the vegans who crashed Bernie's rally to protest his support of animal agriculture are right

sorry libs

Posted Feb 17, 2020, 5:52 AM UTC

017

Or maybe we should be concerned about people having enough food (e.g. children who go hungry without school lunches during the summer) before we consider the ethics of their food?

20
Turtle-HerdGramsci Crackers•

All else being equal, that's 100% the right response. But, I think it's a bit like saying "we should be concerned about people being able to heat their houses and turn on the lights" as a defense of coal-fired powerplants. Are factory-farmed animal products hyper-convenient? Yes. But the externalities they create and the systems they prop up/are propped up by are unconscionable. We don't have to become vegan overnight, but resisting movement in that direction seems reactionary. We can be concerned about both at the same time.

6

Except these kinds of vegans aren't just against factory farming, their against the consumption of all animal products, including things like honey. There are infinite points on the spectrum between what they want and the excessive meat consumption we have in the US right now.

Moreover, this is the domain of affluent people. The poor living in food deserts are struggling to get fresh produce, so the transition to veganism is something they can't afford.

8
Turtle-HerdGramsci Crackers•

I agree that if we eliminated animal products today the vast majority of Americans would see their diets lose variety and suffer to meet nutritional guidelines (take it from someone who ate rice and beans for several months, it isn't enjoyable), but a vegan movement wouldn't just eliminate animal products and call it a day; in my mind, veganism as a movement is an intersection between climate advocacy, animal ethics, and food security. The bourgeois approach is to dump meat and move on, a socialist approach would ensure a transition to a more humane approach to feeding everyone.

2
knowyourbroccoli•

Yup. Veganism is a reaction to factory farming rather than the consumption of animal products. The right approach is indeed ending factory farms, and using the subsidies they receive to support the redevelopment of local food systems that, by virtue of operating on a smaller scale, nearly always ending up using more humane and sustainable husbandry practices whether that was the intention or not.

2

And which approach do you think these kinds of militant vegans favor?

1
knowyourbroccoli•

See my comment below. Veganism wouldn't exist in any meaningful way if we moved back towards local-scale food production, which is the right thing to do in many ways.

0
Shirakawasuna•

These are not in opposition. You can easily do both: advocate for veganism and food guarantees for all, including children.

If anything, veganism would marginally help that situation because it would make food cheaper. Animal products are very energetically costly and we feed about 70% of our crops to animals rather than people. Imagine having 3X the food we do now. It wouldn't fix all the systemic problems of malnutrition, but it would help.

These kinds of false choices are the bread and butter of chud arguments, by the way.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

11
Turtle-HerdGramsci Crackers•

I mean, if you're going to get any candidate to change their mind on something like this, it'd probably be Bernie

5
knowyourbroccoli•

Because they think he should be further left on the issue. I don't disagree, and while I wouldn't do what they did, I respect that they did it.

5
Shirakawasuna•

Because their form of advocacy short-sighted at best, malicious at worst.

But they're right that Bernie's support of the dairy industry is bad.

3
makecowsnotwarHypocrite that you are for you trust the chemicals in your brain•

Right in what way? In a moral sense? Are we subjectively weighing the altruistic value of two actions as a balancing test? Are there objective standards to this? Are we deciding with or without broader context? Are we measuring it by the effectiveness of the message? The total good created by the act?

5
BernieStanders2020•

Yeah, good. Ok.

5
chris010390Friend of the show•

Under Bernie, people would have money to spend on vegan alternatives. Problem solved.

3
ArabismoBoss steals my surplus value, State steals my taxes. Society=Fuk•

Wrecker

2