Bought a UMIK, downloaded REW, solved my bass issue and then some - these are great tools to improve your setup. Here are some charts showing how a few measurements made my ears and wallet very happy.
Short version:
Been wanting to improve my bass performance and thinking about buying a new sub, but through the magic of a couple of hours spent with UMIK, REW, and my AVR's onboard settings I solved the issue while also discovering just how low my system was actually currently extending. The title image shows the initial sweep and bass deficiency in the 50-150HZ range (and confirms my subscription to the 'Harman Target Curve' club with some extra bass to get TR even with all the concrete...) along with the drastic improvement achieved solely through change of crossover frequency, tweaking of sub distance setting, and a touch of EQ for flavor.
Long version:
My 5.1, 50/50 music/theater-use system consists of an Onkyo NR656 pushing Revel F35 fronts, an Emotiva C2 center, Jamo S809 surrounds, and a boat anchor DIY sealed 15" sub. Listening position is about 8 feet from the fronts and a little less to the center and sub. It's all tucked into a small basement 'bump-out' that opens up into a space at least 3000 cu ft. Placement of the F35s is near both side and rear boundaries, spots that conventional wisdom says are a no-no for floorstanders.
I've been doing car audio since high school and have spent years playing in bands and recording in good studios, so I've always felt comfortable with my ear and ability to tune systems. I didn't bother with AccuEQ in my current setup and was pretty happy overall but as noted above felt that the bass was lacking. My sub is currently placed in a sub-crawl approve location but the overall bass just wasn't as big and clean as I felt I could get in this space so I picked up the UMIK as a precursor to maybe grabbing a new sub (eg VTF3, with lots of midbass).
Jumping right into it I calibrated to 75 db (so as to not disturb those sleeping upstairs) and my first measurement showed that I was lacking right where I thought it was (not good) but also that my sub was digging surprisingly deep (is good), even moreso than I realized... it's comfortably below 20 Hz:
When looking at the sweep I noticed that my crossover, currently 70 Hz, seemed to be in the heart of the midbass suck. I decided to do some more measurements with various crossover frequencies from 50-100 Hz to see how things changed... man was that eye-opening. My sub is on the front wall and right inside of my right speaker so I was really surprised to see just how drastically the performance changed as I varied the crossover. This pic, psychoacoustically smoothed since it's the bass region and since I'm only worried about how it will perform in my room, shows the various sweeps with crossovers ranging from 50 Hz to 100 Hz:
However, I thought I'd try for more. After settling on the notably-improved 80 Hz frequency I decided to tinker with the distance setting. Subs often have a longer distance entered to help offset for any processing time required for an onboard amp, so mine was at 12.9 ft. Once again though, adjusting that to the randomly-chosen 6 ft distance and adding just a dash of EQ yielded even more improvement, to the tune of ~4 db at 75 Hz:
As shown in the title image and again here, the improvement is drastic both on the charts and to my ears. I've been sitting here reveling (pun intended) in this refreshed bass sound while I wrote this and it's exactly what I was hoping for in thinking about a new sub.
The icing on the cake though is that I now also have confirmation that my current sub is providing plenty of output and extension at my listening levels. Something like a VTF3 or one of PSA/Rythmik's offerings would likely afford more headroom at those lowest octave and may do so with less distortion but even without measurements I never really felt that part of things was lacking.
Long post but I thought I'd share in hopes of encouraging more folks to dive into the world of measuring their own systems and getting things where they want them via positioning and analysis rather than wasting money and/or just trusting room correction to to get things right. Happy measuring!
Posted Feb 23, 2020, 8:31 AM UTC · edited
I have my UMIK and mic stand ready alongside my Audyssey App waiting for the full installation of my kit. Currently rocking a 4.1 with a few notable issues according to the Audyssey App graphs but it still sounds pretty bloody awesome.
Can't wait to get into this kind of tweaking!
As many before me have said and I now know for myself, it's great to see this stuff 'on paper' like this and can lead to very striking improvements. You'll dig it once you're up and running!