Should I try to reform a family member’s exclusivist beliefs about salvation? And if so, any suggestions of how to do so?

My sister and I grew up in an Evangelical family, and over the years our beliefs have varied significantly.

She has a strong belief of exclusivity which manifests itself in her attitude toward almost everyone else (including many Christians).

I think she genuinely feels that each of these other groups are out to corrupt or destroy true Christianity, and she often raises the point of other groups not being saved as justification for dangerous positions.

She tells me how isolated and alone she feels and expresses her fear about everything that’s attacking her. I’ve been observing her circle of acceptable friends shrink over the past several years. She used to have several people in her life that she considered “liberal” but those relationships disintegrated as her conviction about certain views surpassed her level of tolerance.

Anyways, I’m sure I’m not the first person to experience something like this. I feel like I should try to expand her belief about salvation to at least include most Christians. It seems like this shouldn’t be hard to do but I’ve not succeeded in convincing her that different sects aren’t the evil characters in Revelation.

I have offered to buy her some e-books by interfaith Christians but she was quite opposed to it. I’ve tried appealing to a sense of God’s love and salvation having a larger tent for many faiths that believe in God but she wasn’t interested.

On a positive note she has been listening to Ben Shapiro so she’s been exposed to more inclusivity relatively speaking. I respectfully asked her how she could listen to a Jew in light of her views; there were several seconds of silence, followed by “good question.” So I definitely think there’s hope. I suspect that the best argument I could make would have to be a Biblical or theological one for her to accept it but I’m not really sure what would be best considering where she’s at. Or maybe I should just leave it alone?

Posted Jan 28, 2020, 4:55 AM UTC

229
Loading comments…