What makes a judicial opinion a "leading" opinion?
I've been doing some work on a niche issue for my part-time job. The issue is recently emerging and I'd estimate that >90% of people (professors and classmates) I've talked to about it have never heard of the legal question or the real-world subject matter raising the question.
There are probably fewer than a dozen cases ruling on the issue in some way. One of the opinions is particularly extensive and well-reasoned, and I've come to think of and refer to it as the "leading" opinion on the issue. That got me to thinking... what makes an opinion "leading"? Influence over subsequent decisions? Soundness in reasoning? Longevity?
Posted Feb 18, 2020, 3:11 AM UTC
14