I'm not that great at UI/UX, I'm looking for some advice on a component on my application.

You can see the interface in question here:

https://imgur.com/a/RLDqcOK

This UI is used to define a data structure. This is an object that has buffer and sources properties. The sources property is a list of objects with dimensions and a name.

The cog on the left of each "data type" is a dropdown with a bunch of different options to change the data type and various other things. It also has 4 items for you to do the following things: 1. Configure the data type (set min, max, whole number?, validation stuff) 2. Set the default value for the data type 3. Set which input is used to edit the data type. You see Textbox, Table, etc above. 4. Change the properties for the chosen input. The label, columns, colors, icons, etc.

I want to move some if not all of the four functions above outside of the menu - so you see them in this view. I want to reduce the number of clicks since these things are done very frequently when your configuring, it would reduce many clicks as you are defining all the parts of your type. I've thought about icons, but they might feel like too much. I want minimal noise added - but somehow still clear that the user can click on something and change it. I'm not that great at this stuff (see picture above) so if anyone has any ideas they would be greatly appreciated.

Posted Jan 25, 2020, 5:24 PM UTC

010
matulka•

I may be misunderstanding the mock up, but it seems like the object you are configuring and the options that belong to it seem hard to distinguish from each other at the moment.

I would maybe suggest have the UI focus more on distinguishing the object being configured to be more prominent. And having the configurations kind of acting as socketing into the object.

The "sockets" could be added via some kind of menu on the object being configured. That why you could configure the individual options on the object without cluttering the screen with all the other options for the other "sockets" at the same time.

Main takeaway: focus the UI on the object being configured and allow the user to socket in options for said object. That way you can be more granular to configure each option and it can guide the user a bit more.

I hope that's what your looking for?

2
ejbredabre•

which platform are we talking about here? is this web UI or touch-based interface or it should work on both?

1
travisjd2012•

Not trying to be mean but you're probably not going to get the best advice for free on Reddit, maybe consider hiring a UX consultant?

0
[deleted]•

I think you’re totally right. It’s like asking a dev to build your site for free. UI/UX is extremely valuable, honestly, more valuable than development. I’m a developer and respect the amount of time and mental anguish designers go through to make something look amazing, intuitive, and work REALLY well with an overall flow.

Sorry, but not sorry. If you’re working on a project for a client, do yourself a favor and have a partner that is a designer, and include that into the cost. Make life great for the both of you.

If you’re trying to get free help, get an account on dribbble.com and get your inspiration from there.

1
DaCush•

It is not like asking a dev to build your site for free lol. That can take 100s of hours. This takes 30 seconds.

1
[deleted]•

You’re just proving my point in the disrespect of designers. You think it is a quick and easy job obviously. Just go design your site in 30 seconds and see how shitty it is.

0
DaCush•

.......I’m a designer too bud. I know how long it can take to design a site. Usually longer than it takes me to code it, much longer (usually I say as long as it’s a static site and not a full fledged application) if I’m making my own icons and graphics. What the hell does this have to do with designers or developers? And yet again your point makes absolutely no sense. “Giving advice” takes 30 seconds. It’s not the same as asking someone to design your site or develop your site for free. It’s called asking advice.

1
DaCush•

Maybe he/she is working on a side project for fun and not trying to spend money on something they aren’t trying to make money off of. Maybe they are trying to get better at UI/UX and is simply looking for advice to improve? And I don’t understand why you and others think that Reddit is not a good place for advice. Is it possible that you will get bad advice from someone inexperienced? Definitely. But there’s also a good chance you’ll get good advice and that advice will be at the top with the most upvotes.

1
travisjd2012•

They can ask all they want but you see what happened.

1
DaCush•

I saw he/she got some good advice from the top comment. Yes, there wasn’t a lot of advice given but you should expect that from a sub that isn’t that active. And I do agree that they shouldn’t expect to get professional advice but that’s just it, they should expect that. Thing is, this is a UI discussion forum so it makes sense to post that here unless the rules are against it and it’s never a bad thing to get advice from other people.

What I’m saying is, why not just tell them what you think or leave it be if it’s not against the rules? All he/she is asking for is your advice/opinion.

1