Which one of these 2015 published, Viking-themed worker placement games to buy?
[removed]
Posted Jan 28, 2020, 3:23 PM UTC
[removed]
Posted Jan 28, 2020, 3:23 PM UTC
I enjoy both, but for my tastes I prefer Champions of Midgard. I think both Champions and Raiders feel quite different and can see someone owning both. However if you are worried about two games feeling similar to each other you should not bother with Champions of Midgard as it is very similar feeling to Lords of Waterdeep. Both games (CoM and LoW ) involve collecting "fighters" to go on quests. CoM is less deterministic as you have to roll dice for your fighters rather than just turn in the required cubes, but a very very similar gameplay loop.
Raiders on the other hand, feels more like a "point salad" type of game to me. There are many avenues to scoring points (caveat: I never played the base game, only ever with all expansions) combined with the place a worker pull a worker mechanism makes Riders feel less restricted as far as worker placement games go. There's a lot of different strategies to try out and they will change depending on initial setup. In CoM there are different things can aim for, but all of them are involve building up an army you just choose where you attack.
If I was to summarize how each game feels besides the worker placement aspect: Raiders tends to feel like a race to certain things with a bit of tableau building in assembling your raiding team, with a pretty good ability to form and enact a longer term strategy. Champions still has a race feel but a lot more push your luck. There's plenty of ability to mitigate luck of the dice rolls but it costs you time in a game with a set number of rounds. I like games with a decent amount of push your luck, makes things more exciting to me than just running through a strategy, so that's why I prefer Champions.
I own and enjoy both. The only real similarities is the mechanic name "worker placement" and having the "viking" theme. In both cases the worker placement is implemented differently and the games feel mostly different enough.
Hey there, I removed this post.
Personalized game recommendations can be requested in our Daily Discussion and Game Recommendations sticky thread. I'd encourage you to post it there!
There's also the Need Help Finding A Game section in our wiki.
Thanks!
(If you believe this post was removed in error you can request a re-review by messaging the mods.)