r/PioneerMTG•
fdoom

LSV and Matt Nass discuss the State of Pioneer | The Ban Wagon

Posted Feb 25, 2020, 9:30 PM UTC

105103
MC_GD•

I hope they ban breach and inverter, DTT and TC are fun :D

37
stratusncompany•

what is TC?

4
SteveBot24•

Tauren Chieftain

28
moe_q8•

Is he elite?

7
ary31415•

Very

1
Stealthsneak•

Treasure cruise

17
Exatraz•

Also there really isn't another constructed format where DTT can be played. If it can't be played in Pioneer, that'll be the final nail in it's coffin. I think you leave it in the format for as long as possible.

3

Of the two, DTT is borderline and TC is perfectly fine. I wouldn't lament the loss of DTT too much, as the card is very, very pushed, but I also don't lament it's existence either.

I heartily disagree with their reasoning on Treasure Cruise, however. The level between the two in Pioneer is significant, and Cruise isn't a full 1-to-1 switch for Dig at all. I would be very disappointed to see it banned "just in case".

3
Remember_Navarro•

Good insight as always, thanks chaps!

I'm of the opinion that they won't ban DTT and TC yet as there aren't really other broken decks around that abuse these + maybe phoenix can make a comeback after they deal with inverter and breach.

26
dmk510•

Sadly phoenix just isn't up to snuff in pioneer with or without inverter and breach. Maybe if you can will 3 phoenix to your top 20 every game you can win a gp.

I think the question revolving around cruise and dig are, can these combo decks be brought to a reasonable level if they didn't have double demonic tutor (obviously exaggerating digs power slightly)? Also, as they touched on, since the cards are likely to become problematic eventually, banning them now to avoid banning something else and then ending up banning them anyways is a legit consideration.

Whatever they decide I hope they do it soon because the format is not particularly healthy imo.

34
Exatraz•

For Inverter, I personally think it gets better without DTT in the format because it makes their discard that much more brutal and they'll be able to replace it's delve with other spells like Tasigur and Gurmag Angler (or going Sultai for Uro) and have a solid backup plan that still has a resilient combo finish.

0
stormie_sarge•

That makes them less dedicated to the combo, and having to utilize two different wincons. The deck will be more of a delve creature fatty deck with a side of combo, kinda like possibility storm.

1
Exatraz•

Sure but my point being is that I don't think it'll substatially hurt their win rate enough to keep it from continuing to dominate the format.

1
Inquisitr•

Pheonix was on the way out before Theros ever dropped. It's not coming back

7
agokbvdru•

But this sub won’t have any comments if there’s not several people asking if this post means Phoenix will be meta again.

2
kami_inu•

We need a bot that just replies "r/pioneer, stop trying to make phoenix happen. It's not going to happen!"

2
TheDarkBebop•

Yo, why’s the dude in the grey hoodie double checking every three seconds that the large man is not about to strangle him?

26
welshy1986•

This is the most underrated comment I think I've ever read in the MTG community. Get you someone who looks at you the way Matt Nass looks at LSV.

10
tallandgodless•

"Why isn't he strangling me yet? Did I do something wrong? Is he not in the mood?"

9
ViviCetus•

What's the wincon in common between the two busted decks in Pioneer? [[Thassa's Oracle]]? That's a good place to start, then.

DTT wasn't busted before Oracle. What is this sub's/ Wizard's methodology for bans?

15
mkurdmi•

That won't even hit lotus breach. A ton of the current lotus breach lists aren't even playing oracle, they just wish for a jace from the sb. The only way to justify that is if we're trying nerf inverter (by making the one turn combo harder, cutting the amount of combo pieces, etc.)... but it seems to me like a DTT ban accomplishes that better by heavily weakening whole control aspect of their gameplan where they just out cardadvantage the opponent so that attacking the combo itself is a stronger plan.

26
rapidcalm•

Both decks can also win with Jace, Wielder of Mysteries.

