Mike Pettine
Any thoughts or word on what’s going to happen with Pettine? I don’t think he necessarily needs to go but he was a McCarthy guy and maybe ML wants to bring in his own guy.
Posted Jan 21, 2020, 12:07 AM UTC
Any thoughts or word on what’s going to happen with Pettine? I don’t think he necessarily needs to go but he was a McCarthy guy and maybe ML wants to bring in his own guy.
Posted Jan 21, 2020, 12:07 AM UTC
Not firing Capers after 2012 and holding onto him for so long wasted Rodgers prime without a defense. I don’t want to repeat the same mistake in Rodgers remaining years when Pettine’s defense always gives up big plays and can’t stop the run. Let LaFleur get his own guy.
I hate this narrative. Nobody else “wasted Rodgers’ prime.” For that matter, he’s not blameless either. Handle a snap. Stop holding the ball for eons. Aaron is as guilty of “wasting” his own prime as anyone by, ya know, competing.
Dude in all of Rodgers playoff losses the defense has given up an average of something like 34 points a game. Three of those losses he led a game tying drive and then never got the ball back, two of those being in overtime. Most of those were under Capers defense but still they’ve always disappointed. Yeah Rodgers isn’t blameless but let’s not act like the defense isn’t most responsible for those losses. Brady has had far worse performances in the playoffs and won because he’s had a reliable defense his whole career. You must listen to Nagler and his shit takes too much or something, either that or you don’t understand football is a team sport.
It’s 36.9 ppg allowed in his losses. Yeah. I understand football. It’s about individual accountability. Not hero ball. Not Swiss cheese defense. Not blaming the previous coach. The 49ers kicker their ass. But stop it with this “Woe is Aaron” mentality.
He’s too conservative like McCarthy. If we get a decent sized lead he just plays deep zone coverage so that they don’t get huge 50+ yard plays off of us. He lets them get to the 20 and then starts blitzing and playing man. He’s got to go.
Because if he didn’t they’d get huge 50+ yard plays off of us.
I don’t think Pettine will be canned this offseason. The defense made some big leaps from last season so I expect him to have another year. In the weeks to come look for changes to be made to some of the assistant coaching staff though.
Pettine made some big leaps in defense so hard to see moving on. I think we move Gary to ilb and Blake gets released though
Uh...what makes you think we would move Gary to ILB?
Yeah, idk about that. If anything Gary would play DE. But we spent all of last season teaching him to play a 3-4 OLB. And if we lose Fackrell in free agency we’re going to need Gary for depth at OLB.
Right after we move bulaga to wr
It worked for the Titans last weekend!
I don't think it's a big secret that he's not MLF's guy and was strongly suggested by management. I think at times he misplayed the defense and got caught up playing all too soft and not trusting guys to make plays.
Then again, the scheme for the most part was fine. There just wasn't enough talent, especially in the interior or the defense. Outside of Kenny Clark, the middle was abysmal. Blake Martinez is an average to below average ILB. Tyler Lancaster, kinsgley Keke and Adams are, at best, replacement level players right now.
The defense needs speed at inside linebacker and they need more beef up front. I went back and watched some of the big runs from the 49ers game and there was rarely a down that Goodson or Martinez were able to run free and downhill. Constantly had guards in their face almost immediately. Hard to defend the run when that happens.
If they replace Pettine it has to be with an established defensive mind. Wade Phillips or someone like him. I think going too young and inexperienced is a bad choice for an already very young staff.
Bring in wade Phillips
I want to leave it in LaFleur’s hands. If we wants a new guy, let’s rip the band aid off and do it now. If he likes Pettine and wants to give him another year, let’s give him one more year and reevaluate
If you are looking for a replacement, Kris Richard, the former Seahawks DC and most recently Cowboys Pass D Coord is not being retained. He’s had a lot of success in the past and was one of the instrumental pieces in creating the legion of boom. It might mean a move to a 4-3 defense, but it wouldn’t be the worst thing. Gary and Z as DEs with Kenny and Lowery/Lancaster/Adams at DT. Preston can play the strong side LB and use FA/draft for the MLB and weak side. You could still do a hybrid 3-4/4-3 in transition but that would be my pick if we move on from Pettine
Get me Jim leonard
He’s tight with Pettine, idk if he’d take it after his former coach/mentor got canned
I would get rid of him You haven’t got time to waste. It’s not like Rodgers has years left. They need to be sensible and get pieces around him and shore up the defence.
Needs to go
Consider bring of in Wade Phillips. Put some pressure on Pettine.
Man wade Phillips would be awesome
Wade Phillips is old and couldn’t get it done with a stacked defense. No thanks
Wait what? His defence is what carried the Rams in the Super Bowl and most of this season.
Exactly lol. Have no clue what he is talking about.
I don’t believe he was a McCarthy guy for starters.
Secondly it’s up to MLF and what we think we need to do moving forward which could include switching to 4-3.
We've already hashed this out on this sub.
Realistically, we aren't parting ways w/ Pettine this year. It's yet to be seen that our run D problem isn't a personnel problem. Gute will make sure we shore up the middle this off-season. If Pettine can't get it done next yet, then, it's fair to start this conversation.
I'd be happy if we moved on