Issue testing IRS W-4 calculator with bonus income
I'm trying to get a better handle on the new W-4 and also testing out the IRS calculator. I put in a scenario of someone single earning $60k, paid monthly, with $800/month withheld who also received $60k supplemental income that's subject to withholding. The IRS calculator correctly states that the total annual withholding would be $22,800 ($800 * 12 + .22 * $60k).
It then went on to advise increasing withholding to $1659/month, essentially ignoring the tax withholding on the supplemental income.
Is the withholding calculator just getting this wrong? I'd been really hoping it would do the calculation to give a dollar amount to put in the deductions box to offset the excess supplemental withholding :\
Posted Feb 4, 2020, 2:23 AM UTC · edited
26
That's the only adjustment is suggested? Additional withholding per month?
https://imgur.com/a/F5ENC9b
So you'll see it says pre-tax wages as $60k in one place then pre-tax income as $120k in another place. No idea why it says $14k withheld to date, but I don't think that's a factor.
That looks right to me. The standard withholdings will be about 6300.00, plus the 13,200 from the bonus, total of 19,500 withheld, plus the 200.00 over withholding to date. That's really close to the 20k of expected tax liability. So it's perfect.
It's saying 14k withheld to date because of the 13. 2k that will be withheld on the 60k supplemental check, plus the 800.00 withholding to date.
It's not saying to withhold an ADDITIONAL 1.6k a month. It's saying that's the total per month that needs to be withheld, and will be, with the new w4 submission.
Ah-ha. Thank you. I was getting thrown off by the "you will need $1,659 withheld from each paycheck" statement in the second image. But yes, realizing now that filling out the W-4 this way only $522 would be withheld each paycheck.
Now off to test another scenario that actually models what I was trying for.
Yay, got it to work: "Enter $93 for credits and other reductions to annual withholding"
I wonder what we'll be seeing in a year as a result of fewer people defaulting to overwithholding.