[NY] Brother-in-law was about to leave the country for a few months, then got himself booked for a misdemeanour
I'm gonna start with the facts of what happened as he related it to us, then ask my questions. Thanks in advance for your patience. This is in New York City (Queens, if it matters).
What Happened: Late last Saturday night, my 23-year-old brother-in-law was hanging out with friends and got pretty drunk. Some of his friends were fucking around, and broke the door of a deli. He says he wasn't involved in actually damaging the door at all. Cops arrived, everyone but his drunk ass ran away, and so he (and only he) got arrested. He was charged under 145.00.01, and has a Desk Appearance Ticket for Feb. 28.
Question 1: This is a class A misdemeanour, which seems serious and something that he should get a lawyer for. However, he definitely can't afford to pay a lawyer. We could probably afford to pay for the lawyer for him if push came to shove, but I really don't want to do that unless it would move the needle a lot in terms of consequences. How much worse would it be for him to get a court-appointed lawyer?
Question 2: He's got a plane ticket out of the country departing next week, and was planning to be gone for two or three months. It's because his work has slowed way, way down, and he can't afford to stay and pay his rent. (He's an American citizen, but was born in a country where it's much cheaper to live, and will be going there until work picks back up again.) Is his plan to leave right out the window, now? Or is there a way he could petition to get his appearance moved until after he returns? His work has slowed way, way down and he can't afford his rent in the city until work picks back up again, so if he has to stay here he's gonna be even more financially screwed. Assuming there's a way to petition to get the appearance moved, is that something that would be doable self-service, or would he need to find a lawyer for that?
Question 3: Let's assume for the moment that he's not telling the truth (or remembering wrong because he was wasted), and the cops actually caught him red-handed. He's got no criminal record of any kind--is he likely to be able to plead this down to something like a violation and paying restitution to the deli owner? Or his he pretty much doomed to have a class A misdemeanour on his record?
Posted Feb 11, 2020, 6:48 PM UTC