r/Star_Trek•
HaySwitch

'Do you really want to go back out into the cold?'

It's been like two/three weeks since I heard this line in Picard and I just can't stop thinking about it.

Like it's obviously the writers trying really hard to be profound but it doesn't make any sense.

The spaceships Picard served on were like hotels on terms of comfort and everyone there wanted to explore space and enjoyed the adventure. Of course,sometimes a console exploded and killed you but that's not a being in space problem, that's a 'being in torpedo range' problem.

Plus the show is loved by people who want to go into space or know more about it. The line just makes it seem like serving in Starfleet is some gruelling national service rather than a chance to experience the universe.

I really don't like it when shows try to make you feel guilty for enjoying their main appeal. Making it sound like space is horrible to be in really works in something like the expanse but not Star Trek. Same thing happened when Alfred kept getting mad at Bruce Wayne for being Batman in the Dark Knight Rises. Like fuck off I've waited four years and one hour to see Batman again.

Don't get me wrong I enjoy a good deconstruction of popular tropes and characters but I don't think the return of Picard is the appropriate context for how grim space exploration can be. I don't want somebody who thinks space is horrible to be writing my Star Treks.

And in terms of writing. Who the fuck talks like that? It's not natural. It just sounds weighty and smart but it's just not. I don't know why bad writers seem to think every other line has to be poetic for it to be good. Writing something that sounds real should be your priority before anything else.

But then 'I can understand why you'd jump at the chance to go back but this situation could get very dangerous' wouldn't sound very good in the trailer, would it?

Sorry complete rant and nitpick but it's really been stuck in my brain since I heard it.

Posted Feb 20, 2020, 11:13 PM UTC

2239
Loading comments…