Lotus Field was just fine without Breach, so it's easy to see that one ban knocks it back down.

Inverter is an interesting ban puzzle to solve and I don't envy their position. Do you ban Dig through Time? If so, you risk cutting out other decks that use the card for significantly less nefarious purposes, and I think they want to avoid having something like this happen again after the Mox Opal ban inadvertently killed Affinity. Do you ban both Thassa's Oracle and Jace, Wielder of Mysteries? That's a very clunky solution to this problem and you leave yourself vulnerable to Inverter potentially being a problem again. Do you ban Inverter? It seems weird to lower the power level on Lotus Breach while you just kill this deck. I suppose you could lower the power level of the deck by banning Thoughtseize, but that's a very unpopular solution that likely has bad long-term ramifications for the format.

I think those are the options on the table when it comes to Inverter. I think they're likely to kill Inverter, but Dig and Oracle will probably face the chopping block at some point.

14
Inquisitr•

Killing other decks that are fair didn't stop them from banning faithless looting, and it hasn't stopped them in the past either.

Dig and TC is a good ban

10
ViviCetus•

Opal also killed Lantern Control. Should've banned Urza instead.

3
ThisHatRightHere•

Banning Thoughtseize would be one of the worst things they could do to Pioneer. Yes, the card is obviously very powerful, but it’s also the best tool the format has to counteract powerful decks like Inverter and Breach.

I think there are a lot of ways to weaken Lotus Breach but keep the deck and it’s play style intact. But Inverter is essentially a pile of the best U and B cards the format has, with the combo pieces slotted in. Banning one of either Oracle or Jace weakens it a bit, but essentially leaves the deck as it once they replace those four spots with more ways to find the combo. Makes things like Unmoored Ego better against it, but doesn’t change the very powerful play pattern the deck uses to win.

2
ManSeekingToucan•

Thoughtseize seems like it plays a similar role in the format as Force of Will in legacy. They both help keep unfair decks in check. Sure they can also be used by unfair decks themselves but they are a required card to exist in the format or it becomes a nightmare dystopia of combo decks.

2
MTGCardFetcher•

Thassa's Oracle - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
SonofaBeholder•

The idea behind banning DTT is it’s a known factor. It’s not a matter of “if” something breaks DTT, it’s “WHEN” something breaks DTT. It means they either have to stifle/depower any and every future set with graveyard matters as a theme, or wind up making the same mistake modern did and ban a bunch of other cards because of one ( the “mox opal” situation).

1
kami_inu•

What specific cards do you consider banned in modern for opal's sins? Artifact lands are an iffy unban only because to the opal banning and I have no issue with them being banned from day 1 (per how the modern ban list was run compared to pioneer). On a quick skim through the list everything else is independent of opal imo.

1
SonofaBeholder•

Definitely the artifact lands, though I’d have to agree at this point they probably need to stay banned because other equally broken cards on the same vein as Opal now exist.

I’d also say Krark Clan Ironworks (again at this point an unban would be pointless) because when Ironworks combo was the boogie man of the format one of the biggest reasons was its consistency combined with its speed. Opal was pretty much the main reason that deck was so fast, and banning it then and there would have been a better choice (Having gotten to play with an opal-less version once, I can tell you the deck was nowhere near as scary, still powerful but no more then say tron or hardened scales at the time.)

That being said, I also bring up Opal (the reason I called it the “Opal Situation” and not “the Hogaak situation”) because WotC admitted its ban was in large part “because of its potential to harm the future of the format [modern]”. So they’ve already set a precedent of banning problematic cards they know will eventually get broken well in advance.

1
kami_inu•

I think it's not unreasonable to say the artifact lands would have been banned in short order had they not been on the initial ban list. OG modern affinity was already a strong deck without the artifact lands.

