People who makes millions or billions on a business are not greedy.

They've employed thousands of people. They've done massive good for many people's lives and taken huge risks to do so. I don't even care if they give to charity afterwards. They could spend their lives performing mutually beneficial transactions legally and fill a building size vault full of gold coins and swim around in it. They earned it.

Posted Feb 20, 2020, 2:03 PM UTC

1864
throwaway_0876•

I would be way less critical if:

  • they and their companies would pay their taxes in any country they sold something. They use the states infrastructure way more, they depend on a functioning state way more, they should pay their fair share.

  • they would not lobby the way they do. Arguing for or against certain positions and policies is understandable, they have an important perspective and role. But they should not buy their way into it with bribed politicians or faked scientific papers.

  • pay their labourers in developing countries a living wage so that their children can get a decent education and fight for their human rights.

  • accepting unions as a necessary counterweight for their employees and trying to cooperate with it.

  • give a shit about the environment.

Of course this will never happen because any huge company that will do it will have a severe disadvantage against their competition. So the states need to create an equal playing field internationally. And that is, to put it mildly, a political clusterfuck. But the EU is a good start for that.

8
belterman•

I struggle to understand how you assume billionaired "earned it". Do you assume the so-called "risks" they take equate to the amount of wealth they have accumulated? I live in the UK where there are about 150 billionaires and over 14 million people live in poverty.

Maybe you don't fully understand how much a billion actually is. The median income in Britain today is £29,400. It would take the average person 34,013 years to make £1 billion.

Disregarding the obvious disparity between the top 1% in Britain and the myriad of people in poverty. The money hoarded by billionaires is 100% of the time made from the exploitation of working people and using public services that are paid for by taxpayers. To be honest, you just have to look at Jeff Bezos as a prime example . He is now the richest man in the world with a net worth of over $100 billion (that’s just under 3.5 million years of wages on the average US salary). But despite this, Amazon workers work in some of the most inhumane working conditions in the world on an average salary of $28,500 a year. Last year, Amazon paid precisely $0 in tax in the US and barely anything in the UK.

I understand your point is about them not being "greedy". Have you considered it takes around $300 billion to end climate change? Or the minimal $30 billion to end world hunger (per year obviously)? - which is less than a third of Bezos' wealth.

2
theKalmar•

You can be greedy and employ people. As an example would be if you didnt pay your workers what would be considered a living wage because you want more in your pocket.

1
UtMedOP•

Living wage is pretty subjective though. And if your workers don't want to work for what you're offering, they'll leave. And if you want good people, you pay them more. If all employers had to pay people to keep them was minimum wage, why do most (90% plus of adults) make more than minimum wage?

2
theKalmar•

Or you could back unions so employers dont have all the power. There are tons of ways to fuck your employees.

1
UtMedOP•

I'm not against unions. They're restricted on what they can demand by how much the company makes. A good union helps make a company profitable by keeping its members productive and doing quality work. But unions can overstep. Hostess had to shut down (not sure if they were bankrupted or not) because of their union problems. They wanted more than the failing pastry company could provide. Fortunately other companies bought up bits and pieces of it so now we have twinkies again. Yay!

I can't however back public unions. And neither should anyone who is anti corruption. There's no limitation on what they demand of governments. And no incentive for politicians to push back against them. The public unions fund their campaigns. And the politicians bankrupt their state and or nation as applicable to give them the best contracts. Even better than the private market in many cases. Its a "you scratch my back I'll scratch yours and then escape any responsibility because I won't be in office when the state is bankrupted anyway" situation. It's gross.

1
theKalmar•

So exactly like it is in america now? Some rich guy who is proven corrupt gets elected and only do stuff for the rich? Your system is so broken you cant even so unions right.

1
toastedstapler•

if your workers don't want to work for what you're offering, they'll leave

Only if there is a better option

Look at how many people in the US have no savings and live paycheck to paycheck, why haven't they all left for a better alternative?

1
UtMedOP•

That's an individual decision. Lots of factors go into it. I don't have a one size fits all solution for that because there isn't one. But if you're alluding to an increased minimum wage you're only going to put those people out of work. How kind of you.

0
toastedstapler•

i'm alluding to nothing. i am directly saying that it's ignorant to think that there are better options for everyone. it's nearly half of americans, that's half the jobs. there's clearly something bigger wrong with the system than just an 'individual decision' if it's half the country

1
UtMedOP•

Shareholders, including those employees? They're evil? No. It isn't exploitation to voluntarily enter into an exchange of goods and services for money. You've read too much Marx and apparently not spent enough time in the work force. Start a business. Get some life experience

1
gosh02•

1.) it’s not every millionaire that’s bad, however ALOT ARE. 2.) those employees live paycheck to paycheck.

