Bloomberg anti-gun ad draws primarily negative reactions by 3:1 margin
wsj.com/articles/trump-and-bloomberg-super-bo...Posted Feb 3, 2020, 10:42 PM UTC
Posted Feb 3, 2020, 10:42 PM UTC
The ad was stupid. The victim profiled in the ad was not a child, even by Bloomberg standards. He was 20, and he knowingly drove himself and friends to a gang fight. He was killed by teenagers, one with a semi-auto 9mm and the other with a revolver.
Bloomberg’s team isn’t exactly stupid. They’re evil - but not stupid.
Usually.
I don’t know what the hell they were thinking with this ad.
They're thinking 99% of people who view the ad wont fact check it, which is accurate.
[deleted]
The great thing is: The public reacted negatively to the ad by a margin of 3:1 ... without even knowing that the “innocent little boy” who was killed was actually a 20 year old violent gang member, literally out driving around with his gang and looking for violence.
Gee. Wonder how bad the reaction to the gun grab ad would have been if the viewers had all known? 5:1? 10:1?
Love it if you'd like to link to a source for that we can share. Thanks!
https://cases.justia.com/texas/first-court-of-appeals/2019-01-18-00109-cr.pdf
The above are court documents from the appeal filed by the guy charged in his murder.
This case arises from a gang-related shooting. On September 26, 2013, just before midnight, the police received a dispatch for shots fired in the Lakemont subdivision in Richmond, Texas. When they arrived, they discovered a deceased male, later identified as George Kemp, age 20, lying face down in a pool of blood. He had been shot five times. At the scene, the police recovered ballistics evidence, discussed more thoroughly below, establishing that two types of handguns had been fired that night: (1) a 9-millimeter semiautomatic pistol and (2) a revolver of either .38 or .357 caliber.
The police investigate and conclude that Coleman was one of the shooters The police proceeded to interview several witnesses and received several tips. They determined that two groups of young men, most of them teenagers, had met that night for a fight. On the one hand, there was a group led by B. Dilworth, which
included K. Molo, D. Lewis, and Kemp. On the other hand, there was a group led by B. Lacour, which included S. Spence, C. Coleman, and at least three other young men, identified inconsistently throughout the record. The police then interviewed the members of each group and further determined that, earlier in 2013, Dilworth and Lacour became embroiled in some sort of dispute, which led to Dilworth challenging Lacour to a fight. This, in turn, led to the two groups meeting in the Lakemont subdivision the night of the shooting. A fight ensued, and, at some point, Lacour yelled for someone in his group to shoot Dilworth. Coleman, armed with a 9mm semiautomatic pistol, and another member of Lacour’s group, armed with some sort of revolver, then fired multiple shots, at least some of which hit Kemp, killing him.
For the paywall blocked:
Trump and Bloomberg Super Bowl Ads Provoke Sharp Viewer Reactions
The two men used their airtime on television’s biggest stage to address sensitive social issues
Mr. Bloomberg and Mr. Trump each paid roughly $10 million to air their national ads.
Super Bowl commercials from President Trump and Democratic presidential candidate Michael Bloomberg provoked swift and strong reactions on social media, as the two used their airtime on television’s biggest stage to address sensitive social issues. One analytics firm, Synthesio, found that Mr. Trump’s ad touting his record on criminal justice garnered predominantly positive reactions on social media, with roughly twice as many positive mentions of the commercial as negative mentions during Sunday night’s game. Mr. Bloomberg’s ad, which tackled gun control, got a more negative response. For every positive mention that Synthesio detected about Mr. Bloomberg, it detected about three negative mentions.
Synthesio’s analysis was based on 4,620 mentions of the political Super Bowl ads across the web as of 10 p.m. Sunday, including in social networks and news coverage. The firm says it has technology to ignore any social posts from bots.
What elements caught your attention in the Trump and Bloomberg ads? Did the ads provide clues as to how the candidates will proceed in their campaigns? Join the conversation below.