Similar for KCI - a big strength of that deck was being able to abuse rare timing loops with paying costs. Mopal was a key part of it, but I wouldn't be shocked if a refined mopal-less version was still strong enough to push the envelope too far. KCI letting you get around lots of timing restrictions IMO meant that it needed to go at some point so long as it was highly competitive. (And now it would have Emry/Amber anyway)

That quote isn't the full context of the opal ban either:

As the strongest enabler in the recent Urza artifact decks, and a card that has been concerning in the past and would likely cause balance issues in the future, Mox Opal is banned in Modern.

It was also the previous powerful (and sometimes ban worthy) decks that mopal was a part of. DTT doesn't have that extensive history yet, it's only been busted in nexus (where nexus was the clear problem) and now inverter. Dig has been fine in pioneer to date outside of those 2 combo decks where there's a bigger problem present. Compare to Treasure Cruise in modern, where even burn splashed for it.

1
Exatraz•

A lot of Breach decks aren't even running Oracle anymore and have moved to Expansion // Explosion instead. That said, I do think Oracle was a mistake and could easily be the ban target of choice from the Inverter deck, you still need to hit Breach or Lotus Field though.

1
cateater3735•

‘DTT wasn’t busted before oracle’

Lol good one

-1†
GeRobb•

It wasn't broken in Pioneer, it was however very broken w/fetchlands, right?

Sigh, I would hate to see Oracle go, I love her in my MonoU devotion deck.

1
gkourou87•

They could absolutely leave TC alone, as it has to prove itself that can destroy a format.

8
Redineveryformat•

Do you not remember what happened to the other formats when it was still legal?
We even played treasure cruise in modern burn ffs.

-3
GeRobb•

Doesn't have the same "gas" in Pioneer that it had in Modern.

2
kami_inu•

Because it was a zero effort splash for what approached ancestral recall in any deck that wasn't already spread tight across multiple colours. It's not some casual splash for that power level in pioneer.

1
Bughferd•

TC shouldn't die for Digs sins. TC is much worse in these combo decks. They should be banned one at a time not together. Right now the only deck that uses TC is Phoenix and that's mostly because the whole deck is just gas so you only need a critical mass of cards rather than the right cards.

4
tdewald•

Dig shouldn't be banned for Inverter's sins. The card is fine outside of literally that one deck.

8†
SonofaBeholder•

DTT is and will always be a broken card. It wasn’t a matter of “if DTT gets broken in pioneer” it has always been “when DTT gets broken in pioneer”. It’s just too easy to completely break with any kind of decent graveyard synergy. So it creates a scenario where one of three things has to happen:

1.) WotC purposefully neuters all future graveyard themed sets and mechanics in hopes that weakening them will prevent a DTT break.

2.) WotC bans a bunch of other cards just to keep DTT in the format (the Mox Opal strategy)

3.) WotC bans DTT.

Most people tend to side with option 3 as the best. Yes it may suck to have to bite the bullet and go ahead with a DTT ban, but it’s better for the long run health of the format.

1†
tdewald•

4.) Wait until Dig is actually a problem and ban it then. That way people get to enjoy playing the card in the one format where it isn't currently too busted to allow play.

0†
SonofaBeholder•

So.... right now then. Let’s look at SCG Indy as an example: in a very large tournament where a majority of the day 2 decks were either Inverter decks or decks specifically designed to take down inverter, Inverter still saw a > 55% win rate and had 5 decks in the top 8, and 3 in the top 4 (all of which took 1st 2nd and 3rd place in the tournament.)

The reason for this was that inverter has an incredible amount of flexibility for a combo deck. Whereas just a few weeks ago aggro strategies like mono red and Boros aggro were the answer (being able to effectively “get under” inverter) by changing up just a few cards on the main and sideboard inverter wiped the floor with them.

The source of this flexibility is: DTT. DTT acting as card draw that can very reliably keep them up in the Card advantage game while simultaneously keeping their yard low for the combo allows the deck to devote more slots to answers. W/o DTT, the deck is forced to slot in more card draw and ways to keep their yard size down, removing much of its interaction and conversely making the deck much more easily interacted with.

