Why do you think many games punish players with less health when they’re not doing well and reward with more health when they don’t need it?

Discussion

Many games punish players with reduced health when they die (which of course happens when players are struggling) yet reward players who are doing well (and therefore don’t really need it) with extra health. Why do you think that is?

Ignoring that its a cheap and easy punishment/reward system, I guess it also helps prolong a “good-streak”, and if it were purely a powerup reward, then I think that might feel pretty great to the player: I’m doing great and this lets me maintain my momentum longer. It can also add a risk-reward element.

But many games have the higher-health as the default, so you don’t get rewarded for being good, you only get punished for being bad. I find it very frustrating when I’m struggling with a portion of a game (eg a boss) and then have to do it with reduced health because fuck me for not being better.

Some games use the mechanic, but getting back to max health isn’t a big deal, so they somewhat side-step the negative parts. Hollow Knight being an example: getting back to full energy isn’t hard and can always be done before a boss.

Thoughts? How would you handle rewarding the player for doing well, encouraging them to do better but not kicking them when they’re already down?

Posted Feb 9, 2020, 3:21 PM UTC · edited

823
kodiak931156•

Simple. It rewards play that avoids damage and seek health and incentivizes play styles that achieve this.

Look a the OG zelda. They didn't want you to tank the enemies they wanted you learn the enemies patterns well enough a play smart enough to avoid the damage.

If you did so and were at full hp they gave you the sword power shot. This also made it less of a chore travel in the low risk areas because you very likely would have a powefull weapon to help speed up the 500th time you've passed through the same screen while going from place to place.

After death they started you out at half hp because enemies drop hearts and if you are playing the way they want tou should be able to farm up to full hp.

If you want a good system for the opposite, rewarding a low resource player look at doom

A player with low ammo naturally wants to play carefully and slowly. The designer doesnt want this, so they made it so the most agressive up close weapon, the chainsaw, makes enemies drop ammo

22
guywithknifeOP•

Thanks, this is what I was looking for!

3
kodiak931156•

Glad i could help.

A mechanic usually boils down to I am promoting a type playstyle or this mechanic is popular so i feel i need to shoehorn it in to make the game "marketable"

2
bearvert222•

Tthe type of challenge you need to go through to get back to the boss usually has little to do with the boss that killed you. I think the real reason is to force the player just to slow down after repeated retries. It works too well though-a lot of time it slows them so much they stop playing the game.

1
AMastryukov•

I cannot recall specific examples of this system at work but my guess is that it depends on what kind of game it is and what experience the designer wanted to make for the players.

For example, in casual party games like Mario Kart it makes sense to give losing players a bit of a boost to give them a fighting chance so that everyone has a great time. On the other hand, if you have a game like Dark Souls, giving struggling players a massive boost would only take away from the challenging experience.

It also has to do with player expectations. If I buy a game advertised as a brutally hardcore experience, I would be pretty disappointed if the game decided to give me a special health pack when I died 5 times in a row to a challenging boss.

4
guywithknifeOP•

> if you have a game like Dark Souls, giving struggling players a massive boost would only take away from the challenging experience

Sure, but punishing the player who is having issues by reducing their health seems like a recipe for frustration. If I’m having problems, making it *harder* will only increase my problems. Conversely, if I’m already doing well, then the reward of more health is only decreasing the challenge (although, the latter isn’t a problem in Dark Souls, since you always progress past a boss with the health boost. I guess this is probably always the case in any game with such a mechanic: the reward isn’t a problem, only the punishment is).

Again, using Dark Souls as an example, if I lose to a boss, the next time I have to fight it with diminished health, making the likelihood of losing again more likely. Which in turn makes frustration and leaving the game more likely.

I didn’t find this to be so problematic in DS3 (I don’t remember offhand about the others) I didn’t find this to be a problem because I mentally played the game as if hollowed was the default and embered was the reward for playing with the danger of being invaded. Also, since I could always pop an ember, it felt less of a punishment to lose embered state and more of an optional boost. But I think it could have easily become frustrating if I didn’t put myself into the mindset that hollowed was “normal” and human was boosted.