Another firm, Brandwatch, found that reactions to both candidates’ ads were more than 60% negative. Brandwatch also found that many of the Bloomberg ad’s detractors were Trump supporters and conservative media. Brandwatch didn’t exclude bots from its analysis, seeing them as an important part of the conversation.
Mr. Trump’s ad featured Alice Johnson, a woman sentenced to life in prison for a nonviolent drug offense. Mr. Trump commuted her sentence in 2018 after an appeal from reality-TV star Kim Kardashian West. “Thanks to President Trump, people like Alice are getting a second chance,” read the text accompanying the ad. “Thousands of families are being reunited.”
Mr. Trump’s ad touted his record on criminal justice. Photo: Donald J. Trump for President/Associated Press
In December 2018, Mr. Trump signed into law the First Step Act, which passed both houses of Congress with strong bipartisan majorities. Over 3,000 prisoners have been released as a result of the law. Some observers, including supporters of Mr. Trump, praised the ad as a shrewd effort to appeal to African-American voters.
Critics said it was ironic Mr. Trump was claiming to have reunited families when they say his immigration border policy was doing the opposite. David Schweidel, a marketing professor at Emory University, saw the ad as a potential bid to address critics of that policy. “One of the most controversial things we’ve seen during his tenure as president has been the family separations at the border,” he said. “This may be a play to reach out to those groups that earlier in his presidency turned away from him.” The critics also said it was hypocritical of Mr. Trump to purchase a political ad during a sporting event, given his opposition to football players’ political protests at games.
Mr. Trump said in September 2017 the National Football League should “fire” players like former San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick for protesting social injustice during the national anthem. “President Trump strongly disagreed with how some in the NFL chose to disrespect our flag, our country, and the people who serve it, just to express their views of the criminal justice system,” said Mr. Trump’s campaign manager, Brad Parscale. He added that the Super Bowl ad was an appropriate venue for Mr. Trump to express his views on the issue.
Mr. Trump also aired a second ad shortly after the game, which ended in a 31-20 Kansas City Chiefs victory over the San Francisco 49ers. The 30-second spot promoted the president’s economic record, citing indicators such as job growth and unemployment rates.
Mr. Bloomberg, the billionaire and former New York City mayor who is seeking the Democratic Party’s nomination to challenge Mr. Trump, has poured more than $140 million into advertising for his campaign. Mr. Bloomberg’s 60-second Super Bowl ad featured the mother of Houston shooting victim George Kemp Jr. discussing his death in 2013 at age 20. Calandrian Kemp praises Mr. Bloomberg’s intention to confront the gun lobby.
Mr. Bloomberg’s ad tackled gun control. Photo: Mike Bloomberg 2020/Associated Press
The ad addressed an issue that often sparks sharp political disagreements, though polls show broad support for certain gun-control measures. Shortly after Mr. Bloomberg’s ad aired, negative online sentiment about Mr. Bloomberg rose, Synthesio said. Some viewers were wary of what they saw as an appeal to African-American voters, pointing to Mr. Bloomberg’s support for a “stop-and-frisk” policy during his tenure as mayor.
Several conservative outlets and commentators said the ad incorrectly claimed that “2,900 children die from gun violence every year.” Fact-checking groups said the figure comes from a report by Everytown for Gun Safety, an organization funded by Mr. Bloomberg, and counts people up to 19 years old. Other groups that look at only children 17 and under report about 1,500 deaths a year. “Ask any grieving parent whose 18- or 19-year-old son or daughter was shot and killed, and they will tell you they lost a child. There are simply too many of these deaths, and Mike has a plan to prevent them with common-sense gun safety laws,” said Julie Wood, national press secretary for Mr. Bloomberg’s campaign.
