r/canada•
nas

Comcast CTO: $6.85 to double bandwidth, Canadian ISPs: $2/GB, can you say cash grab?

tldr from the article:

[Comcast CTO stated] it only costs an average of $6.85 per home to DOUBLE the bandwidth capacity of an entire neighborhood

Posted Jan 26, 2011, 3:39 PM UTC · edited

13922
beatjunkeeAlberta•

Hey! Internet cost more up here because of shipping costs, duty fees & taxes, thought you all knew that? If they didn't charge more, how would the ISP's make money? Sheesh

9
aurthunderdrake•

A great message to send to all the yuppies out there. Until people realize how bad we're getting screwed by the telecom industry, these yuppies need to be force fed outside perspective to contrast.

2
Koss424•

Wait a minute, I'm a yuppie

1
redditmemehater•

lol yuppies

-2
jgzman•

Fuck doubling my bandwidth, I just want Comcast to deliver the goddamn bandwidth I'm paying for!

2
xfinity•

But you get Xfinity with more Xfinity in it than we previously used to deliver prior to Xfinity

1
jgzman•

Do I now? Can I trade it in for the promise of more bandwidth?

1
jreid42•

You can't compare metrics like this so why bother. Canada's population is tiny and spread out across a country almost the same size as the United States (in terms of livable area). I think 2$/GB is a bit extreme, but nonetheless stop comparing USA prices to Canada.

-10
TurtleStrangulation•

Oh no, not that argument again! The vast majority of the Canadian population lives within 100km of the US Border, while the US population is spread across a huge country. Canada's population density sure is a convenient excuse for telecom companies, but it's in no way linked to the ridiculous cap overage fees.

$2/GB is not "a bit" extreme, it's downright obscene.

21
Private_SubManitoba•

Even in slightly rural areas, there is no cable or DSL capability. They can't charge to upgrade something they never bothered to build in the first place.

7
gusey•

There's thousands of kilometers of dark fiber laid down by government money that no one's using. The infrastructure for long distance point to point communication is already there, it's just the 'last mile' in the case of those rural areas. Also, there's plenty of rural areas with cable or dsl already

1
untogethered•

I'm not saying that this is the answer, but you should bear in mind the radically different population densities of the US and Canada. It isn't fair to directly compare the two countries sometimes.

-12
[deleted]•

If were going to argue the old density issue, then tell me why major cities like Toronto and Montreal have relatively atrocious service/price compared to similar cities around the world?

17
untogethered•

That isn't really connected, though. The original post says that it costs the average house $6.85 to double neighbourhood bandwidth. Canadian neighbourhoods are more spread out, therefore it isn't impossible to imagine that it costs more.

As for why inner cities have shitty service, well, they don't operate in a bubble. Bell provides service to the entire country, and it's quite possible that inner city users effectively subsidise those in remote areas. Is that fair? Perhaps not. But if it didn't happen then people in remote areas would pay astronomically high fees for internet access.

-11
troubleondemandCanada•

That would be great and all except they don't service a lot of the rural areas at all still. They also get subsidies specifically for that reason.

6
TurtleStrangulation•

As for why inner cities have shitty service, well, they don't operate in a bubble. Bell provides service to the entire country, and it's quite possible that inner city users effectively subsidise those in remote areas.

Vidéotron operates only in non-shithole Québec cities, yet it charges $4.50/GB past its 40GB cap. Try to explain that.

0
untogethered•

I don't know anything about them, but if they're a non-government subsidised private company then I imagine they are maximising their profit in the full knowledge that there is no viable cheaper alternative for users.

2
logicom•

At least they have a plan with an overcharge limit that puts the maximum charge you can ever pay at around $90 (it's a little over $100 if you don't have any bundled services). Still very expensive for only 7.5 mbps but not as obscene as the others.

1
soldates•

Who cares, you already steal cable / satellite / music / movies / everything else from the US. Now you have to "pay" for internet and your mad? - lawl.

-17
Oxyfire•

I'm not sure if you're being sarcastic, or a moron, but I'll assume the second.

It's not about "paying," it's about paying too much. The cost vs. what we pay is outrageous, UBB only gives Telcom more power.

7
CrazyJoey•

Aw man, don't feed the trolls! Still, an upvote for your efforts.

2