PvE fear mechanic in vanilla and classic WoW

Question

Hello all. The way fear is working in classic PvE troubled me so much, to the point I’m making this post, asking for your help. Currently, classic PvE Bosses are not resetting threat for the duration of fear.

What I remember: As a MT, I remember that once you got feared, you were losing all threat for the duration of the fear. Once fear was off, your threat was back to the pre-freared state. As a result, if all the raid (maybe that’s only for the melee, not range, but I’m not sure) was getting feared, the boss was still attacking the MT. But if anyone resisted/removed the fear he was getting aggro. That’s what I remember of Onyxia and Nefarian. That was also true for Nightbane, up until a patch in tbc, that changed/nerfed fear mechanic to its current state.

What I found: I tried to confirm that, by watching videoς, but still I haven't found a proper one, with MT getting feared and OT breaking fear and taking aggro while being below second threat place. But I found the TBC Patch 2.3.0 ( source) states:

World environment - Creature AI has been changed to no longer prioritize attacking unfeared targets over feared targets.

Please can you elaborate more on the above issue? Is the PvE fear mechanic the same for vanilla and classic or not? Has this issue already been addressed somewhere else? Many thanks

Posted Feb 23, 2020, 2:56 PM UTC

8838
lanter624•

Just put / so u don’t run like a headless chicken

30
NostalgiaSchmaltz•

My god. This man has finally found a good use for RP walking in PvE.

27
one_love_silvia:horde::rogue:•

Bro this is big brain as fuck. Does it work in pvp too?

21
Aleriya:alliance:•

I tested this in a duel, and you still run at full speed.

12
one_love_silvia:horde::rogue:•

Thank you for the research

10
TopographyDog:horde:•

doesn’t work

5
whateverthefuck2•

Do you have to press it before the fear goes off or can you press it while feared?

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Zwyk:horde:•

Found this record of Onyxia, was posted before 2.3.0 patch and it seems like the tank does drop aggro when he gets feared (right at the start of the video).

Post this in bug report forums! You can use this video.

22
Xossdk:horde::warrior:•

just want to add this vanilla-era uploaded video (jul 2006) with target change each fear in p3

https://youtu.be/OJZ75VMbMsg?t=175

E: updated this magmadar bug report post with info https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/wow/t/magmadars-fear-is-not-dropping-agro-from-the-feared-mt/360967

3
-Atlan-•

2.3 is very different than vanilla.

-20
I_Fap_To_Zamasu_2•

Try reading the thread and the comment you reply to before replying yourself. Really good way to clear up the confusion you are having.

16
kaazmodan:alliance::hunter:•

Hence the video was posted "before" 2.3

4
Ares42•

PvE mobs in general would ignore CCd players over non-CCd players, so you are correct that it's how it's supposed to work (but currently isn't).

This is also why a lot of people have had issues with Onyxia in Classic, since in Vanilla you would just have everyone but the tank eat the fear when she lands and as long as you kept range and did nothing it was highly unlikely you'd pull her off the tank.

14
ChBartowski•

I remember clearly in Vanilla, if any boss feared the tank and the rest of the raid, and I immuned it with wotf I would get aggro immediately. Not so in Classic, picking up Onyxia in phase 3 can be a mess.

11
Miguelsanchezz•

You are correct. One of the reasons dwarf priests were so useful for ony is you could use a fear ward rotation to avoid this.

Stance dancing on Ony used to be critical if you didn’t have fear ward (now most tanks don’t seem to bother)

9
Crysth_Almighty•

It can also come faster than their cooldown on berserker rage. So even if they wanted, they can’t dance them all.

1
nodette•

Yup small window to get fucked, it was Vanilla way for sure.

1
7
Xossdk:horde::warrior:•

Updated this old magmadar bug report on this topic with ony and patch note info

https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/wow/t/magmadars-fear-is-not-dropping-agro-from-the-feared-mt/360967

1
moose_number2:alliance::druid:•

You are 100% correct OP. I hadn't noticed this because we have Fear Ward.

Suck it Horde.

7
twizztedbz81:horde::rogue:•

We have tremor totem.

6
moose_number2:alliance::druid:•

Tank gets feared, Onyxia/Nefarian switches targets. Takes up to 5 seconds for Tremor Totem to work, meaning you have up to 5 seconds of Onyxia/Nefarian smashing your DPS. This mechanic was very painful for Horde.

5
twizztedbz81:horde::rogue:•

Still, not much of an issue.

-2
moose_number2:alliance::druid:•

K

1
Headsplitter•

Still, not much of an issue

All I hear is "Cries in Orcish"

^^Kek

1
nodette•

Yea but I’m a bad player, so blizzard should fix this to help me out. It is broken so why not

1
Gnomefurywarrior:alliance::paladin:•

Prevention is better than cure.

3
lectrin•

That sounds brutal, lets bury this lol

5†
Slacker_RaiderOP:horde::warrior:•

Actually, if MT and OT coordinate their Berserking Rage, it's easier, because the boss will not move at all. Nowadays, the boss will always chase the MT, that may lead to a different tanking position.

12
Uyee•

The MT getting feared into melee and onxy then breathes on all the melee killing them.

2
GrayMagicGamma•

Could also guarantee classes without threat drops don't have aggro at the start of Onyxia phase 3 by just not Fear Warding them.

1
nodette•

This will let warriors go crazy before she takes flight? Because right now rogues go crazy when she’s about to fly, and then vanish for an aggro dump.

1
nodette•

Ahhhhhh th at is strange that it’s always an MT chase. Used to be much more aggro drop.

1
the_flyingdemon:alliance::rogue:•

Do not want lol.

-1
Lightshoax•

This is indeed how the boss's behavior should work. Should be super easy to test on their internal client as well.

2
Lodekim:horde::druid:•

I was actually wondering if I was remembering wrong. I remember it being a huge deal to stance dance the fears on Nef especially for this reason (also Ony but her fear cooldown is shorter so you were going to miss some no matter what).

2