Since circles turn in all directions at once, how is the saying "righty tighty lefty loosey" helpful?

Posted Feb 3, 2020, 2:57 PM UTC

079
un0m•

Since circles turn in all directions at once

I fail to see how this makes sense.

8
ikvasagerOP•

When you look at the head of the screw when you tighten it (clockwise), the top of the screw is turning right while the bottom is turning left.

So what good is the saying?

0
LurdMcTurdIII•

You are either turning the screwdriver to the right or the left. Not both.

4
ikvasagerOP•

But this isn't correct. Any time you TURN something, part of it is going left, part is going right. (and part is going "up" and "down") It's literally how circles work.

0
LurdMcTurdIII•

And yet your hand is only turning to the left

3
un0m•

But the screw does not "turn in all directions at once".

It's called finding an interesting way to remember something.

2
ikvasagerOP•

Did you read what I just wrote? Any time you turn a cylinder, part of it is going left and part of it is going right.

So I repeat...what good is the saying?

0
un0m•

Because no one thinks like that when they turn a screw. They just want to know what direction to turn the fucking screwdriver.

4
ikvasagerOP•

Wouldn't clockwise and counter-clockwise be much more useful and fool-proof?

5
LordSarranghar•

Yes, but it would be harder to remember. It would be more useful tho

3
ikvasagerOP•

I think clockwise=tighten is pretty simple.

1
JAG_666•

You could try clocky locky, but with more and more clocks becoming digital, many children might not have a full grasp on clockwise in the future

2
ikvasagerOP•

This is a fair point. But I'm guessing that "clockwise" will stick around long after analog clocks are gone. People will wonder "where the heck did that come from", but will understand what it means.

1
Throwafterthispost•

How do you understand clockwise but not that right and left begin at 12 o'clock when looking down on whatever you are tightening or loosening?

4
HcVitals•

If you don’t know your rights and lefts then screws are the least of your worries

3
ikvasagerOP•

But which way is "right" and "left"?

You are turning a cylinder. No matter which way you turn it part of the cylinder goes left and part goes right.

1
HcVitals•

You simply use your left and right hand as guidance as taught when 4 years old and then you just go left loosey and boom

3
ikvasagerOP•

This makes no sense to me. It never has. That's why I'm asking.

Any time you TURN something, part of it is going left, part is going right. (and part is going "up" and "down") It's literally how circles work.

1
WZPV•

How easy your life must be to try to make “righty righty, lefty loosey” easier to understand.

3
ikvasagerOP•

You don't seem to understand what I'm saying.

When you look at the head of the screw when you tighten it (clockwise), the top of the screw is turning right while the bottom is turning left.

So what good is the saying?

1
WZPV•

Righty tighty, lefty loosey has worked since screws and bolts have been manufactured.

You not understanding the saying refers to 12-o’clock position of the screw or bolt doesn’t mean it isn’t perfectly fine the way it is.

3
ikvasagerOP•

the saying refers to 12-o’clock position

But this is never stated, nor it is obvious to me. It's rotational movement around a center axis. There is no left or right. It moves in literally all directions.

0
WZPV•

Just because it isn’t obvious to you doesn’t mean it isn’t obvious to EVERYONE else.

3
JAG_666•

It’s about your hand holding the screwdriver turning left/right when you’re (un)screwing.

3
ikvasagerOP•

But this isn't correct. Any time you TURN something, part of it is going left, part is going right. (and part is going "up" and "down") It's literally how circles work.

0
JAG_666•

Not with your hand (unless you’re very flexible). You can’t keep turning your hand, so it is not a full circular motion, you stop readjust your hand and turn again. The focus point will turn left or right.

3
ikvasagerOP•

Yes, and every time you do, you are rotating your hand. And rotation is circular motion. There is no left or right. It is all directions at once.

0
JAG_666•

The hand is not circular and attached to your wrist, from that point of focus, it will move in only one direction. Parts of the hand might move in a opposite direction, but the hand as a whole will move in one direction from the wrist.

3
luminushumanus•

Because despite what your implying theres an equal amount of relative forknowledge to explain the sum concept of clock rotation.

I could just as easly ask you where i put 12 on the screw since 12 is top dead center, the same situation arises, and considering the emergance and prevalence of digital clocks over analog, its gonna take as mich time if not more to explain clockwise to a child.

3
ikvasagerOP•

I teach robotics to middle school and high school kids. They all get confused at first about how to tighten fasteners without just guessing. They are always repeating the "righty tighty lefty loosey" saying but they still make mistakes and turn the wrong way 50% of the time. So clearly the saying doesn't help them. Then I tell them..."why not just remember clockwise is tighten"? And they always say something to the affect of "why the heck don't people just say that!?"

Hence my post here.

1
luminushumanus•

I highly doubt the number of times they rotate the wrong direction changes despite that knowledge, considering how often I knowing both, still rotate the wrong way more than one would expect. I watched a seasoned contractor do it yesterday, after both myself and another did the same. All of us more than qualified and knowledgable on the use of screw drivers.

2
ikvasagerOP•

After I tell them clockwise=tighten they make WAY less than the 50% error they used to make.