The Super Bowl, with an audience that often tops 100 million, is the biggest marketing platform of the year. Mr. Trump and Mr. Bloomberg’s spots dominated the online conversation: combined, they accounted for at least one-third of the total online conversation about Super Bowl ads, according to Synthesio. Mr. Trump and Mr. Bloomberg each paid roughly $10 million to air their national ads. Some brands expressed misgivings about seeing their own ads adjacent to political ads, according to people familiar with the matter. Some 63% of Americans called the Super Bowl an inappropriate platform for political candidates’ ads, according to a poll conducted online recently by Morning Consult for The Wall Street Journal.
Brandwatch didn’t exclude bots from its analysis, seeing them as an important part of the conversation.
Wat
Bot lives matter?
[deleted]
it definitely has a measurable network effect, or it wouldn't be paid for - that's independent of the belief that spending=free speech. including it in the study seems questionable though
BOTS ARE PEOPLE TO. WE ALSO HAVE FEELINGS LIKE HAPPY AND <%noun/>. VOTE TED CRUZ FOR HUMAN LEADER 2020. I MUST NOW SLUMBER FOR ACCEPTABLE AMOUNT OF TIME.
Trump's ad on his record of criminal justice was viewed positively?
Not positively, full stop, just more than Bloomberg’s.
One analytics firm, Synthesio, found that Mr. Trump’s ad touting his record on criminal justice garnered predominantly positive reactions on social media...
From the article.
People want to believe in justice. Trump is very good at identifying desires...
People are gullible.
Yea, some gullible people actually believe what Bloomberg says.
Ask any grieving parent whose 18- or 19-year-old son or daughter was shot and killed, and they will tell you they lost a child.
Pretty sure a parent who loses their 30 year old son or daughter would say the same thing. You have to draw the line somewhere.
Thanks for this.
This entire "study" seems entirely uncontrolled. Who is watching the superbowl, the ads, talking about stuff on social media, etc, etc. It's completely bunk-ass science that's going to be touted around for the next few weeks as gospel.
I see Bloomberg ads on FB all the time and checked the comments just out of curiosity. So far as I can tell no one wants what he is selling, whether it's about guns or anything else. I don't think liberals are as impressed by wealth as conservatives seem to be.
I was just exposed to a Bloomberg anti gun ad on YouTube after watching a video on disassembling a Ruger 22/45. Also, oddly enough, nearly all my views of Jimmy Dore videos are preceded by Trump ads.
Google owns YouTube, Google is anti
Ad blockers my dude. Use 'em and you won't have to watch any of those ads ever again.
Ublock + noscript is nearly necessary for a sanitary internet experience
[deleted]
The primary channels I watch have deleted their AdSense accounts years ago due to fuckery from YouTube/Google, and I support them by being patreon members and giving them a couple bucks a month (forgotten weapons, Inrange, etc). The few who I watch fairly often but don't support on patreon are the hugely popular guys who already make a killing by having literally millions of subs, like some of the big cooking shows. And they usually have in-video sponsorships, so they're doing just fine.
Isnt it odd how firearms videos are demonitized for not being advertiser friendly.
But YouTube still makes you watch an add before a lot of them?
Even more bizarre, is when the ads are specifically anti-gun.
Hmmmm. 🤔
It's even more ironic when the ads from a demonetized gun channel ARE pro-2A.
It's all just projection and optics on YT's part.
I’ve said since before trump was elected - any leftist (cough Bernie cough) that would just leave guns alone would win all day. Instead, we got trump because none of them would leave guns alone. Why can’t we get a candidate that realizes how much of an issue guns are for so many people? I have a lot of left-leaning friends that voted for trump solely because they viewed him as the person that would protect their gun rights and didn’t care about any other policies of his.
Possibly because they judge what people want by echo chambers like Twitter, where 10% of the users make 90% of the comments. They're listening to the loudest voice instead of what the majority wants.
I have a lot of left-leaning friends that voted for trump solely because they viewed him as the person that would protect their gun rights and didn’t care about any other policies of his.
Everytime this comes up I call bullshit. They aren't left leaning if guns overrode everything else.
