bullying is how society reinforces its norms

obviously bullying can be destructive and very cruel but ultimately whether it’s done by children or adults (unless its for personal manipulation and gain) bullying/shunning/shaming all have a place in curbing and controlling behavior. this are social tools of maintaining cultural “order”.

i’m not saying this is right but i am saying this is how we socially govern ourselves and alter each other’s behavior.

Posted Feb 21, 2020, 4:17 AM UTC

810

i guess the extrapolation of this is that violence is how society reinforces its norms. Yeah that is pretty self evident. Like if we want the society that doesn't want to have murder, the society will often give a state or an organization the power to kidnap and lock people up in cages for committing murder sometimes even killing them.

5
e-aremyfriend•

I mean other than don't kill and don't steal I don't really see any norms that should be reinforced

4
137free•

And grizzly Adams has a beard

3
[deleted]•

The opinion we needed and weren’t ready to hear.

2
youngproperOP•

your comment made me feel better than anything else this week

2
youngproperOP•

maybe bullying is micro policing behavior?

2
darthsheoggorath•

Take a bronze award

2
youngproperOP•

my first award! thank you :3

2
MellowTones•

I disagree. You mention shaming and shunning - yes they may support social norms, but when they do they’re not necessarily bullying (especially if they’re desirable social norms). What people normally think of as bullying is motivated by far darker ideas and strikes out not necessarily at those who are out of line, but instead at those who are vulnerable or marginalised in some way. In such common cases it’s not reinforcing any social norms, as those bullied are unlikely to be unable to change their race or heights or physique or problems with acne or timing of puberty or size of their privates or sexual orientation or parents’ wealth or occupations. The bully is as likely to be motivated by their own insecurities or unpleasant experiences, or be experimenting with interpersonal power, or taking out their frustrations, rather than trying to normalise someone else’s behaviour.

2
youngproperOP•

As an individual actor, yes, bullying is probably mostly motivated by the things you’ve listed above. (btw, “experimenting with interpersonal power” is great phrasing). But overall, this serves to assert larger power dynamics and often power imbalances in a nearly systemic fashion. By making fun of people for their features which are not chosen or controlled, bullying serves to mark disapproval or rejection.

(Your comment is the best i’ve seen on unpopularopinions so far)

1