r/factorio•
jaykeith

Anybody know what potential plans there are for Industrial Revolution mod going forward?

Question

I have a private server running this mod with a friend and we love this mod. It's a staple for our experience. The sudden drop of support for the mod is extremely vexing. I wish it had never come out at all so I wouldn't have had the now displeasure of falling in love with it. 4 months and the mod maker just bailed completely without anybody to pass the torch to? /Frustrated rant over.

I did read somewhere that there was some possibility that the code could be continued, but that the graphics would need to be redone because they'd be covered by the license. I don't know all of the legality. Has anybody been able to reach out to Deadlock989 at all or is there any conversation going on anywhere about continuation of the mod? It's a godamn shame to see it just die so suddenly. Talk about a flash in the pan.

Also as a side point, trying to read up on what happened it sounds like he wanted to get paid for the mod and didn't like people streaming? I feel like whatever happened became a giant mess that didn't need to go that way. Why didn't he setup a Patreon? Why did he disable all the rest of his mods? Do. Not. Understand.

Also as far as legality goes, can a creative license really be applied directly to something that depends on another owner's IP? Nothing that Deadlock created can function without the direct consent and reliance on creative property owned by Wube Software LTD. If your own product is essentially a sanctioned modification of another person's IP how can you copyright it? I think that a lawyer could easily make the case that all permitted modifications made to their game are not the sole property of the modifier. I recall Minecraft having a similar issue with some of their mod makers with the villages, and it was a big problem for a while. Can't remember what happened though.

Anyways just throwing this stuff out there because I'm very interested in seeing this mod get carried over to future updates and it's absolutely frustrating to see this piece of art get thrown into public view only to be yanked away completely for god knows why.

EDIT: Also here is a link to the mod itself for the curious: https://mods.factorio.com/mod/IndustrialRevolution

Posted Jan 27, 2020, 9:02 PM UTC · edited

4450
AkronSnapeSmart Inserter Cosplay•

A while ago, it was listed as 'Depricated' and the page was blank. Now the page isn't blank, and it says "Will consider updating to 0.18 Stable"

24
jaykeithOP•

This is amazing news. I was looking at it just yesterday and it said Depricated. Hopefully he comes around.

11
AkronSnapeSmart Inserter Cosplay•

I think he will. Too much time and energy went into making it to let it die.... (right?)

15
jaykeithOP•

Right! It's pretty obvious that he put a lot of effort into everything. I mean even the art assets alone are impressive. It's very professional. I can't go back to vanilla after using his mod and I'm too hooked on the systems to force myself onto another overhaul. I guess I'll just play it till I can't anymore.

3
AkronSnapeSmart Inserter Cosplay•

There's still other big mods: Bobs, Angles, Kastorio, and Psy if you really want to hate your life

2
Pazcoo•

The FAQ actually says now:
"Why no 0.18.x version?

I'm not supporting 0.18 experimental. When 0.18 stable comes out, I'll decide whether I want to update for that."

10
AkronSnapeSmart Inserter Cosplay•

Close enough

3
TfGuy44•

Sweet! Now where can we throw money to make this happen?

2
wewladdies•

He seems like the type that is unable to take people being shitty (which, on the internet, is sadly extremely common)

My theory is he got burnt out by people being overly critical on his work, and while he initially intended on passing on the code for someone else to manage, the response to his "Im quitting" announcement drew enough negative messages he got frustrated and withdrew full support out of spite.

22
jaykeithOP•

I can totally understand the not wanting to deal with shitty people on the internet. I guess I can only say that I wish he'd just not care what most other people thought about it. And the truth is, so he had over 100k downloads. Let's say 5% of those people didn't like it (5,000 people), and 2% of those people cross-sectioned with negative experience and complete assholes and also willing to say something, which is around 100 people. So if 100 people get in your face on the internet and you as the mod maker have 100 totally negative experiences I can totally see the burnout. But what you're not seeing is the 95,000 people who either are enjoying the mod in peace or are indifferent or whatever. Even Skyrim doesn't have 95% approval.

All I'm trying to say is, his experience was almost certainly a statistic with inevitable complainers. And I wish that'd he would roll his eyes and move on. His work speaks for itself and it's very good in my opinion (obviously).

4
wewladdies•

Logically yes, the negative shitters are an inevitability, but it winds up grinding down on you after a while.

I was a guild master of a wow guild for 3 years. I loved 95% of it and loved the majority of my raiders, but the 1 or 2 people you get occasionally that are just insanely horrible to deal with eventually ruins the entire experience for you, especially if you truly do care about your guild. While it took me 3 years to get to the point of wanting to say fuck it and quit, i can only imagine what having thousands of voices criticizing you and being shitty is like.