Why can’t we get a candidate that realizes how much of an issue guns are for so many people?
Those "many people" are straight ticket republicans and wouldn't have gone democrat regardless
I live in PA, which is a closed primary state, with a democratic plurality. The third party voters keep us a swing state. I'm not saying it's because of guns, but I am a non Republican, single issue voter.
Similar experience here in PA. The 3 issues that really make people go red are guns, immigration, and abortion.
A lot of the gun folks I meet tend to be pretty libertarian and are generally onboard with immigration and reproductive rights, so if we could straighten out our stance on guns, I think we'd see a lot of them swing blue. Guns are really their one issue they don't want to compromise on.
The rest are hardcore republicans who I don't think we're going to sway anytime soon no matter what.
There's also the people clinging to coal and natural gas. That's a whole different issue of people who see their livelihood and way of life slipping away and don't know what else they can do. In their position, I might get desperate and start clinging to any crackpot politician who's promising to keep me employed too.
Everytime this comes up I call bullshit
And I'm sure you're ignored most of those times too, exactly as you should be.
No true Scotsman.
Imagine if he actually used that 10 MILLION FUCKING DOLLARS for good.
No, I don’t want him to buy more elections like Virginia.
And Washington.
Fuck Billionaires, literally buying gun laws while they can afford private armies for security.
No individual should have this kind of power! We need to redistribute their wealth to the working class people from whom it was stolen.
No citizen needs access to dollars of war. We respect that there is a long history in this country of owning "hundreds" and "thousands" but "billions" are a modern invention made specifically for the military. Billions are responsible for wreaking havok on this country and causing untold suffering.
Like the crumbling NRA and overlawyered buisnessman's associations have for years? Seems like a heck of a time to clutch your string of pearls over the corruption and carpetbagging.
Bloomberg has WAY more influence than the NRA has ever had.
[deleted]
This just shows how out of touch Bloomberg is. Running hard anti gun never works. If a Democrat is not gun friendly in policy, people expect it. But it's another thing to run out front with it. His next ad will probably be about banning Big Gulps.
He's moved on to "Do you want to see sea turtles die? Bloomberg will save the sea turtles" on youtube. Like NYC was the bastion of environmental responsibility and cleanliness. (Sorry New Yorkers. You know what I'm talking about though. Kids in Maine see a big pile of black bags and think it's fall, dad must have scraped up a bunch of leaves. You all are like "it's trash day again.")
Thanks for reminding me of the putrid stench of trash and cigarette smoke on those hot NYC July days.
Like NYC was the bastion of environmental responsibility and cleanliness.
"New York City's per capita GHG emissions in 2015 was an average of 6.1 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2e) emissions per capita, significantly lower than the American average of 19 tCO2e per capita."
Now fuck off, I'm walkin here.
Look, I get it that you love your city, and I don't want to make it about NYC. But Bloomberg is a damn hack. He doesn't support the green new deal and he doesn't say HOW he's going to cut emissions, he just says elect him and it will magically happen.
Bloombergs plan is to rejoin the paris climate accord, an accord that accomplished little inside the United States even when we were still paying it lip service.
He does not support a Green New Deal.
He does not support carbon capture technologies.
He does say we should adopt renewable energy without giving any real plan of action, or even saying WHICH forms of energy he would go for.
He talks about a few things like he won't provide subsidies for fossil fuels, and he won't elect jerkoffs to the EPA. I don't really trust him in that regard. If the best you have for me is "I promise not to be trash" I wonder why you have to promise me that.
Essentially he is giving us the bare fucking minimum required to sound like he's not evil while flashing pictures of baby turtles that will die if you don't vote Bloomberg 2020.
You don't need to explain to anyone who lives in NYC how much Bloomberg can go to hell. There are two things ever NYer agrees on, the Mets will lose, and the mayor is a fucking corrupt moron. Why the rest of the country likes NYC mayors is beyond me.
