/nieuws/binnenland/politie-flitst-elk-jaar-15-000-hardrijders-zonder-camera-50-of-70-km-u-dat-zie-je-ook-met-blote-oog~af4b364d/

3
RangerUK•
2
imalpsOP•

Ha. Paranoia will get ya.

1