Does the community have a list of bike brands to avoid? Or brands they like?

Hi all,

I know I’m asking a general question with a complex answer. I’m just curious if the community has strong opinions on specific brands to avoid or specific brands they love.

e.g., I’ve read some folks on other forums really don’t like State Bicycle Co. for build quality and for delivering packages with missing parts. On the other hand, Raleigh was recommended to me by a local shop but he didn’t tell me why he recommends them.

Lastly, putting this out there in case anyone needs to know before replying, I’m looking at steel frame road bikes specifically.

Any respectful input is appreciated! TYIA

Posted Jan 30, 2020, 8:28 PM UTC

511
lazerdabArgon 18 Ambassador•

State, Public, and the other internet single speed, low-end bikes should be avoided.

Basically, don't buy any bike that you can't buy at a real bike shop and you'll be safe.

That said, there are some quality direct to consumer bike companies sprouting up (Canyon) and it will become the norm before too long. In fact, most mainline bike makers are now offering a semi-direct to consumer option where you buy the bike on their site and pick it up at a local shop.

If you're looking at steel road bikes, All-City, Raleigh, Surly, Masi, Kona, and even some of the big names all offer something.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
jsbisviewtifulOP•

Wow, the GS is what I am considering right now so I truly appreciate that breakdown. You rock, my dude/dudette.

3
peters1023•

At the top Raliegh even offers some Reynolds steel. Tamland is a superb bike, I love mine. I would not touch most of the rest of their offerings tho.

1
jsbisviewtifulOP•

Thank you for all the name drops. I’ll check them all out. What do you ride?

3
lazerdabArgon 18 Ambassador•

Current garage: Argon 18, Giant, Cannondale, Kona, Trek, Bianchi, Fuji.

3
sitdownrando-r•

Generally if it's sold at a local bikeshop, it's ok. (Giant, Trek, Specialized, Bianchi, Scott, Cannondale, etc.)

If it's sold through an online retailer (Amazon) or a department store (Walmart), it's terrible. (Huffy, Schwinn, etc.)

Something like bikesdirect falls somewhere inbetween. (Motobecane, Mercier).

Then you have bespoke manufacturers and straight to consumer models (Canyon, Rose) and these are ok.

Really it just comes down to the quality of parts and the quality of the build. A mechanic will do a better job than a retail employee and better brands will spec better parts.

6
jsbisviewtifulOP•

That’s incredibly helpful info. Thank you. Curious, what do you ride?

3
sitdownrando-r•

Currently I have a Cannondale CAAD10 and a Cannondale Topstone, but I've ridden quality bikes from Trek and Cinelli as well. I've had middling experiences on chromoly bikes from Brooklyn Cycles and a fixed gear I built. I had a miserable experience with a dept. store Schwinn.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BiNumber3•

I absolutely love my motobecane from bikes direct, modern steel frame (double butted Reynolds), but still has old school styled lugged joints.

It originally came with Sram reds too, though I completely swapped everything out on it.

I know it's not the same motobecane from the 80s, but if their other bikes are on par with this one, then I'd have no issue at all buying more from em.

1
commutingtexan•

If you're looking for a steel frame, the Jamis Renegade Expat is absolutely fantastic. By far my favorite bike I've ever owned.

2

This depends a lot on what community you ask.

There's giant and reputable companies like Giant, Trek, Cannondale, and Specialized that make all kinds of bikes.

For mountain biking, people would know things like Santa Cruz, GT, Yeti, and Kona.

For road biking there's the legendary Italian bike manufacturers like Bianchi, Colnago, and Pinarello. There's also European brands like Scott and Canyon that are well known and respected.

For fixed gear riders, there's companies like Cinelli that are well known.

There's a bunch of new wave american manufacturers that make steel frames like All City or Soma. If you're a gravel rider you might know about some niche companies like Bearclaw bikes.

There's also super high end custom shops like Fetska in the Czech Republic. It really depends on what you're into.

2