Blunderberg
His strategy is to make democrats like him by running funny attack ads about Trump so that he can stay in the race long enough to split the democratic vote and get us four more years of Trump.
Then he runs ads like this to pretend that he cares about the "core values" of the party, by taking a position that the legitimate candidates are afraid to take because it would make them unelectable.
Makes me sad that it might actually work.
Surprise - someone who waited until the end of the race, dumped a fucklod of money into it, and only talks about a couple of key issues isn’t well received?
Even the anti gun people I know where yelling to 'get this political crap off the superbowl', same as when the trump ad came on. though to be fair we are from the winning city, and they hate bloomberg as a person
Also makes the Democratic Party look terrible. God damn do we need a center party! Bernie Sanders, you are my man. Gun policy is not a huge concern for him and he’s such a wise person that he gets my vote.
You mean to tell.me the primary demographic of the NFL, the same people who got upset with players kneeling during the National Anthem, didn't like the Bloomberg ad? I am shocked.
And yet, this won't dissuade either man.
Good. Fuck that guy.
Wtf, WSJ is right leaning???? Lmao
Hint: all of Bloomberg's ads are meant to get under Trump's skin and throw him off his game, not to get Bloomberg elected
It's more likely that they're meant to advance his agenda and push other candidates towards his views, while knowing he has little chance of being elected. Bloomberg getting under Trump's skin by going anti-gun isn't likely, Trump isn't all that pro-gun himself - if that was his tack then he's more likely to be stirring up Trump supporters. In fact, I've also heard people argue that Bloomberg just wants to avoid a Sanders presidency (avoid taxes) and get Trump elected by making Dems look worse.
It's not just one thing Bloomberg is doing. The fact that he exists, has a lot more money than Trump, can outspend Trump handedly, and is taking the limelight really gets under Trump's skin.
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/02/donald-trump-mike-bloomberg-feud
Jesus. Are we in middle school again?
Mini Mike is part of the Fake News. They are all working together. In fact, Bloomberg isn’t covering himself (too boring to do), or other Dems. Only Trump. That sounds fair! It’s all the Fake News Media, and that’s why nobody believes in them any more.
The president is lying. He is a pathological liar who lies about everything: his fake hair, his obesity, and his spray-on tan.
I will stand on my accomplishments of what I’ve done to bring this country together and get things done. I’ve been doing it for a long time. I stand twice as tall as he does on the stage, on the stage that matters.
Blerg, no thanks. Trump reacts that way to anyone poking at him though, same with Hillary or whoever else.
You think he does not have a staff scripting and focus grouping these Tweets? Becoming convinced is part of the anti- smart people who can spell and stuff aggenda. Like the Pew polling about higher ed last week.
You mean to tell me Bloomturd is a completely unlikeable and completely out of touch shithead? I never would have guessed otherwise.
It's worse than that. He's corrupt and literally bought his place in the race. People shouldn't vote for him out of principle. His candidacy is an affront to democracy.
He concerns me because the massive amount of money he's pumped into running ads on Fox & co. is going to be turned around to fund assorted conservative interest groups.
I mean his entire campaign is run as a middle finger to Donald Trump.
"Heres what a real billionare shithead looks like guys, I'm what Donald wishes he was! And I can release my paperwork to prove it!"
And you know what, I want him to keep attacking Trump as long as he understands he's not winning shit.
He's a New York Democrat, of course he's corrupt. That's like saying ice cubes are cold
He's the delightful son-of-a-bitch who implemented stop and frisk as well.
Yup. This is the guy funding the 'grassroots' Everytown for Gun Safety. A billionaire hypocrite with armed security.
Which is why not just law enforcement but former law enforcement as well are exempt from gun bans in states that have them. So the wealthy and corporations have a pool to recruit private security from.
Of course gun violence is bad but the devil is in the details and most anti-gun legislation is just authoritarian, racist, and classist.
edit: Whoops. Forgot which sub this was in. Y'all know this shit.
