Wondering how others react to Nfamily's expressions of love when you don't feel much towards them.
My Nmom has a a very revisionist view of what type of mom she was to me growing up, including thinking we were closer and had a deeper relationship than what was true. I lived with my dad for years after she left him when I was a teen. I left home right after graduating to be in the military, met my spouse and moved away to a different state almost 2 decades ago. Since then she has burned bridges with pretty much everyone due to her negative views and attitude. She has shown the same towards me and my spouse, having stages where she would judge our lives and espouse perceptions of mistreatment. Given her lack of emotional stability and narcissistic nature I rarely let her into any aspect of my life on more than a surface level because the rare time I opened up was turned against me or made to be about herself. As such, for years I have established a very basic and polite demeanor with her, keeping all conversations surface level and not giving her much insight into my life.
I don't have her visit often and my only texts to her are occasional pictures of her grandkid and a description of how the kiddo is doing. Thing is when she visits she says "I love you multiple times" a day at random times which I only say back once or twice and without much emotion. I go out of my way to avoid her physical proximity because I feel no affection for her and because honestly I find her gross due to lack of self care that has resulted in her rotted teeth, bad skin, and untrimmed dandruff hair. Last time she was here she finally goes "I want a hug, I don't get hugs from anyone anymore" (because she alienated everyone by being an asshole) and came up to me resulting in me basically doing a "there there" pat on her back. Thankfully she hasn't pushed physical closeness more than that instance.
The biggest thing she does that drives me crazy is that she texts me every so often in the morning and say things like "I love you," "love you all," sometimes every few days. This usually happens when I haven't texted her a picture in awhile. Thing is I feel absolutely no love for her, I'm neutral towards her emotionally at best and disinterested at worst. I'd love to tell her to stop texting me that stuff in the morning but telling her "hey I don't love you cut out the attempts at closeness" would not end well for either of us. My response has been to ignore the texts for the most part, send a pic of her grandkid, or the occasional heart emoji sent back.
I'd love to know how some of you react when an Nfamily member expresses/wants affection, what do you do or say in cases where outright telling the person you don't feel affection towards them isn't the best option?
Posted Jan 24, 2020, 2:15 PM UTC
Ugh, so many feels for this one. TBH I realise now I was grey rocking the declarations as well as the abuse. Particularly because an N episode was often punctuated or followed by: "I do love you really"
I stopped responding at all. (NC many years now). Took them a while to notice. Then I got "sometimes I get the feeling you hate me". I just looked at them. No response. Just went cold and looked at them. I wasn't given them the satisfaction of a response either way. And I'm sure as hell not going to lie because I realised I didn't like them from a very early age, turning into fear, hatred and then, the one they hate most, cold indifference to their existence. They'd genuinely rather I hated them than simply didn't care one way or the other of they were still alive.
Yeah my mom went through the whole gamut of ways to try and engage me from being hateful/angry to me about my life and lack of interaction with her, "woe is me why aren't we close," complaining about me to the one sibling who occasionally speaks to her, and the "I don't understand why you don't want to be around me." I had never heard of the grey rock method until a year ago but I'd say I came around to that method on my own about 7 years ago and that is how my interactions with her have been since an incident where she was visiting us and told me how she didn't like that I'd "changed" from when I was younger, aka self sufficient and confident, unwilling to let her bully me, and because I wouldn't help her money wise after a few years in which she'd ask for money for food AND having lived with us previously without contributing anything for half of a year.
She doesn't push much for emotional closeness and while she complained to my uncle I no longer let her visit unless I say it is ok she now just says things like "grandkid is growing so fast" when i showed her pics. I though having a kid might make her a bit more mellow but I had to stop her visits because between my baby shower and kid's first birthday she came to visit five times and didn't help during the shower or when I had an emergency c-section and was a burden, and during the subsequent visits she did nothing to help us around the house with the kiddo and only paid scant attention to her and treated our house like a relaxing vacation spot while being her usual negative self. I'm like you in that I am indifferent to what goes on in her life because it's her fault her life has turned out the way it has and hence why I can't lie and text "love you back."