How plausible is it to have an isolated island with modern technology?
I’m currently building a fantasy world which I intend to use for a series of books. The world has 1990’s technology + magic. But unlike the urban fantasy genre, it will have completely original geography, cultures of people etc.
In this world, I planned to have an island (or acapellago) of approximately 50k people. This island would have absolutely no contact with the outside world. As far as they’re concerned, the other continents are inhabitable and there’s no reason to leave (which they can’t even if they try.)
However, the island didn’t develop separately from the outside world. There was a point several decades before the story when a powerful being caused the isolation via a lot of mass memory erasing. Basically, they developed with the rest of the globe so they didn't need to invent everything themselves. But now that they're cut off, they need to sustain it without falling back into the dark ages.
The question is, how plausible is it for a modern island of 50k people to sustain itself with no outside contact? I’m not against using magic to explain things, but I’d prefer to stay as grounded in reality as possible
Lack of trade is one major issue I can think of so far. All of the materials, foods, and animals would need to come from that specific geographic location. All of the factories to produce their clothing, computers, cell phones, cars would also need to be on the island.
The government would need to block incoming radio waves, etc. but this system wouldn’t be perfect. I would expect certain people on the island to be smart/resourceful enough to figure out the outside world exists. This is okay– the blocking only needs to be good enough to fool 99% of the people
Aside from what I've mentioned above, there any other major issues I’m overlooking that would make this idea implausible?
Posted Feb 2, 2020, 1:13 AM UTC