Will Darkest Dungeon 2 give the option to automate combat?

I think the biggest problem is that Darkest Dungeon is essentially a "solved" game. You can either play the optimal way or not progress. There is no in-between thanks to feature bloat and constant nerfs to everything from the devs. Once you have the RNG minimized, there's very little player interaction or thought. You don't really have many choices to make because the risk-reward of doing something unexpected is so heavy on the risk that it's not even worth it. Yeah you may have a fully leveled party of 4 wipe thanks to a bad roll, but are you actually able to work around that and learn from it? You're stuck with now having to regrind a group of heroes, probably multiple since you can't have heroes reliably stack quests in a row. The enemies and challenges that they are facing are the same things that you have already been facing during the leveling up process. All that you are cost is pure time, which I do not judge a game's enjoyment on simply an hours-passed basis.

This is why I propose that devs implement the option to automate combat in Darkest Dungeon 2, similar to the Total War games. When presented with an encounter, just show me the combined RNG of an optimal battle and give me the option to click that. Enemy moves are essentially random, though some will show preference to targeting marked characters and marks are also random. This will save me and other players a lot of time and would be fairly easy to program.

Now some people will say that this removes a core aspect of the game. So in place of combat, once the player has assembled a team and outfitted them with items, they can be shown a progress bar of the party's trip through the quest. As the bar works its way towards completion, the player is presented with a pair of dice that they can freely roll in the meantime while the narrator reads off a thesaurus.

!This is only about 20% sarcastic. I do genuinely think that feature creep from the expansions and DLC has marred the original design of combat in a way that makes it no longer fun. Hopefully the devs will work to have more cohesive design to player interaction in combat. If I can level up a party that doesn't have upgraded skills or armor through a level 3 dungeon, it should be assumed that I can do that with subsequent parties that do have the upgraded skills and armor. An addition of meaningful player choice outside of combat but still during quests such as sneaking past enemies, setting traps, or solving puzzles would also help keep me engaged beyond just watching numbers on my guys wax and wane.!<

Posted Jan 29, 2020, 3:15 AM UTC · edited

09
TPLuna•

This game does not require anything within 10 miles of optimal for you to win. In fact I would argue the polar opposite, you can play the dumbest, least viable shit and still win without needing much luck.

Also “fairly easy to program” is just... something else. And definitely not correct.

20
LeGweg•

Automate combat ?

This game is based on dungeon crawling. What you think is optimised may be not. This game is all about making the best out of messy situations, and sometimes taking risks. The entire gameplay revolves around fights, knowledge of curios, ennemies, events. The RNG makes sure that you'll have a ton of trouble and shady choices ( many people forgot that you can retreat / abandon quest)

An automated gameplay would focus the action on town upgrade / roster management, and this is another kind of game, not a rogue like.

Maybe what you are looking for is a management game, focused on resources / costs, detached from the combat strategy : and it's fine! Because those games are also awesome.

7
Tadatsune•

I think the biggest problem is that Darkest Dungeon is essentially a "solved" game. You can either play the optimal way or not progress. There is no in-between thanks to feature bloat and constant nerfs to everything from the devs.

I think this is a gross, gross overstatement - though I do share your distaste for some of the more heavy-handed attempts to shut down alternative strategies. Even then, however, as a prolific user of stuns and scouting, I have to admit in retrospective those nerfs were warranted.

! An addition of meaningful player choice outside of combat but still during quests such as sneaking past enemies, setting traps, or solving puzzles would also help keep me engaged beyond just watching numbers on my guys wax and wane. !<

!I could certainly get on board with this.!<

3
GeesomOP•

From what I have seen, the trinkets and effects carried over by the expansions look to essentially trivialize the base game with items and statuses that make vanilla items seem quite modest. This has a major effect on what sort of options are available to the player.

0
Tadatsune•

I don't have Color of Madness, so I can't really comment on that. I don't think that holds true for CC - some of the trinkets are very, very good certainly, but many are not and you aren't going to have access to most of them if you are playing on Bloodmoon (aka Stygian) as you wont have the opportunity to pick them up before you complete your main victory objectives.

I realize that it is conventional wisdom on this board that there is one objectively "optimal" way to construct parties (ie, push direct damage and accuracy), but this is a sentiment I highly disagree with.

2
Donutmelon•

The CoM trinkets are designed to be tradeoffs. They also pretty much force a style of play for some characters. Some trinkets are still kind of ridiculous, however. Like the abomination's.

4
trasci•

I can use the dumbest team in the world and still win consistently, you don't really need some meta strategy to go forward and the fight aren't automated either, if something goes wrong (as usual) you have plenty of room and options to recuperate the situation,what's the point of making the fight autoresolve? You cut 70% of the game that way

2
frandlebibbins•

I only have the base game (+ Shieldbreaker) with no DLCs or mods so I might not have experienced exactly what you're talking about, but I definitely don't play the game as an optimisation-bot. Which is why I'm Occultist Squad and Antiquarian Squad all the way haha. Sometimes I truly screw myself but in the same breath taking risks can really pay off, and therein lies the tension of choice. And most important is being resilient in the face of RNG's fickle ways and prepared to recuperate your team from the very precipice of insanity and death.

However I certainly won't be mad if DD2 had more roster/hamlet management aspects to it as a buffer for the combat.

2
YarHarDiddleyDee•

This isn't a mobile game.

2