r/bicycling•
pathug

An idea for googlemaps's bike route function: Would it be possible to calculate the average incline or elevation change for a route?

I noticed that the estimated times google gives for a route generally assume a speed of about 12mph, but I want to know how much climbing I'll be doing. Going from south Austin to downtown for example takes only about 20 minutes, but the return trip can take me about 3x longer, due to the unavoidable hilliness. Sometimes a more direct route can take longer because certain roads are steeper than those on longer routes. I bike for transportation and exercise is simply a side-benefit, so I'm always looking for the flattest, shortest routes. Is there a way I could suggest this idea to Google, or is there perhaps another site I could use?

Posted Jan 2, 2011, 4:15 AM UTC

1622
[deleted]•

RideWithGPS.com uses the google map interface but uses elevation data from uploads (I think). I find it to be easier to use than MapMyRide.

9
pathugOP•

this is exactly what I've been looking for. Thanks!

3
officedepotColnago Master X-Tra Lite•

I just signed up today and discovered my iPhone app contained much more data that was displayed. Thanks for linking this site.

1
Pinot911Rock Lobster, Presidio CX & Salsa Spearfish•

I'm not positive where their elevation data is from, but they have up to two sources: 1) their primary source, 2) your GPS track data. If you're just drawing a route, obviously only #1 is used, if you're using an uploaded GPS track you can chose either.

1
natrius•

According to the blog post that announced the biking directions feature, it already tries to avoid hills.

7
omgplsno•

But I'm out searching for hills...

2
pathugOP•

thanks!

1
Odd_Bloke•

http://bikeroutetoaster.com/ is also pretty good. It'll let you use the OpenStreetMap route finder (though you can use the Google one), which will sometimes include cycle paths that Google doesn't (though this is probably more useful for me, as I live in a part of the world that Google doesn't think contains cyclists :p).

3
champsLitespeed Blue Ridge, Trek 5200, misc.•

As cyclists are known to say, HTFU (harden the fuck up).

Fine, the correct expression is KISS. I see where you're coming from and I have a little background in riding Austin, but it's not worth it. Even if the distance and complexity are favorable, the advantage is minimal at best. Not only that, you'll be safer on the primary routes. Grow some climbing legs, you won't regret it.

1
pathugOP•

I've got climbing legs from riding all over Austin for years, but I don't have climbing lungs. I was simply curious about both whether there was a way to map elevation and grade changes (got my answer on that one and I thank all of you who helped thereby) and whether it makes much difference. I've always felt it makes a big difference, but maybe you're right in that it's not worth the trouble.

1
taonzenCannondale: 1983 ST500 & 2008 Synapse 5 Alloy•

Living in New England, I agree that growing climbing legs is important. But maybe I'm missing something - why is the primary route safer?

FWIW, I don't commute by bike; it's mainly just for exercise. But I do use it for transportation when I can, and in my area, I try to stay off the main roads, especially riding through town.

1
champsLitespeed Blue Ridge, Trek 5200, misc.•

Now that my inbox loads...

I'm not saying you should get out on the MoPac, but as a subset of "anything," drivers are more likely to be attentive on primary routes. They also tend to have a wider berth, like a shoulder, and fewer doors to worry about, since there's not much parking.

1
[deleted]•

use mapmyride
or grow some climbing legs

0
pathugOP•

I can climb, but no matter how good I am at climbing, going up a steep hill is always going to take more time than a flatter one. I'm trying to get from place to place in the shortest amount of time possible. This means I need not only to climb unavoidable hills quickly, but to find the flattest, shortest, route possible.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
pathugOP•

ridewithgps had a better elevation function, but thanks, unwarranted patronization aside. I think you're misinterpreting my intention here (or trolling a bicycle forum). I'm not trying to improve my cycling ability. As a non-motorist, my bike is the most convenient form of transportation available to me (almost always faster and far more reliable than our crappy bus system). I love riding my bike and it's great that it not only transports me, but also makes my legs stronger, but even if I were the fittest, fastest hill-climbing cyclist of all time, I would still prefer to go downhill, because going faster saves time. If you had to get from point A to point B in the least amount of time possible, would you not seek the route with the least amount of climbing and with the most descent?

6
cvncpuWindsor "THE HOUR" [48/17]•

I'm not trying to start a huge ragefight here, but I think this commenter is just trying to point out that if you're going from point A to point B, the elevation change will be the same, the grade of the hills will change.

Having rode in Austin quite a bit, it's really fun to mash around, but there are some hills that aren't really fun to climb (I'm looking at you MLK and Lamar). The best thing you can do is know about the big ones, and find little side streets that are not as steep.

2