0
UtMedOP•
  1. I'm gonna need evidence and your definition of "a lot" because most small business owners are millionaires on paper. Because they own assets.
  2. Gonna need evidence for that too. And a consideration of who is really at fault. Most folks have abysmal spending habits. Most adults make more than minimum wage
2
gosh02•

Gonna need you to be specific about your definition of “millionaire” then. What I took it as and I’m sure most other people did too wasnt a “small business company”. I was talking about the standard definition of millionaire: Rich CEOs that under pay their employees and dude do you research yourself. You can’t live off of 7.25$ an hour and if you need proof then get a minimum paying job and just try to support a family YOURSELF. The “millionaires” could spend an extra part of their business towards it employees and not just into the business to make more and more profit. The incentive is for money not well being of the people making the money for you. Yeah that shits gotta change.

0
UtMedOP•

Millionaire. Someone with more than 1 million dollars in cash and/or assets. And believe me, I know what you can and can't do with 7.25 an hour. When I got in the workforce the minimum was 5.15. Inflations a bitch and I hated getting paid so little. So I stopped working at a movie theater and delivered pizzas. Then I became a store manager. If you're an adult in this country making minimum wage you need a mirror to find the person to blame for that. And yes, companies try to pay as little as they can. Just like we try to buy goods priced as low as we can. But no one is forced to work for minimum wage. They're not enslaved. They can leave and find new work.

2
gosh02•

No man, you clearly don’t know how hard it is to secure a good job for the younger people these days. And it’s because older people already have them. I’m telling you not everyone gets equal opportunities in today’s world and not everyone gets to go to college to get the six figure jobs.

1
Vasuki44•

The idea that billionaires employ people is patently false, though. They don't. Corporations employ people. Corporations created by the labor of workers and the capital invested in them. If billionaires didn't exist or they had their wealth redistributed, the capital would still exist and would still be being invested in the economy.

The billionaires aren't at all required for the system to function, they've just popped themselves on the top of the system and engorged themselves.

0
UtMedOP•

When you measure people's net worth their stock and assets are a part of it. Bezos doesn't have billions in cash. He has billions in assets. In stock. In his company. That he owns. That employs thousands of people. What are you smoking?

1
Vasuki44•

Yes. That's what I explained to you. Do you not understand what "capital" means in economic terms? Shares in a business are "capital". You buy the share, providing funding to the corporation. This is known as an investment, and you receive money for having done that, known as dividends.

Does that make sense to you or do you need me to explain it again with more detail?

0
UtMedOP•

You don't receive money for your stock until you sell it but it is still calculated as part of your net worth because you own it. If Facebook stock went to 1 cent tomorrow everyone would say Zuckerberg "lost billions" but has he lost any cash in his bank account? No.

If it then doubled what it was before it dropped to one cent they'd say he doubled his money. But what he invested in the company hasn't changed. His net worth has because he owns it. But unless he divests, that money is still in the company and making it run. It is at risk. As you point out, it is funding the corporation and allowing people to work for it. I'm not sure where the disconnect is here. I think we're saying the same thing and just talking past each other.

Also, why so hostile man? Geeze

0
Vasuki44•

I'm not being hostile. I apologize if I offended you, but I'm just trying to be clear.

Now, I see where you've made your mistake, you don't have a complete understanding of how stocks work. You do, of course, receive money for your stock before you sell it. These are called dividends. Basically, ever economic quarter, the quarter of a year, a sum of money is taken from the profit of a company. This is then divided up based on how many shares there are currently being owned.

So, if a private company decided that it was taking $100,000 from its profit, and it had 100 shares in ownership, each share is worth $1000. So, if you owned 10 shares, the company would send you dividends of $10,000.

Here, you can read about it. Perhaps this will explain things better.

As to the funding of the company... yes, that's how companies are funded. Through the capital. But as I explained before, the billionaire is not required for the company to run. Only the capital is. So if we got rid of billionaires and redistributed that wealth, the wealth would still exist. It would still be invested companies, there just wouldn't be a billionaire at the top taking money.

We could and should run the system without the billionaire, because he doesn't actually add anything.

Has this made more sense? Do you see where we're disagreeing?

1