9
jaykeithOP•

Yes I'm not trying to diminish the actual experience of dealing with shitty people, especially online (usually it's amplified in some form), only that it's unfortunate that what amounts to an inevitability for a successful project became it's simultaneous demise.

3
RepairmanSki•

My take appears that they were the unfortunate recipient of stridently worded 'suggestions' about what their mod should/shouldn't do.

I think it's a combination of IR being so good and highlighted in the FFF post that it attracted many people who wouldn't normally have been exposed or self-selected for the experience. Paraphrasing here but the gist as stated by Deadlock was that they "built the mod (they) wanted to play" and that the vehemence of some of the negative responses were a bit overwhelming.

Additionally, I never saw anything remotely like "I wanna get paid". If anything it was more like "You can't earn off my 1000+ hours of effort," which I respect. Others definitely did not.

As far as updating the mod, you can mark it 0.18 compliant to get it to (attempt) to load. You will then get several prompts about what fails after that. Basically, there were changes to the burner-generator prototype that you'll need to make corrections on. If you can figure it out, hooray, back in business.

There are other undocumented fixes that require less interaction on your part but, if you love it like you say, you'll figure it out :D

14
DomenicDenicola•

A perspective I don't see being shared a lot here is the practical one.

Licenses aren't magic. They can't make you do things, in and of themselves. Courts can make you do things. Hosting services can make you do things. But licenses do not.

So a restrictive license (like CC BY-NC-ND) is not a magic spell that prevents anyone from forking the mod and redistributing the fork, bitmaps and all. It doesn't prevent you from making money off of Twitch streams that use the mod. Instead, the license is something that the author can use, if they choose to sue you, to attempt to get damages or actions imposed by a court. Assuming equally-skilled lawyers on either side, I'd imagine the license would mean that the author wins in court. Maybe they can also convince hosting services to take down any forks/streams, either by pointing at the license, or by some other legal means short of a court trial.

IANAL, and I don't have any suggestions about what people should do. But I get a bit tired of the magical thinking and theorycrafting around licenses. Is X "software" covered under the "software license"? Is Y a "derivative work"? Is Z a "technical modification necessary"? Who knows. Lawyers could give you informed guesses to how a judge would rule on these questions, informed by case law. (Although from what I understand the case law on software licenses is pretty small.) But in the end these things don't cache out in some platonic ideal interpretation we come up with on internet forums. They cache out in court.

8
entrigant:nuke:•

It's unclear what point you are trying to make. Practically all contracts and law work this way. E.g. where I live I'm allowed to use lethal force if I have legitimate cause to fear for my own life. What constitutes legitimate cause? The courts will ultimately decide that. Do I care in the moment when I feel that fear? Not really.

All you are seeing here is people trying to act in good faith which most people will try to do. OP is asking for advice. Is there a way to achieve their goal while abiding by the spirit of the terms under which the mod author declared or can it be argued that the mod author was acting in bad faith negating the need to reciprocate. This kind of discussion is good and perfectly normal in healthy communities and societies. It's an indication that people generally want to do the right thing and respect the rights and wishes of other people.

So why are you so "tired" of it?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
LordOfSwans•

My thoughts exactly.

I'd love to see the lawyer who will take on this case of "he stole my doot". And then the lawsuit that forces the doot stealer to what, pay damages on a thing that was distributed for free and is not worth anything... On top of that, courts in the US can fine you but can't compel you to pay, so even if damages/fines are awarded, it's still extremely unlikely anyone but a bunch of lawyers would get paid.

It's doubly ironic that it seems the mod creator stopped support because they didn't like the community reception (which is fair imo), yet that same community is aggressively upholding said creators wishes (despite reataliation being exceedingly unlikely) to have it die.

Maybe this is why the mod page says something like "will consider .18 update".

0
entrigant:nuke:•

On top of that, courts in the US can fine you but can't compel you to pay

I'm guessing you've never had the privilege of somebody showing up at your door with a Sheriff to collect court ordered damages? :)

4
LordOfSwans•

Technically illegal but to be fair it's still done. Also different states have different laws.

In your case, what was the outcome? Did they put you in jail, steal you stuff and sell it?

-1
kitty-dragoncombinatorio•

Nothing that Deadlock created can function without the direct consent and reliance on creative property owned by Wube Software LTD.

It can. Do a clean-room reimplemenation of factorio with the same API, then that mod will still work on it, without involving anything owned by Wube. It is not a "sanctioned modification", it is a product in its own right.

Imagine windows-only software. Can it function without windows? Is it considered an IP? Same thing here.

