If salvation comes from being born again, wouldn't pre-reformation Christians be damned?
Probably a better question for r/Christianity, but I'd rather ask here.
This is something I've always wondered; no idea if it's historically correct.
Since Martin Luther reformed the doctrines of the Catholic Church (salvation through the church), wouldn't the new definition (salvation through Jesus) damn everyone to hell that lived prior to this revelation?
Asked another way, wouldn't most of the Christians that lived from 500-1500 AD technically be lost souls since they didn't know about the new doctrines?
Edit:
Not trying to make sense of Christianity, just wondering if this would be a valid point to make to Christians
Edit:
I guess what I’m getting at is that the main difference between Protestants and Catholics is the Old School vs Default Evangelical position (on salvation) They have been killing each other for centuries; they don’t believe the other is going to heaven.
Thus, if evangelicals are convinced on this point, they should have to concede that every Christian that died prior to learning about the Jesus method is damned to hell - that is if they insist on claiming that any Christian prior to 1500 AD was going to be in heaven.
I suppose I just like the idea of deflating the 2,000 year claim of Christian lineage.
Edit:
What I’m hoping for in asking this is to gain any kind of historical insight about this argument. I’ve had this idea for 20 years but in all of my studies I haven’t come across anything to illuminate my understanding.
I feel like if I make this argument, I should at least have some kind of evidence rather than rely on a vague understanding that it happened sometime in the first 500 years.
Have some Christians always believed in the Jesus method going back to Paul, or did that legit not happen till Luther?
We know salvation was obviously different at the time of the Reformation, but Evangelicals will claim that the early Christians believed exactly as they do based on Paul’s epistles.
Without going down the rabbit hole of explaining how we know early Christians were probably most similar to Eastern Orthodox...
I’m not going to try arguing that point with a Fundamentalist, but
TL;DR - there must be some empirical information documenting when the salvation through church doctrine started and at when it came to dominate “Christendom” in the first millennium. I know that some of the best intellectual ex-theologians are on this sub so I suspect someone actually has some insight.
Posted Jan 25, 2020, 1:17 AM UTC · edited