In Hollow Knight p, its also not problematic, because the negative effect is very slight (small but of reduced soul energy, you don’t get reduced health) and getting it back is typically easy (and always possible before a boss).

I suppose these are key ways to avoid it becoming a point of frustration. (And as usual, rewarding good play rather than punishing bad play helps avoid frustration).

3
AMastryukov•

As u/kodiak931156 stated, this could be done to promote a specific play style (i.e. what sort of experience the designer wanted to make for the player).

As a designer, how do I tell the player that you have to move to the left every time the boss attacks to avoid his massive damage? If I just pause the game and tell the player to move to the left, that would take away from the "aha" moment that players love to experience, so I have to instead provide incentive or meta-hints. Reducing the health when the player keeps dying basically tells them "your health doesn't matter, you aren't supposed to tank the boss, find another way to beat him".

Either that or the game designer is inexperienced and/or sadistic.

Edit: game design has a lot to do with designing and balancing incentives for the players (answering the question "how do I make the player do X without explicitly telling them to do X?").

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
kodiak931156•

Mario kart is an even better example then you think.

Mario kart is in a tough spot. It wants to be a party game but it's also played competitively. The blue shell is a perfect example of elegant game design.

For low skill players it is a huge catchup mechanic that casual players would love because it gives the player in last place a chance to get back in the game. Competitive people would hate it because it punishes the player who has earned first place by shooting an unavoidable shell just for them

EXCEPT IT IS AVOIDABLE. For a casual player it isn't, so it works in casual play as described. But if a skilled player times a mushroom boost JUST RIGHT it avoids the shell. Meaning that in competative play it stops functioning as catchup mechanic.

Low skill players get one thing out of it while high skills players have the exact same mechanic function completely different. And that promotes completely different gameplay

2
SlickSpecHobbyist•

The problem with the Blue Shell in most of the games is that unlike other items it often doesn't benefit the player who throws it. Compared to other items I would say it loses design-wise due to this.

Mushrooms allow you to catch up and to take shortcuts. The Stars and Bullet Bill items help you clear the road as you advance with increased speed. Lightning bolts are brutal but fair; though they make everyone in front of you drive slower and lose their items, it lasts shorter the further back in the race the victim is.

The Blue Shell, however, only keeps 1st from getting too far ahead: it lets 2nd and 3rd place advance into 1st -- but the person in 8th place who threw the shell gets no boost and will simply stay back in 8th. (Perhaps the thought was to affect the final scoreboard more than saving the losing player in that race?)

The N64 version of the Blue Shell, as well as the latest one from Switch, somewhat solve the problem by making the shell travel along the track at ground level, potentially clearing away several players and dropped items on its way to 1st.

For me there is still a problem, however, because the shell benefits the person in 2nd place far more than the one in 8th, but it is the one in 8th who has the best chance of getting it while I'm not even sure if 2nd place has the ability to receive a Blue Shell at all.

1
bearvert222•

This is incredibly common in shooting games: Gradius for example will depower you mercilessly if you die once, forcing you to lose all your options and gear. If you die in Contra, you lose the powerful weapon you have and need to fight with the default pea shooter, which is much harder, especially if you have the machinegun + the rapid fire upgrade (using a rare weapon drop to make a very powerful combo weapon)

In Gradius again as well as other shooters, a very nasty version of this is losing movement speed; your speed itself is a function of how many powerups youve collected, and you revert into being a slug in the middle of difficult levels.

It's fallen out of favor because it's generally not fun at all, because a lot of times you need a perfect or near perfect run to beat the game

2

A specific example of this system at work would be Dark Souls 2. Dying in that game, unlike the first and third games, reduced your health down to a minimum value and the only way to get it back was to use a human effigy (return yourself to human state/reverse hollowing).

