Why do you think many games punish players with less health when they’re not doing well and reward with more health when they don’t need it?
Many games punish players with reduced health when they die (which of course happens when players are struggling) yet reward players who are doing well (and therefore don’t really need it) with extra health. Why do you think that is?
Ignoring that its a cheap and easy punishment/reward system, I guess it also helps prolong a “good-streak”, and if it were purely a powerup reward, then I think that might feel pretty great to the player: I’m doing great and this lets me maintain my momentum longer. It can also add a risk-reward element.
But many games have the higher-health as the default, so you don’t get rewarded for being good, you only get punished for being bad. I find it very frustrating when I’m struggling with a portion of a game (eg a boss) and then have to do it with reduced health because fuck me for not being better.
Some games use the mechanic, but getting back to max health isn’t a big deal, so they somewhat side-step the negative parts. Hollow Knight being an example: getting back to full energy isn’t hard and can always be done before a boss.
Thoughts? How would you handle rewarding the player for doing well, encouraging them to do better but not kicking them when they’re already down?
Posted Feb 9, 2020, 3:21 PM UTC · edited
Simple. It rewards play that avoids damage and seek health and incentivizes play styles that achieve this.
Look a the OG zelda. They didn't want you to tank the enemies they wanted you learn the enemies patterns well enough a play smart enough to avoid the damage.
If you did so and were at full hp they gave you the sword power shot. This also made it less of a chore travel in the low risk areas because you very likely would have a powefull weapon to help speed up the 500th time you've passed through the same screen while going from place to place.
After death they started you out at half hp because enemies drop hearts and if you are playing the way they want tou should be able to farm up to full hp.
If you want a good system for the opposite, rewarding a low resource player look at doom
A player with low ammo naturally wants to play carefully and slowly. The designer doesnt want this, so they made it so the most agressive up close weapon, the chainsaw, makes enemies drop ammo
Thanks, this is what I was looking for!
Glad i could help.
A mechanic usually boils down to I am promoting a type playstyle or this mechanic is popular so i feel i need to shoehorn it in to make the game "marketable"
Tthe type of challenge you need to go through to get back to the boss usually has little to do with the boss that killed you. I think the real reason is to force the player just to slow down after repeated retries. It works too well though-a lot of time it slows them so much they stop playing the game.