Moving away from CSR

Card Advice

I've had my CSR since May 2018 but with the fee increase, and mostly the anticipation of spending less in travel/dining this upcoming year or two (I'm guessing ~ $6,500 per year) I'm looking to move away from my CSR - which I've loved for the past two years.

My question is, should I just downgrade to the CSP - I'm unclear if I'm eligible in May this year when its been 24 months since my bonus in 2018 (I know the rule recently changed to 48, but does that apply here?). If I cannot get the CSP SUB, I'm interested to hear which card I should go for. The WF propel and AMEX Gold seem to be this subs common recommendation, but I'd be interested to hear any thoughts/suggestions. Alternatively, since I'm already a fan of the UR points, should I just downgrade to the CSP regardless and forgo any SUB? Thanks for any suggestions!

​

FYI

  • Current cards: (list cards, limits, opening date)
    • Citi Dividend MasterCard: $11,00 limit, February 2012
    • Chase Freedom: $6,000 limit, December 2015
    • AMEX Cash Magnet: $16,500 limit, June 2016
    • Chase Sapphire Reserve: $ $10,000 limit, April 2018
    • Chase Freedom Unlimited: $3,800 limit, April 2019
  • FICO Score: 778
  • Oldest account age: 7 years, 10 months
  • Chase 5/24 status: 2/24
  • Income: $60,000
  • Average monthly spend and categories:
    • dining $200
    • groceries: $200
    • gas: $90
    • travel: $250
    • other: $100
  • Open to Business Cards: Not really, but I'm not sure the pros/cons
  • What's the purpose of your next card? Travel
  • Do you have any cards you've been looking at? WF Propel, AMEX Green/Gold
  • Are you OK with category spending or do you want a general spending card? Prefer category

Posted Jan 23, 2020, 9:42 PM UTC

17
VoxBozKnowledgeable•

My question is, should I just downgrade to the CSP - I'm unclear if I'm eligible in May this year when its been 24 months since my bonus in 2018 (I know the rule recently changed to 48, but does that apply here?).

The 48-month rule pertains to getting a SUB, which you never get when you downgrade anyhow. You can downgrade now.

I don't recommend the CSP, it makes no sense for you. I'd look into the WF Propel+ Amex BCE. The Gold only makes sense here if you can use the credits well.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
HazardMagicOP•

Yes I think you’re right. A lot of my travel is NY/NJ transit so having just realized that the travel isn’t general travel, I think Amex gold makes zero sense.

WF propel and Amex BCE seems like the obvious solution, thanks

1
Unixobject•

I would downgrade based on the travel spend indicated

1
pmo2408•

If you really spend $450 monthly on travel and dinning, then I’d say you’re fine.

$550 AF - $300 travel credit (flight, Uber, hotel etc) = $250.

If you value TSA pre check or global entry, take off $20 of that annual fee. $230

If you redeem your points through the Chase travel portal, the rewards become 4.5% from this card alone (1.5 x 3), and amplify your other cards (2.25% CFU, 7.5% CF) again in the Chase travel portal.

So spending on this card alone for you is breaking even.

$230 / 0.045 = $5,100.

$450 monthly dining and travel x 12 months -$300 travel credit = $5,100.

No better card for traveling and you’re justifying the AF. Not to mention the Lyft Pink membership and the DoorDash membership if you value those at all. Priority pass in select airports.

Edit: now if you don’t use Chase travel portal, don’t value the other perks, then maybe not. You’d have to spend $8333.33 for the 3% benefit which WFP does the same thing with no AF.

CSR already paid for itself for me with a flight cancellation I was fully refunded. I use it for one trip a year and for bars / restaurants / lyft / Uber / hotels instead of the Uber Visa.

1
HazardMagicOP•

Yeah I like the chase travel portal but honestly the ability to transfer points to all the travel partners is one of the best perks imo.

I’m finding it very difficult to think about life outside of the ultimate reward points system since it seems a lot better than others

1
pmo2408•

Yeah good point, even better value if you play it right. I’ve seen posts on here about 7 cents per point

1