Why is this sub filled with so much woo?

If anyone would like to have a rational conversation about consciousness I'm down. There's nothing in the sidebar so maybe I was mistaken in thinking this sub was actually about consciousness. I mean seriously, most of these posts belong in r/psychonaut.

Posted Jan 20, 2020, 5:31 PM UTC

519
psychedchick•

I also noticed that, thought it would be filled with thought provoking posts and about the subject..

2
01212002•

Well, what do you wanna talk about in r/consciousness

1
LocalFluffOP•

I dunno, how weird it is that we seem to "possess" it and yet can't show that it exists in anything other than abstract relational notions and perspectives (thus why I think it's ultimately an illusion, but not not real, just as real as software. I'm just tired if the same old speculation and insistence on a magical wonder substance. Sigh, I'll head back to r/neuroscience I guess, but it's kinda stuffy for my casual attitude. Thanks for responding, smooch.

2
Fishk_•

There’s always r/qualia but there’s not too much activity there

1
bad_nosebleed•

It's filled with woo because it's just very hard to talk about modes of knowing beyond mental - so we get caught in all the fancy stories and explanations (and ultimate circle-jerk) of relying on mental to transcend itself. It's just not possible. It's obvious to any serious student of consciousness that our thoughts (and "mind" itself) have severe limitations - and then everyone comes in and are like "there's no evidence for this". But what's not understood is that the need for "objective" evidence is a just another mental construct. Experience of self that transcends the mental is possible (in fact it's our birthright). But so much has to be left behind to access it that folks just chase their tails forever trying to "figure it out". This leads to fantastical stories, semantic arguments and name calling. Which is a complete waste of time!

1
tuku747•

Because consciousness doesn't even exist. If you think it does, you're already insane.

1
FlowRiderBob•

I would argue that consciousness is the only thing one can know with 100% philosophical certainty actually DOES exist. It is everything else that COULD be an illusion. I haven't the slightest clue how to explain the existence of consciousness, but it damn sure exists.

4
LocalFluffOP•

I think you two are using different definitions of "exist".
Does software exist? What is it made out of? I think OP was saying it doesn't exist independently, as a separate substance beyond the physical substrate. But we obviously are displaying some kind of existence when we interact with each other.

1
edups-401•

How can you be so sure?

0
ro2778•

I'd like to talk about consciousness but I think many people use the same word to define different subjective experiences and there isn't much agreement on the objective definition either! So first, we should agree that we are talking about the same thing. What do you mean by consciousness?

1
LocalFluffOP•

I think "awareness" is my favorite. Which begs the question what is awareness? Simply put, it's understanding that something is happening. So what is understanding? Can you prove you understand anything? How would we test to see if someone understands something? Is just robotically repeating a sentence an example of understanding? It's hard to show understanding but if you take something simple like "do you see my text?" And they respond with "yes" they are displaying awareness. A plant can not do this but they still respond to the environment so they might have a higher degree of consciousness than a rock.
A single neuron displays as much awareness as a plant, or an amoeba but when in a network of billions, much higher degrees of awareness can be displayed. I think we can display it, but we can not contain it. It is not a substance, it's a response to stimulus.

1
ro2778•

Well, I don't think consciousness is awareness, I think that association is derived from a lack of understanding of what consciousness is. Often the two words are used together, conscious awareness, which doesn't help!

What is awareness? I think it's actually the domain of the 'Mind' which I would define as the analytical engine, or the supercomputer in our head which processes all of our sensory inputs and stitches that together with our experience / fears / imagination / other cognitive domains, in order to produce an output which is an understanding of what's going on. Certainly we have more awareness than a plant because we have a brain with lots of cognitive domains. Where as I don't actually know anything about plant physiology, but you are right they respond to light, my orchid grows towards the light, so in that sense a plant I would say has a very rudimentary mind, not a supercomputer though!

However, I think the mind interacts with consciousness but that they are separate.

1
IcallmeAce•

I think it’s more like a lighter. When the fuel is out, the flame dies. The end.

1
G_Nostic•

Considering there is exactly zero firm evidence as to what consciousness even is, seems that rationality around it is highly subjective.

0
LocalFluffOP•

Rationality, if used correctly and coherently is not subjective. Of course the conclusions you make might be, but that's what is so great about using logic to approach truth claims; facts are true wether or not you believe in them.

1
G_Nostic•

Within an agreed upon framework, yes. The issue is that consciousness seems to occupy a space which includes ALL possibilities. Is imagination outside of consciousness? Not sure one can rationalize the infinite possibilities of imagination.

0
LocalFluffOP•

I don't know if anything can be "inside" or contained by consciousness. I doubt it. Would you say that a program "contains" the information? Or is the information just the same as the code? As in, the code "contains" meaning but it's just ones and zeros as far as its physical reality is concerned.

1
G_Nostic•

Ok, so if the brain/body is the computer/hardware, then the code is coming from somewhere external. Let’s call that “intelligent infinity”. Is the code, itself, conscious? Is consciousness the product of processing the code? How is the code delivered to the hardware? Is it delivered through energy? Is the energy conscious?

0