3
Trei-Work•

No it's not. It was the reason Nexus of Fate got banned too.

-6
tdewald•

Nexus of Fate needed to be banned regardless. The card is nothing but problems for tournament play.

5
Trei-Work•

Same with DTT.

-5
Exatraz•

No, Nexus of Fate got Nexus of Fate banned.

2
Trei-Work•

K.

We'll just see how this next banning plays out.

1
BrendanLyga•

WotC are probably still deliberating on whether or not to ban Dig or Inverter, or both. I honestly do not know what the correct solution is. Maybe Inverter, because the other 2 card combo had a piece banned from it already and it wouldn't make sense to leave one legal and not the other.

2
Exatraz•

I really agree with pretty much everything said in this video and have been saying very similar things for a while (kinda nice when things you've said are also then said by people with the clout of Matt Nass and LSV). Changes need to be made to this format, it's only a matter of what needs to change.

I also wholly agree with LSV's sentiment at the end that they seem to be favoring DTT and Cruise in this format and that might result in a body count. It should be noted that I do think that even if you ban DTT, that doesn't fix the issues these combo decks put forward and as such, I see them banning Inverter or Oracle and then Breach or Lotus Field. Then they decide if they want to keep DTT in the format and I agree if you ban Dig, you probably have to ban Cruise as well. That said, I think they hold off on that for as long as possible.

1
Thadatus•

I hate how the second a combo gains traction people are immediately calling for bans :(

-4†
Merosi•

this is quite a bit above "gains traction", as it is the currently obvious best deck of the format.

17
Macblaze43flame•

It's the speed and consistency that makes them broken . If left unchecked every game will feel the same

13
Thadatus•

I guess I’m just a little upset because inverter was always that one janky pet card of mine

2
Exatraz•

There is still the chance that they hit Thassa's Oracle and you can still have the jankier Jace/Inverter deck that is far less consistent and far easier to interact with.

5
GeRobb•

I think Oracle should be the target to leave the Inverter/Jace deck in tact. It will still be playable, no one will play it, therefore it will die. Mission accomplished.

If Oracle goes, I will be very sad, she's so good in MonoU Devotion. :(

1
The_Upvote_Beagle•

The speed? You meaning on turn 6 at the earliest is too fast?

-6
GeRobb•

It's gone in 60 seconds fast, and don't you forget it.

Turn 6 keeps me from winning with my really crappy jank brew, that goes off on turn 11, and that's NOT fair.

2
The_Upvote_Beagle•

Agreed.

ITT: bunch of people that have never played against the deck and keep screaming “TURN 4 KILL!” and people pissed their yank deck can’t cut it

2
Exatraz•

It has nothing to do with the archetype and everything to do with the results. Any deck that puts up 24% of the PT metagame and then proceeds to win at above a 50% rate and put up the results that Inverter has (with multiple large events with many copies in top 8 including 5/8 at GP PHX and 4/8 at SCG Indy) is going to be banned.

2
Thadatus•

Yeah I know, I’m just upset that inverter is finally good and itd already be a waste to build it cause I’ve wanted to build this

1
GeRobb•

Preaching, man, preaching.

I had it sleeved, barely played it, un-sleeved it. Too many people playing it.

1
GeRobb•

I agree with you.

Opponent: "Because you're mean, and your combo kept me from enjoying my 8-12 turn deck, we need it to be banned."

F@ck sake.

2
tdewald•

I hope Dig doesn't get banned for the sins of Inverter. Being able to play with Dig and Cruise is one of the unique and fun things about Pioneer.

The fact of the matter is that when we talk about Dig being busted in every other format, those formats have all had some combination of fetches, cheap cantrips, busted mana, and/or other efficient ways to quickly fill the graveyard.