0
FuzzForce•

I wasn't a fan of the morale system in Guild Wars. If you died, it took a while of having 85% Health and Spirit before you got back to 100%. Worse if you died again and it went down further to 70%. It was really crippling.

2
ElizzyVioletHobbyist•

Very few games actually have mechanics like this, but dark souls 2 and 3 are good examples.

If a player manages to get past a difficult section in dark souls 2 with their now-reduced health, then this means that they have acquired skills that will help them beat other areas more easily. If you can beat the Ruin Sentinels on half your maximum health, you’re ready to beat up the Lost Sinner with full health!

Dark souls 3 actually improved on this formula by framing the Ember item as a buff rather than a debuff cure: it’s functionally the same but there’s some psychological trickery at hand to help. Plus, the HP bonus from an Ember isn’t too big, and you don’t look like beef jerky anymore if you refuse to use it, so it doesn’t feel bad.

1
guywithknifeOP•

There are other games that kind of do (I already mentioned Hollow Knight, but as I said, its not a problem there at all) and I remember seeing it in a bunch of other games, but now that I want to list them, I’m failing to think which ones I was thinking of :-/

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
guywithknifeOP•

That seems short-sighted to me and a recipe for frustration. If I’m failing, the game is already dificult, so why add more? Yet if I’m doing well, when the extra difficulty might be warranted amd welcome, the game doesn’t do provide it.

2
GhostOfSparta305•

What exactly is the game adding more of, in your example, that makes it “more” difficult? It’s very possible that the game might be “difficult” as a natural consequence of the player having less health, which can be incorrectly perceived as “added” difficulty.

If you’ve ever watched two people playing a fighting game, watch how a player with only a sliver of health left plays compared to a player with tons of health. The high health player will usually take lots of risks and use a wider range of their fighter’s move set. The low health player will usually play defensively, and only use a small subset of their fighter’s available move set (the “safer” pokes).

In that situation, the lower health player is playing a more difficult game, but that’s due to circumstance. The game isn’t taking away any of his/her options or piling any new challenge on them: it’s the low health player’s perception that drives this more difficult gameplay.

3
moute3•

The problem with your example is that the low health player has already messed up by taking damage, they already used up a lot of the wiggle room the game has given them. But by making so that if a player dies then they lose a chunk of their max hp, it makes the game harder as they have to replay a section of the game with less wiggle room, something the player clearly needed more of, not less.

3
GhostOfSparta305•

I’m not sure I agree that it’s clear more health was needed in your situation. You seem to think that more wiggle room helps a player learn, but I think the opposite is true.

If a player keeps dying due to losing health, then I as a designer would want my game to teach the player how not to lose health, and see it as a valuable resource. Your solution of granting the player more health upon death, however, wouldn’t really accomplish that.

As I mentioned before, players with tons of health take more risks and are more reckless, because more health = more opportunity for mistakes to be forgiven. Granting a player who keeps dying more health upon death might help them get past a tough section, yes, but it would not teach the player to value and preserve their health. Quite the opposite is taught here.

Making someone’s health bar smaller upon death, however, would continuously force a player into a state of health preservation mode. The more a player dies, the more a player is forced to do what’s necessary to NOT die. The more a player repeats this skill, the better they’ll get. In this situation, a player may get past a tough section, but will more importantly be taught the lesson of how to preserve health.

Death in games isn’t something that should be perpetually avoided. It’s often death that teaches us the most about how to best play a game.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
Swiftster•

Many feels like an overstatement. The Souls-like genre certainly does this, to encourage their particular brand of careful combat, but for most games death is a slap on the wrist at best.

0
AchromaticSky•

The only Souls game that lowers your health when you die is 2, and that's pretty much the most reviled mechanic in the series because it goes against the core design principle that death is a learning experience rather than a failure.

1
ned_poreyra•

Why do you think that is?

Because game designers often forget that losing in itself is already a punishment.

-3†