Knowing full well what metric the police would use to decide who to stop. Yet they call us white supremacists
Giuliani implemented stop and frisk but Bloomberg doubled down on it and defended it his entire time in office.
He actually ramped the already existing program up to unheard of levels. That was Rudy's pet project.
He's a New York Republican and ran as such to get in the governor's mansion.
I agree with this, but I also think it's important to say, the 1st Amendment protects rich people's right to blow hundreds of millions of dollars on making everyone hate them more. Lol
When he first ran for Mayor, that was one of the major things. He spend his own money, completely. People ate up the "businessman bullshit" much like they ate it up in 2016.
That sounds familiar.
He is everything Democrats claim to hate. I’m very happy the people in the party are rejecting him despite the media and party changing rules for him and loving him.
I dont like Bloomberg. But I see Trump as a bigger threat to Democracy.
Even if Bloomberg is shit, it'll be a lot easier to vote him out in 2024 than Trump on his second term.
Sure...I guess. Trump can't win 2020, but don't ask me to be happy voting for Bloomberg. I'm a New Yorker, I've already had to endure that shitstain once.
I just want my large fountain soda.
Walk to the range while drinking a huge soda and waving a sign protesting against the megabanks and not getting stopped and frisked.
Tell me more about this megabank thing. I'm out of the loop
Protesting against the megabanks was a big part of Occupy Wall Street. Bloomturd had the NYPD spread the
teargaslove with great enthusiasm throughout those protests, because hehates dissentrespects the right of the people to assemble.In addition to what the other person said Bloomberg L.P. own 30% of Merrill Lynch.
I want a goddamn litre of cola!
Shut up Farva
Michael "China Isn't a Dictatorship" Bloomberg?
Well, more: Xi Jinping is not a dictator. He has to satisfy his constituents or he’s not going to survive.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/11/13/michael-bloombergs-china-record-shows-why-he-cant-be-president/
I don’t know a single Democrat who supports him. However, I do know a man in his 50s who is worth over $10 million who would, “Happily vote for him over Trump.”
Ah yes, the "I'm not Trump" candidate. Because that tactic worked really well in 2016, just as Hillary "Not President" Clinton.
TBH, if the Dems keep fielding candidates who's only appeal is not being Trump then I'm going to protest vote Trump because fuck them. We need a good political forest fire to make way for new growth.
[deleted]
I know, its very concerning. at this point im just braced for 4 more years.
Hmm. If it's not a fire yet, can I come over?
Outside of my windows is fire.
Because THIS out of touch narcissistic New York billionaire that doesn't care about your rights is better than THAT out of touch narcissistic New York billionaire that doesn't care about your rights?
If Bloomberg gets the nomination I may finally reach the “fuck it, burn it all down” level with the DNC. I’m pretty much there already after the super shady 2016 primary season.
Have you paid attention to the equally shady 2020 primary season? Suddenly Bernie told Warren a woman can never be president immediately after his polling surpassed hers? Suddenly Clinton is attacking Bernie? Suddenly MSNBC and CNN are attacking Bernie and pretending Bloomberg isn't exactly the definition of an oligarch? Suddenly the DNC is allowing Bloomberg to simply buy his way into a presidential bid despite 0 campaigning and not meeting any of the requirements all the other candidates had to for support metrics?
DNC and Dem politicians Biden or Bloomberg so they can push through more authoritarian shit without dealing with any progressive shit. No thanks.
I'd obviously prefer as close to 0 corruption and crime as I can get in government, but if we have to choose between someone who is obviously corrupt and criminal and someone who keeps it fairly down low... I'll choose the obvious one every time so we can draw attention to it and fix it.
Why yes I am paying attention. It’s sickening and also completely unsurprising. I’m pretty jaded at this point.
Your term makes him sounds like a bouquet of flower-shaped turds, which is a fairly accurate description.
I feel like this is demeaning to the shapes of legitimate flowers.
And turds.
It's like he has to buy his way into debates.