Lacking everything that made Dig/Cruise busted in other formats, Pioneer almost feels custom-tailored to contain these cards as very powerful yet not broken... until this one weird deck hit the scene.

I guess I'm just very tired of the argument that because Dig is broken in other formats, it is absolutely destined to be broken in Pioneer (a logical fallacy). Then people offer Inverter as proof, but it is not proof of anything other than that Dig is uniquely powerful in that particular deck for very specific reasons.

(While Lotus Breach also runs dig, it honestly doesn't even need it. Imo Breach seems very easy to hate out; Damping Sphere is amazing sideboard tech against it that any deck can run.)

-5†
iamcherry•

I hope Dig doesn't get banned for the sins of Inverter

Dig will always be too strong in a combo deck that leverages cheap spells, which is most combo decks. It makes comboing off too consistent. If you ban Inverter here, like mentioned in the video, it's just a waiting game on what dig combo deck is too powerful again. This isn't the first time Dig has created a powerful combo deck. The turbofog/nexus deck got a ban as well, and banning Dig likely would have been sufficient enough. Dig is too often insurmountable by decks that aren't playing the card, because so often it just ends up reading "UU, instant, tutor two of the best cards in your deck for the matchup."

12
DoomAtuhnNalra•

I agree whole heartily with everything said here. At the end of the day DTT is just a busted magic card in almost all formats outside of draft.

8
Flare-Crow•

Most combo decks like that in Pioneer would be heavily Graveyard-focused, meaning any GY hate would stop both their combo and DTT from being very effective. As OP said, every other Constructed Format it could be legal in has far too much ease in filling the 'Yard.

1
tdewald•

Well that didn't take long. The same old tired argument for banning Dig based on a predicted future rather than measurable data.

-6†
iamcherry•

Measurable data? The measurable data is that the decks that have leveraged Dig Through Time in Pioneer's short existence have all needed to be banned due to having absurdly high winrates and metashare (breach, Nexus, inverter)

Everyone talks about it being banned because the card is obviously broken and is resulting in bans, if you think otherwise you're intentionally being obtuse because you like the card. People said the same stuff about faithless looting and Mox opal.

6
BradleyThreat•

I think the problem with just banning dig through time in regards to those 3 decks you mentioned, is that even if you do, it's reasonably likely that you will have to (or, would have if nexus wasn't axed) ban something out of those shells in the future any way. It's the hogaak problem all over again.

Maybe I am being obtuse by hoping it doesn't get banned, but I don't really care to be honest. For once, I'm loving playing a good card selection spell in a fair control deck, it's the only thing that can drag me out of tight spots sometimes.

6
tdewald•

Nexus was rightly banned outright and Dig is far from busted in Breach (the deck doesn't even need it). That leaves Inverter, where Dig is admittedly too good.

Also, based on the data I've seen so far, Inverter and Breach don't actually have absurdly high win rates. In fact, recent results seem to indicate Breach is very easy to hate out altogether. Most of the winrates I've seen for Inverter hover around 55%, which is a bit high, but what really matters there is the overall win rate of Inverter in non-mirror matches... something only WotC knows.

Faithless Looting and Mox Opal are not good comparisons since they both enabled multiple busted decks in Modern, vs a single outlier in Pioneer. Also, just because 'everyone' is saying Dig needs a ban doesn't make that true. The MTG hive mind is notorious for being wrong, and there are plenty of examples proving it.

4
ary31415•

Lacking everything that made Dig/Cruise busted in other formats, Pioneer almost feels custom-tailored to contain these cards as very powerful yet not broken... until this one weird deck hit the scene.

"Dig isn't broken till it's broken"

This is obviously true but it's about the likelihood of breaking it. Put another way, your post boils down to a No True Scotsman fallacy wherein you claim:

"Dig is broken in every format except pioneer. What's that, it is broken in pioneer? No but that doesn't count because I say so"

7
tdewald•

My argument is not even remotely an appeal to purity fallacy, but nice try.

