Asking for feedback about 2 magical homebrew items of Legendary level, possibly beyond legendary
Hi everyone, my players are currently level 15, so campaign is getting to ridiculous levels. Organising civil war within a kingdom, protecting them against Mindflayer invasions, all that stuff. I've introduced a couple legendary items in this campaign already, but since there might be a moment when players actually acquire these two items below, I wanted to write down the properties throw it your way for feedback :
Mage Banes Ring (legendary ring, requires attunement): While wearing this ring, you can turn invisible as an action for 1 minute. Anything you are wearing or carrying is invisible as long as it is on your person. You become very briefly visible once you attack or cast a spell. This feature can be used once per day and regains its power daily at dawn.
- idea here is clear. It's a very powerful combat ring when it's time to actually murder someone. The brief visibility is the only weakness of the ring (besides timer as it's 1 minute and that's it for the day), leaving opportunity for readied attacks of enemies.
Mage Banes Cloak (legendary cloak, requires attunement): While wearing this you have advantage on saving throws against area of effect spells. Additionally this cloak has 2 charges. If you're the target of a spell targets only 1 creature, this cloak protects you, directing the effects of the spell back at the user, using 1 charge in the process. If you're hit by a spell attack or fail a spell saving throw, original caster of the spell must make a spell attack against themselves or a saving throw against their own spell. This cloak regains all of its charges daily at dawn.
- this one is superb, it gives constant advantage against spells like Fireball or Cloudkill, plus when being a target of spells like polymorph or disintegrate and the user fails it's save (or is hit), it fully redirects the spell back. The clear weakness is that it has 2 charges, so two simple firebolts (or in theory 1 magic missile or 1 cast of eldritch blast by at least a level 5 character) deplete it's charges. However the user would have to know what the cloack does, plus the logic is that the original assassin was going against highly powerful mages, they would more likely cast Finger of Death or Disintegrate or Feeblemind or Power Word : Stun or something like that.
Thematically those items have a reason to be like this : Within my campaign setting there are sometimes mentions of legendary warriors that existed centuries ago and the ridiculous gear they had back when civilisations thrived. Talk about a legendary gnome known as "Mage Bane" that acted as a safeguard against archmages that felt like not fitting the "I'm 100% awesome and good and help mankind". So the theme of his gear was all about killing mages. Tracking wherever they are, assassination with ease, immunity against magic, etc. There is currently a high level halfling rogue NPC that is the PC's antagonist and has been able to find two of her items. He already fought the PC's twice with them items and gave them a hard time, so the players are really itchy to hunt down this Mage Bane imposter.
Posted Jan 23, 2020, 2:38 PM UTC
There is a ring of invisibility, a legendary item that gives constant Invisability no matter what you do. So perhaps you’d like to buff the first one as invis for 1 minute really isn’t that big, and could be a rare item. The second one is strange, as it really does gimp spell casters. I understand it working for single target spells like feeble mind etc, but having it work on aoe spells where it’s not just the wearer, it can be multiple people is very strong for an item, but it only has 2 charges which makes me think it’s not that whack. It’s a good idea, and if you want it to make spellcasters suck for a couple rounds then it definitely works, the first item just needs a few buffs to be comparable to the ring of invisibility.
Also be sure to catch the wording, for example how you must be “hit by a spell, or fail a spell saving throw”. For spells like power word: stun and kill, there is no save, and is no hit, and so would go straight through the cloak with no chance to send back :)
Thanks for taking time to help! Appreciated.
I compared this ring to that one and it does indeed give invisiblity, but the second you attack or cast a spell you are visible again and you have to spend an action to become invisible again. So it gives essentially endless casting of 2nd level Invisibility spell. This ring acts as a Greater Invisibility spell without concentration. A 11th level Fighter can action surge to active the ring and then for the next 1 minute be invisible no matter what and do 3 attacks per round at advantage because he is invisible, all while moving without provoking opportunity attacks, etc. Do you still feel like it's not legendary level? I'm more than welcome to buff it but it has to have a limited amount of uses, otherwise it's just insanely better than another already legendary item.
Oh man you're 100% right. I completely missed this. I'll rewrite it as "being affected" or something along those lines so that it's clear that this even shields you even against spells like you described that automatically work.
Fair point with the ring of invisibility, but I think for a rogue it is better. It’s also a bonus action to activate the invisibility. I think perhaps you are caught up with the in combat side of things, there is still even getting to where the mage is. Think about it this way, if you are hunting a mage, that isn’t a 1 minute invis thing, that’s days of stalking and finding info, days you could be completely invisible for, no one ever knowing you were there at all. In my eyes I would rather have that as a rogue, than something that is only a minute which could be helpful in combat. Also, with it reflecting power word kill, it shouldn’t be able to send it back, as that’s an insta kill against an enemy mage as they wouldn’t gets save either. Kinda destroys combat at that point. Maybe just don’t send those spells back.
Understood. Thank you again for the input.
Happy to help :))