The community town tiers
Now that it's been two days i thought i'd share the calculated town tier list from my post. Just as a reminder this is for SoD and not Hota.
I used a weighted average to calculate the tiers of the towns from the number of votes given, you can see the excel sheet here.
There was broad agreement that Necropolis is the de facto strongest town and that Inferno is the weakest town.
I think now might be a good time to actually discuss what makes a town strong. I am not claiming to be an expert or all-knowing, but these are the things i consider.
- The early game: Having a good start is important in all strategy games i've ever played. In homm3 this depends on your starting hero, your starting army and usually the tier 1-3 troops. Conflux has quite possibly the best start in homm3 with sprites/pixies and luna's fire wall being capable of taking on wandering monsters that no other town can do this early in the game. Kyrre is also a hero i love because not only is she amazing in the early game, she transitions really well into the later stages.
- Transitioning: You also got to consider what you're going to be doing after the initial phase, this is where a town such as Necropolis really shines. The necromancy skill lets them "start the end game" day 1 by just doing what you should be doing anyway: Exploring. A town such as Tower suffers here as their tech tree is rather demanding and getting to just mages can be a real problem. Thus they can have problems getting out of the early game.
- The power stack: This is the unit stack that does the work, i am only talking about early-mid here. For necropolis it is usually vampire lords and skeletons. For inferno it's likely to be either demons due to demon-farming or efreets. Rampart uses grand elves and so on. What matters is "ease of access" and power of your important stack.
- Tech tree: Being able to skip buildings is quite powerful. This is where fortress and stronghold gains some power since they can get wyverns and behemoths quite quickly. Castle can in principle get portal of glory early too, but it's very expensive.
- Week growth strength: This is what i'd call a "false indicator". In my experience it is very rare that all players will be able to buy every troop in their town at all stages of the game. What matters is what you can buy and what you want to buy. Castle might have the biggest baddest week growth, but you usually have to pick perhaps 2-3 troops that you want to buy since there simply isn't enough money to go around.
Chime in with your thoughts on what makes a town strong and keep in mind: I didn't construct this tier list, i just looked at the number of votes :)
Posted Jan 28, 2020, 11:03 PM UTC · edited
2022