Show me where it's broken in Pioneer outside of Inverter. I'll wait.

-5†
ary31415•

Why should I? I'll tell you where it's broken in pioneer: inverter. I see no reason why this example of brokenness shouldn't count

6†
tdewald•

It's too good in Inverter for very specific reasons that differ greatly from what made Dig too good in other formats, as I explained in my OP. Inverter is doing a very unique thing that is extremely unlikely to happen again if Inverter itself were to be banned. Don't misrepresent my argument, especially if you aren't even willing to back up your own.

3†
Vicarious0ne•

also nexus before it got banned

-1†
cateater3735•

Ok, nexus died for digs sins!

Mostly /s. Mostly.

1
vickera•

Uhhhh as the card pool gross, low cmc cards and ways to fill your graveyard grow making the delve cards easier and easier to cast. Or are you saying they are never going to print 1 mana cantrips and graveyard fillers ever again?

Delve cards will be broken and will be banned in pioneer, maybe not now, maybe not in the next year, but it will happen.

1†
tdewald•

Why should we preemptively ban Dig for fear of future problems? Why not let people enjoy the card in the one format where it isn't generally busted until it actually becomes a problem?

1†
SonofaBeholder•

I’d argue it’s to prevent even worse “feel-bad” moments later on down the road. And it would show WotC learns from its mistakes.

Look at the situation with Mox Opal and Faithless Looting. Opal was known pretty much from the get go that it was going to be an easily broken card and would have to be banned at somepoint. Similarly, while Faithless Looting initially seemed fair (much like DTT) once graveyard strategies started appearing in force it became apparent that it too was just too good for the format. WotC had a chance then to cut the head off the snake early and instead chose to go down a route of banning multiple other cards over the years for the sins of those two, and when they finally decided “enough is enough, we have to ban these cards not others” what happened? The “feels bad” fallout was actually worse, because they had allowed the cards to become format staples and many other less powerful decks had arisen relying on those cards (affinity, Mardu Pyromancer, etc....) and so the culling was more widespread and more actively felt (in addition to Opal hurting a lot of wallets of invested players as it lost almost 3/4 of its value practically overnight).

If I were WotC I would be keen on avoiding a repeat of the situation, and with DTT already being seen in a similar light (we know it’s on WoTC’s watch list they’ve admitted that themselves) it only makes sense to cut it off now before it has a chance to get to that level.

0
vickera•

I didn't say we should ban it now. You said you don't think it is destined to be banned in pioneer and I'm saying that is absolutely turning a blind eye.

-4
tdewald•

Actually, I never said that at all. I suggest you reread my post.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
KarnSilverArchon•

I think Inverter and Dig should be banned. I think those are the only bans. Lotus Field decks have proven to be able to be hated out and become very reasonable once they are. Inverter decks have proven to be very adaptable and resilient to hate and keep pushing themselves to the top against everything. I think it should be banned. Dig also just makes combo too consistent. Get rid of it too.

-6
Swindleys•

Dig was fine before people used it to kill with inverter though..

0†
Vicarious0ne•

dig was fine after the previously busted dig deck, Nexus, got banned and if inverter goes a new busted dig deck will emerge sooner or later.
Dig is simply way too good in decks trying to do broken things compared to what it does in fair decks

2
SonofaBeholder•

The problem with DTT is it’s far too easy to be broken. It’s like Faithless Looting in modern: anytime a new set with graveyard synergies gets released, there’s a very real possibility the card gets broken to the point of format warping.

As long as DTT remains unbanned, WotC either has to power down graveyard sets / synergies to avoid breaking the format, OR they have to ban a bunch of otherwise ok cards instead to keep DTT fair (much like they did with Mox Opal and Faithless Looting).

1
giggity_giggity•

Matt Nass and LSV pet a dog while probably talking about something. But who cares? Dog!

-6