Other games may restrict mod licenses (to which modders agree by publishing to modportal or by accepting EULA when using the game itself), factorio at this point in time does not.

7
jaykeithOP•

Aw I see. Well there you have it then. I think I was grasping at straws more than anything else. Thanks for the reply though I appreciate it.

1
kitty-dragoncombinatorio•

I believe a straw is there: create a separate mod (set of diffs will probably qualify) that patches IR incompatibility.

And you can publish your new mod as it is yours (can't include anything from IR in it, but you can use IR as a dependency which user downloads separately).

Clean-room reimplementation is of course the best, although most time consuming solution here.

3
ItsKirbyTime•

IANAL, but I'll throw out a couple observations I've had about this whole thing:

1. CC BY-NC-ND is a very odd choice for a software license. The IR mod also includes original artwork, etc., but it also contains software. The parts of IR which would need to be updated for 0.18 are the software parts. The OSI doesn't include CC BY-NC-ND in its list of open source software licenses. The intent of the CC BY-NC-ND authors was to provide a license for works which express an opinion (like an essay), and therefore should not be modified. CC BY-NC-ND doesn't really contain much language that's specific to software.

2. CC BY-NC-ND contains this language:

The Licensor authorizes You to exercise the Licensed Rights in all media and formats whether now known or hereafter created, and to make technical modifications necessary to do so.

If I were to perform a straightforward "port" of IR from 0.17 to 0.18, does that constitute a "technical modification"? I think it might. Further, copyright law generally (setting aside which jurisdiction is applicable here) requires that, in order for a modified work to be considered an "adapted" material, some creative expression, some original idea from the modifying author, go into the modification. Porting a mod from one Factorio version to the next, arguably, doesn't have that element. (See also: why CC BY-NC-ND is a weird license to use for software.)

3. Distributing derivative works is not permitted, but what if I were to create some piece of software which can itself modify the mod, and let everyone use that? CC BY-NC-ND permits others to produce adapted materials, so long as they do not distribute it. Suppose I were to write a generic "Factorio Mod 0.17 to 0.18" conversion tool. That is surely permissible, and is 90% of what the community is asking for (running the tool would be a little burdensome, as would not having mod portal support). What if I were to just create a patch file which brings the mod up to date? Am I permitted to distribute that?

Perhaps these observations will be of use to someone feeling more litigious than I am.

5
RUST_LIFE•

Considering the mod conversion tool would likely be a find/replace script that would work on any mod with whatever issues IR has (and just so happens to perfectly work on IR) I don't think there's any reason to think that wouldn't be allowed.

Then again I can buy or make a crowbar, and quite legally use it to break my own padlock off my shed door...but not yours...

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
whoami_whereami•

Well, I think Deadlock wrote somewhere that he's mostly concerned (and protective) about the graphical assets being used by someone else commercially (even if "only" for monetized let's play videos or so) and not so much the code itself. At some point I think he was working on splitting code and graphics into two separate mods, so that he could release the code under a less restrictive license allowing others to make modifications and bugfixes (and publish them), but I don't think he ever finished that.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
omgredditgotme•

Unless you convince the mod author to change the license then no one can update it.

It is fairly easy to do yourself. I don't think much was changed that breaks mods in 0.18 other than the fact the the versions no longer match.

4
[deleted]•

Would you be allowed to distribute a python script which automatically updated it?

6
Dregre•

Considering said script would be "decompress, change factorio-version to 0.18 and compress/delete original" you'll probably be fine. Mind that some mods do break on conversation, Angels mods being one.

6
RUST_LIFE•

Ir breaks too. Something about fluids. I just reverted back to .17

1
Silari82More Power->Bigger Factory->More Power•

The license that it's under doesn't allow anyone to modify and then distribute it. Not sure why anyone would say the code could be continued but not the images, as the entire mod is under the same license. You CAN download the mod and update it to 0.18, but you can't give that modified code to anyone else. Unless he changes the license terms, it's dead. Being made for a game that someone else made has 0 relevance on that.

4
_aD5th Lv. Tech, Grif's Green Grocers•

I am very firmly against using someone's art in ways that are contrary to their wishes, and trying to wriggle out of it on technicalities is unethical.

4
Factorio_Poster:iron-ore:•

He requested the mod thread closed, so it sounds like he's legitimately trying to kill it. People also mentioned in the official thread that he has said he wouldn't actually go after people legally, although you'd have to rely on his word on that.

Someone could probably reverse engineer it without looking at the code and create a similar mod with independent graphics, but that would require a lot of work and a fair bit of mod-writing talent. The graphics were also a huge selling point, as they were very unique and high-quality.

