[Review] Coilturd An RDA for vaping
Hi! For some reason I was pretty stoked about this RDA for vaping, so let's find out if it's also an RDA to gush about.
Coilturd An RDA for vaping
An RDA for vaping on a mod for squonking
Table of contents
- Hard facts
- Soft facts
- Totally personal take
- Pros/Cons
- Summary
- Disclaimer
Hard facts
this is a dual coil RDA for vaping
- Measurements (without drip tip and 510) 24*19mm
- Build deck straight forward postless deck
- Airflow ranges from loose MTL all the way to barn door
- Something noteworthy about the goodie bag? three different airflow rings
- Something else? nope
Soft facts
Rarely am I this torn when it comes to looks as much as I am with this RDA for vaping. While combing matte and shiny just fucking sinks my boat instead of floating it, IRL it looks way less irritating than what the pictures led me to believe. Also, while I like the way drip tips with an engraved pattern look (and feel, for that matter), they are fucking lip crud magnets, so my full black RDA for vaping went zebra already after only a couple of mls.
I'm equally torn when it comes to the tech-side. While not being the biggest fan of postless decks, especially when there is no indication of what leg length to aim for, building on the RDA for vaping is fucking easy. You slam the coil as low as possible, secure the leads and call it a day. What puzzles me, though, is the deck itself. It's a big block in the center of the chamber, which has two repercussions.
First of all, because just-shy-of-shorting is the way to go with the coils, it's inevitable that there is a bit of juice between the coil and the deck. While normally I assume spit back to be a layer 8 problem, there is pretty much no way to not get at least a tiny bit of juice sprayed into your mouth when the RDA for vaping is used as an RDA for dripping. When I use the RDA for vaping as an RDA for squonking, I got spit-back rarely, and also only when I tooted right after squonking.
The other problem introduced by the shape/position of the deck is about the well. We actually have pretty big unoccupied spaces, which would lend themselves really well as juice wells. Squonking juice there actually works nicely; however, when dripping, it's too hard for me to guestimate how much juice I already poured in because there is no visual feedback. You only see that there is already enough/too much juice, once it's too late.
So, while using this RDA for dripping, I wouldn't recommend it.
One more tech thingy to talk about...and well, it's just as weird as the aesthetics and the deck: the airflow. The basic idea is quite basic, namely side airflow, but the implementation is fairly nice. The actual slots are angled vertically and they are shaped like wedges, that is they are narrower on the inside than on the outside; as such, air gets focused to the middle of the coil, which in my experience always leads to nice performance.
The AFC is constituted by you choosing one out three rings. Your chosen one is then put on the barrel and secured via a thread-on cap. Turning the ring isn't possible, so each one gives you a fixed experience. The difference between the rings lays in the number of holes they come with: 1, 2 and 3 per side. The ring with only 1 hole per side yields a loose MTL draw, the one with 3 per side is a barn door and the one with 2 per side gives you something in-between.
Now to the weird part; as I said, the slots aren't just slots, they actually are three tubes; but because of the wedging they - right where the air comes in - merge to one big opening. So, while there are three air inlets, there is only one massive outlet. Hence, slight turbulences are created (more holes in the ring = more turbulences). Why there is nothing in place to separate the single stream of air entering the chamber into three smaller ones is beyond. While the turbulences aren't enough to destroy the whole experience, they still are bad enough to be distracting at times (especially with the airiest airflow ring).
Update I wrote that part about one week ago...and as of today, I'm not too sure anymore, whether there actually are turbulences or if the RDA for vaping is just fucking loud. Really hard to determine, so I settled for this: with the 1-holed ring, I just get a Whistle for vaping, while the 3-holed ring isn't as smooth as I expect RDAs to be nowadays.
Which is a real pity, because the flavor is through the fucking roof. The first toot blew me away, and I enjoyed the 100ml I put through a fucking lot.
In terms of coils, you pretty much can do whatever you want. Something massive like tricore 26ga clapton is just as possible as a loose MTL variant with good old 24ga round wire.