Why is that so hard for you to accept?

1
luminushumanus•

With out more than ur word, yes.

I dont believe most of this is any more than embelishment and would bet that this happened with one kid, one time.

2
jlkauffman92•

They are referring to the top of the screw/bolt/etc. But it is not helpful when dealing with reverse-threaded screws lol

2
ikvasagerOP•

But which way is "right" and "left"?

You are turning a cylinder. No matter which way you turn it part of the cylinder goes left and part goes right.

2
jlkauffman92•

By "top" i mean when viewing the cylinder from the perspective which makes it appear as a circle. The top of the circle moves to the right to to tighten.

2
Betamax-86•

but it’s a mnemonic designed to help people remember which direction tightens/loosens bolts when they are starting to get a handle on mechanical things

ignoring lefthand threads of course...

2
ikvasagerOP•

But which way is "right" and "left"?

You are turning a cylinder. No matter which way you turn it part of the cylinder goes left and part goes right.

0
luminushumanus•

Because its the implied rotational vector from 0* to 180* in the circle.

2
ikvasagerOP•

And where does 0 start?

0
luminushumanus•

Top dead center

3
ikvasagerOP•

1.) that's not part of the saying 2.) no kid is gonna know what "top dead center" means...your just gonna end up explaining that too

Why not just say clockwise=tighten. done.

0
bm2bynd•

Screws have lines in them so clockwise and counter clockwise would be better to say but righty tighty lefty loosey is easier to remember

2
ikvasagerOP•

But the saying doesn't make any sense.

When you look at the head of the screw when you tighten it (clockwise), the top of the screw is turning right while the bottom is turning left.

So what good is the saying?

1
OOOdragonessOOO•

YOU turn left, your hand turns left. YOU turn the screwdriver left. lefty loosie.

2
ikvasagerOP•

But any time you TURN something, part of it turns left and part of it turns right. It's how circular motion works. Your hand doesn't turn "left". It rotates. And rotation is in ALL directions.

Why don't people seem to understand how circles work?

0
OOOdragonessOOO•

now you're just being obstinate.

3
Betamax-86•

the convention is a point at 12 o’clock starts moving ‘right’ when turned clockwise or ‘left’ if turning anticlockwise

2
ShopAndCraft•

I know this is an old thread and it's been stated but in less than cordial ways but I had issues with this exact thing growing up. I completely understand what you mean when you say a circle turns in all directions at the same time. When you say this you are opening your perspective to consider the nature of a shape. This is not a natural thing to do. This is often what engineers and artists do, though. We first have to get our commenters to also consider the nature of a shape before they will understand what you are talking about. I took quite a few engineering and art classes in high-school and did a lot of thinking about this very topic. The saying is only helpful to those who make 5 primary assumptions about the fastener being interacted with. There are more than 5 but these are the most relevant, I think.

  1. The fastener is oriented in such a away where the "head" is in a plane parallel to your face.

  2. The plane of the head is in-between you and the "end".

  3. Your focus is on the "top" of the plane the head is in. This is also relative to the position of the plane in regards to where it is on the planet. This gets us into the "when in space, which way is up?" dilemma. That is also context that has to be assumed albeit, more easily that where to focus on the head of your fastener.

  4. You are interacting with the fastener from the head.

  5. The faster has standard thread direction.

I always thought it would be easier to say cw and ccw. Then again, this only removes assumption 3 listed here. Even when using cw and ccw you still have to make the other 4 primary assumptions. As long as you know that you have to make these assumptions you can "look" at the fastener mentally to get the correct direction no matter what orientation it is in but it still can take some effort.

I've had to interact with fasteners in every direction, not just where the head is facing me. For instance, if I am looking at the head of a bolt that is through two mating pieces and I'm to put a nut on the bolt and I can only move the nut, then I actually have to turn the nut ccw relative to my face to tighten it.. In a perfect world the head would always face us but we live in a world where we sometimes have to reach up into a metal carcas of dirt and darkness, and with only our sense of touch, feel our way to our fastener and think about which way to turn the fucker, while blind.

Anyway, I hope I gave a somewhat decent response. Many people who were responding were not willing to open up their perspective to see what assumptions one must make in order for the saying to make sense. This is somewhat to be expected though, since these people already were assuming these things and if we assume something, we naturally believe others will assume it as well. It takes practice, education, and effort to understand our perspective is not the only one, everyone sees the world differently, and to consider their view without accepting it as your own. I can't blame someone I don't know for being uneducated. I don't know what kind of life they've had or what they are going through. What a crazy world I was brought to make this comment because you commented on a random pencil I was happy to share about. 😌

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ShopAndCraft•

Hahaha! You're welcome. I enjoy discussing such things on occasion. Yeah, if you pick one up, let me know what you think.

1
blonde_squab•

This. 100%.

-1
ikvasagerOP•

You are literally the only person that agrees with me. I am blown away at the responses here. I cannot fathom how they don't understand the point I am making. It's like I've been transported to an alternate universe where no one speaks my language except you.

2
blonde_squab•

Honestly I think this is a tiny part of the reason i have a lot of problems with right and left. North south east west never change but right and left is all about perspective.

1