r/raleigh•
miscsubs

Appealing new appraisals

Has anyone had any luck with appealing Wake County's appraisal for their home?

I just got mine for 2020 in the mail and somehow they think we have the nicest home in the neighborhood by far (we don't).

The square footage is close enough (though higher than what it really is) but when I looked at the Wake real estate search, they marked our house 91% "condition %" while most of our neighbors are around 70%, even houses that have been remodeled recently.

Our assessment went up by 21%, even though the previous one was based on the sales price we bought it in 2015. As far as I can tell, none of our neighbors have had that much of a markup.

Anyone know if I can use the neighbors' houses as an argument in an appeal?

Posted Jan 18, 2020, 7:22 PM UTC

320

it amazes me the amout of folks complaing about property values or assesments going up. So far it not even raising property taxes becasue we dont yet know what the new rate will be.

Did anyone complaining own property in 08-09 some places values dropping 20% was ok because at least it was not 30% like it was the year before..

Up is good, down is bad. So some of us might have to pay a bit more prropty tax but it beats the hell out of a stagnant or dropping market even if you are not selling anytime soon. be careful what yall wish for, you might get it and most of yall will regret it.

11
fortfive•

Up is definitely good if you’re fixing to sell. Not if you’re holding.

-3

Up beats down even if holding. If it looses it takes time to come back up and if it looses odds are the tax rate will increase for the county to offset the losses and shit starts to spriral down real fast.

That guy down the street who just bougght a house he can just barely afford and was gonna sell in 2 years panics cause he is uside down and stops paying his mortage, three more do it. next thing you know you got empty bank owned foreclosed houses sending values down farther. And the ccyle just keeps getting worse for 3 years then takes 5-8-10 to recover and get back to the values you had last year.

Up is the only good thing.

11
fortfive•

Assuming taxes bear some relationship to actual market value (they are supposed to), in your scenario, if i own my house outright i’m still better off on a 12 year time horizon as my costs will be lower. Also better if i’m a landlord.

Granted there may be other benefits to a growth market, but in straight dollars costs of ownership, lower assessments are better if i intend to hold or buy.

-1

if i own my house outright i’m still better off on a 12 year time horizon as my costs will be lower.

But at the end of 12 years you get the increased value in your pocket at the sale. The little bit of possible increase in taxes is nothing when its sale time if the values go up every year. Not to mention thate increased tax renenue (if the county chooses to increase their revenue which iis safe to assume they will a little) funds stuff that tends to increase values and quality of life more so it cycles up the oppisite of stagnant and declining values. .

When you stop growing you start dying.

4
NotAnOctagon•

Interesting. I just did the math on my numbers and my increase was also 21%. I wouldn't be upset about the extra taxes if I felt like the property was actually worth what they claimed, but a house down the street listed at that amount and after about six months finally sold for 55k less than the original ask.

3
Hkerekes•

It doesn't work that way though. House down the street could have had cat piss everywhere and needed new floors. They can ask whatever they want but cat piss is worth $55,000 less.

Appraisers usually get a rough idea per square footage and apply it to your neighborhood. Most of the time it's close. Ours went up to $113 a square foot. Homes have been selling for around $120 a square in our neighborhood.

Most of the time anyone bitching has no idea of how reappraisals work.

1
chica6burgh•

If you believe the valuation is extremely off base, you can hire an independent appraiser ($400-$500) to get an accurate valuation to use in your appeal. I have a couple of friends that are Certified Real Estate appraisers - let me know if you want a referral.

3
RaleighNC40•

I did, years ago - I think they met me halfway. I appealed a few years ago, and it was denied. Always worth a shot!

2
ApolloThneed•

I filled out the online form this morning, attempting to back it up with recent comps in my neighborhood. Doesn’t hurt to try

3
xenner•

Why? Your tax isn't going up. [yet]

-8
InTownforToday•

Umm... The tax rate isn't going up, but you pay more in taxes if your house has a higher value.

1†
xenner•

Good try making stuff up, maybe you should do some research.

Source: https://www.newsobserver.com/news/local/counties/wake-county/article239169988.html

And

https://wakeweekly.com/stories/check-your-tax-bill-wake-property-values-go-up,199236

“Our local market has been extremely active since 2016, and we have ample sales data to substantiate values calculated during this reappraisal process,” said Tax Administrator Marcus Kinrade. “It’s important to note that the reappraisal only focuses on updating assessed values for 2020 – not the amount of property tax that will be due.”

3†
zaltanaCheerwine•

He's not making stuff up. My taxes are going up not buy much but they are. I had a nearly 50k increase in property value. I have some friends who have seen several hundred dollar changes given the significant change. Here are the stats for my property via the county's revenue tax estimator.

Estimated 2020 Tax Using Estimated Revenue Neutral Rate WAKE COUNTY 0.6 $1,381.73 RALEIGH 0.3585 $825.58 Total: $2,207.31

Previous Property Tax WAKE COUNTY 0.7207 $1,317.73 RALEIGH 0.4382 $801.20 Total: $2,118.93

Change in Total Value: 25.95% Average annual change in Value: 6.49% Estimated Change in Tax: 4.17%

3
miscsubsOPOakleaf•

That is the tax neutral tax estimate.

What that says is if the county decides to keep the tax revenue flat, that is how much you would pay.

But that process will happen in May/June and you need to appeal by March. If you don’t appeal, and the county decides to keep the tax rates unchanged, you have no recourse AFAIK.

I would say the chances of Wake keeping revenue flat is unlikely.

5
xenner•

less than 100 bucks? Okay, keep complaining. Our property tax is laughably low.

3†
InTownforToday•

My apologies. The county hasn't announced if they will adjust the rate down to offset the value increase yet (just that it's a starting point). Based on how the government works, I am 99% confident the amount I pay in taxes is going up.

1