Work-in-progress cave tile graphics for my hobby project. The walls may need a little touch-up maybe?

Posted Jan 28, 2020, 8:37 AM UTC
86

Posted Jan 28, 2020, 8:37 AM UTC
Walls definitely need changing. Your floor is quite bare, a rock here or there and the grass is also moderately simple. Your walls should be about the same. In general those walls are far too busy, it's hard to look at
I agree, they pop a little much with the strong contrast. I'll try adjusting it, along with breaking up the monotonous pattern.
Almost there, a tad too "grid-ey", cave walls are always annoying like that. you can break the vertical strips of rocks if you add a few well placed bigger rocks shifted left or right a bit. Also having less of a contrast and keeping the whites only for highlight rims would help.
Just my 2 cents, these could work if it's in line with your game's artistic style.
I'll try breaking up the vertical lines. I have another rocky tile set with more variations, but I think it may need some adjustment to avoid banding too. I did wonder about the contrast - perhaps a few color palette variations are in order.
Another thing I've noted is that the bottom of the rock wall looks a bit odd in places where the ground is a flat color, as if it's a straight line cutoff. Some shading or smaller rocks to break up the horizontal line is probably in order.
Thanks for the tips!
I'm struggling with the same things lol
One thing that helped me is looking at screenshots/tilesets of games that had cave walls similar to what I am aiming for (I opted for Lufia-like).
I have the same problems with the top/bottom.. one option I though of is to add fringe tiles at the bottom to simulate rock formations that lead into the wall (like pointy rocks piles up at the bottom - it's hard to explain in words).
Anyways, have fun :)
Definitely inspired by RPGs!
I understand what you mean with fringe tiles - they would work well to smooth out corners here and there too, I think.