3
kitty-dragoncombinatorio•

People also mentioned in the official thread that he has said he wouldn't actually go after people legally, although you'd have to rely on his word on that.

He's not making any profit from it. Other people won't make any profit from it. So no need to rely on his word here, since there's no monetary damages, there's nothing to sue people over.

The graphics were also a huge selling point, as they were very unique and high-quality.

Graphics are the hardest part, anything else can probably be reimplemented relatively quickly (since idea itself is already out there, and it cannot be covered by a copyright).

2
Factorio_Poster:iron-ore:•

He's not making any profit from it. Other people won't make any profit from it. So no need to rely on his word here, since there's no monetary damages, there's nothing to sue people over.

IANAL, but wouldn't this be eligible under DMCA copyright violations and subject to up to $25,000 in legal restitution? I don't believe any of those kids who got sued by the RIAA back in the 2000s were making money off of downloaded music either...

3
kitty-dragoncombinatorio•

IANAL, but wouldn't this be eligible under DMCA copyright violations and subject to up to $25,000 in legal restitution?

Maybe. What jurisdiction are you talking about? In any case, living in another country protects from these kinds of lawsuits quite well.

And fines never to my knowledge happen without prior cease/desist letter (to which one should of course comply by moving stuff to less sueable location).

kids who got sued by the RIAA

I would assume that copyright owner was making some money off it, and those figures were 10x inflated (they always are) and used as damages.

But for factorio mods you can't really claim loss of profit if there isn't any attempts to make one.

2
RUST_LIFE•

I made money selling cds in the 90's... Barely covered the blanks, but still. I was probably an outlier tho. Most people downloaded stuff for personal use only.

1
triffid_hunter•

since there's no monetary damages, there's nothing to sue people over.

Copyright law doesn't only give damages for lost income, there's also significant fines for unauthorised copying even in the absence of financial loss by the IP owner - up to $125,000 per infraction last time I checked.

3
24610162642•

You could always just not update the server that is running the game, the mod seems very stable from what I've seen of it. You would miss out on future additions to the Vanilla engine but it seems like that would be a small price to pay to continue using something that you enjoy in its current state.

3
jaykeithOP•

Yes that is the current plan. I didn't realize how easy it is to port over the mod to newer versions if it's just changing some numbers like has been suggested, but I suspect in the future it will not be so easy. However, I am enjoying it right now so can't really complain too much.

I ran a Minecraft server with 1.7.10 for several years because of the mods that I didn't want to change.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Nefrums2•

This is so sad. He created a brilliant mod with great content. But then he baned content creators from showing his work, and received lots of negative feedback for this and got burned out.

But I guess this is how the game community works. If you try to impose restrictions on the community you will get negative reactions. Even more so if the restrictions are unusual and have hard to understand motivations.

3
entrigant:nuke:•

But then he baned content creators from showing his work, and received lots of negative feedback for this

As well he should have, tbh. Peoples opinions differ wildly on this, and nobody has had the balls to demand a court decide one way or the other yet. Some folks see it similarly to showing a full length movie with a commentary voice over, which has been tested and is considered a copyright violation.

However, video games are not movies no matter how badly Kotaku and Polygon wish they were. Games are played. I think a purer form that makes it easier to understand is a board game, so I see it similar to filming a group of people playing a board game. I can't understand how a rational person would consider that a violation of the board game creators copyright. Each and every play through is its own unique creation.

Some folks argue that just the presence of the boards art assets is violation enough, but the video isn't about the art assets. It's not making money off the art assets, and the viewers aren't there to see them. They're there to see the players. The point of the video is the game play itself, the mechanics of it, the strategies employed, the social interactions of the players, etc.

Therefore I get quite upset when game companies try to place copyright strikes on lets players, and I feel the same way if a modder tries it. One of these days the courts will have the final say.

5
Nefrums2•

It is quite unusual that game devs limit content creators from showing of their games. It is free advertising. It is even common for game devs to pay the big content creators to show their games. Twitch even have a bounty system to make this it easy for gave devs to get many streamers to do this.

1
entrigant:nuke:•

True, however what is common is for game devs to feel they have the right to issue copyright strikes. They've used it a few times to remove streamers that don't align with the dev goals in some way, e.g. they don't like the streamers attitude, monetization methods, politics, or the cut of their jib.

I think these have always ended in stalemates so far with nobody trying to push this through courts anywhere.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-3†
LordOfSwans•

This does make you seem like the better person. Well done.

1
omiwrench•

Doing something bad is better than complaining about something bad to you?

-2
tzwaanMOD:artifact: Moderator•

Rule 4: No personal attacks

1