Do we really need X’s on trees?

Question

They have been a nightmare for ages. Hitting trees with a rock is painful. The time it takes to finish an entire tree is not worth the wood you get...

Remove X’s and allow free hitting of trees once again. The better tool you have, the more wood you receive per hit. Finishing the whole tree gives you a bonus amount. Subject to balancing.

Posted Feb 9, 2020, 3:12 AM UTC

29
kdjfsk•

allow free hitting of trees once again.

it was never removed. you can hit the tree wherever you want.

4
Regular_MercOP•

Yes but if you read my whole post I go into other changes that improve the current system.

2
kdjfsk•

just use a chainsaw bruh, big brain time.

4
hunted5•

you don't actually go into any changes.. you only list what is already there... the X's are just an additional bonus..

0
LogansLS•

The x cuts down the tree faster, not just bonus wood. I agree with op the x is fucked and should be removed

5
kabflash•

Not true hitting anywhere with a rock used to give 10 and now you have to hit the X for 10. So no it's not a bonus it's a nerf to the old way.

3
MessiLoL•

Quote from Helk two years ago https://www.reddit.com/r/playrust/comments/7dbtis/new_tree_minigame/dpy0spp?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

I feel it important to point out that everyone on reddit posted about how the node changes were claimed to be horrific when we implemented them and now they seem to be universally appreciated.

This is just supposed to break up the monotony of bashing trees in the same spot forever with a minor bonus if you choose to do it.

If you don't like it, you don't have to participate. The yield is exactly the same as it was before - we can investigate other decal art for it but its supposed to be a spraypainted X, something loggers do to trees IRL. It seemed fitting.

One day it would be nice to have the trees actually show damage and you actually have to chop it down and can see the damage being done to it bit by bit but that would require a hell of a lot of art and time. I think this works for now.

So if it's just to "to break up the monotony of bashing trees" and everyone hates it, I see no reason they shouldn't remove it.

"If you don't like it, you don't have to participate. The yield is exactly the same as it was before" is a shit response, since it's faster to farm if you hit the X, you're forced into participating unless you're some kind of insane person who doesn't like playing efficiently.

1
Regular_MercOP•

but it takes longer to get the same amount of wood with the x’s, compared to the old tree system.

1
MessiLoL•

I don't disagree with you, I was comparing hitting X's and not hitting X's in the current system only.

1