Totally personal take
Fairly weird RDA, IMHO. I mean, I'm confident that someone set out to build their dream RDA for vaping and achieved exactly that. And while I don't fault the design for the turbulences, respectively the noise (might have been too hard/costly to machine some nicer outlet solution), the deck is just weird. Also, I actually like the AFC style, but I can't deny that there is a bit too much liquid building up than I like (not that I care too much, but it is an indication that some more editing could have been done; I think it's due to the juice wells being right next to the AFC rings without any sort of sealing).
Despite the flawed deck design, I enjoyed vaping the RDA for vaping; not only for its awesome flavor, but also because I finally found an RDA that fits right into one very specific niche: low Watts dual coil. Using the smallest AFC ring, I can get away with 60 to 65 Watts.
Flavor is my number 1 priority, but thick clouds are a close second. To get big and thick clouds with a single-coil, I need to push an insane amount of power through the coil and put it into a barn door RDA like the .blank. However, I enjoy restricted ones way more, and as such, I was on the hunt for a fairly restricted dual coil RDA. I've been abusing the B2K for a while now, but a dedicated dual coil RDA is, of course, way more comfortable to use.
So, I like this RDA for vaping, with the smallest insert. And while I can appreciate it for what it is when used wide open, it's too noisy/turbulent/whistle-y for me.
I think, that for people who look for something airy, though, this RDA for vaping probably isn't the end all be all. Yes, the flavor is on point, and I also think quite a lot of people enjoy the raw draw they get from the RDA for vaping, but for everyone who looks for a smooth as fuck affair, the Asgard Mini is a way better choice.
Pros/Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| great range in terms of airflow and builds | no traditional AFC |
| flavor is fucking spot on | pretty whistle-y, maayybe slightly turbulent |
| easy as fuck deck | not the best pure dripper |
Summary
| RDA | Airiness: sucking on a straw to barn door | Smoothness: fasten your seat belts to butter | My thoughts summarized with an ASCII | Star review | Final thoughts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coilturd An RDA for vaping | ■■■■■ (biggest insert) to ■□□□□ (smallest insert) | ■■■■□ | (。◕‿◕。) | ★★★★☆ | a couple of minor annoyances, but I can look past them; the flavor is fucking nice, and I adore the range of builds I can use; if it just wasn't such a whistle |
Info & Disclaimer
- The Coilturd An RDA for vaping was bought with my own money.
- All of my reviews along with my recommendations can be found in these reddit posts: RDAs and everything else. If you enjoy filtering and sorting, I also packed my summary tables into a google spreadsheet.
- I'm a lazy fuck. And English isn't my first language, so please bear with me.
- A proper disclaimer can be found here.
Posted Feb 6, 2020, 5:56 PM UTC
Nice review mang! Was this king of picking one up after seeing so much praise.
around its release there was a lot of appraisal, but I think by now everyone went back to their Asgards...
Haha. Isnt that how it goes though? Like.... I can grab a 2016 rta and vape it side by side with the great thing from now and they are hardly different.... but the old one isnt cool anymore...
performance there is little difference, I guess, but a lot of QoL issues have been resolved since then (building is easier, less vacuum lock)
but yeah, overall you are right, it's always about the shiny new stuff :)
I know there are improvements... look at how many tanks needed a juice flow control to keep them from pissing liquid everywhere
Is the Asgard (mini) that much better than most other common dual coil rdas? I've been vaping all single coil rdas for a little while now after only vaping dual since I started using rebuildables. I got kinda bored of the the dual coil stuff(goon OG 1.5 or 25, recoil rebel, bonza 1.5, rebirth, recurve dual and many others). I've seen the Asgard get a lot of hype and thinking I might check it out.
I used single coils for a long long time pretty much exclusively, dual coils for a week at most until I got bored
then I bought the Asgard Mini and used it straight for months
I can't compare it to any of the ones you mentioned, but I'm pretty confident that it's one of the best around; it's so fucking smooth and so effortless at even 90 Watts, it's insane
overall, best RDA
if you are interested, here is me review for it
Sweet. I'll check out your review.