r/diablo4•
tablo2

Inventory and Interface Feedback

I appreciate the amount of time that Blizzard spends to communicate and to prepare the assets. I hope our feedback will help you to energise and synergise the development process. My feedback concerns mainly the inventory topic which seem to be the most controversial one. However I think Blizzard lacked discernment on this matter and you don’t seem to see fully understand the consequences of art interface on game mechanics. I am not convinced you have fully foreseen or and analysed the consequences, the intricacies of art interface with game mechanics. I’m going to try to give my in depth opinion on this and I hope you will find it helpful.

Inventory proposition

- Drawing icons and writing near it “Life” “Defense” “angelic”, makes no sense. I would remove superfluous icons, I know it’s work in progress but their artstyle is questionnable . Icons must ideally convey action, and be buttons.

- Displaying 2 times the character is simply wrong. I removed the character in the inventory, and added a Zoom, in zoom out toggle button, (could be auto zoom for casuals in options, when inventory open)

- Displaying 2 times the character is simply bad design. I removed the character in the inventory, and added a Zoom, in zoom out toggle button, (could be auto zoom for casuals in options, when inventory open)

- I think it is dangerous to mix inventory and stats panel. Because you already did the mistake in other games, where you want to convey everything everywhere without structure. It ends up with a map in the quest panel and written quests in the map.

- Beautiful design must be structured and be unique as a function.

- If you need a indicator that your stats increase as you put stuff, you can add a small "+" or highlight visual signal above the stats icon, every time you equip an upgrade. Thus, the player notices he/she must open the stats panel every time he/she wants to equip new gear. (or perhaps make a tutorial interface that can be turned off)

​

(textures used `https://i.ibb.co/smktWcc/d4-inventory-textures-sample.jpg` —simply googled medieval patterns)

Background behind images

- Since every quality type (white, blue, set, etc) will have its own pros and cons, and potentially beat a supposed superior quality type item, what is the need to influence the player? Why should quality type influence the decision of the player checking or not checking the item? item class, item type, level and requirements as well as quality type should be the reasons, so everything should be written altogether.

- Since we now have the "green arrow good, red arrow bad", what is the point of sorting the colors of the items with a background?

- As shown in animated gif below, there is a continuity of having an item lying on the ground without background, hold with the mouse without background, as well as placed in the inventory. Holding an item like this with a rectangle colored background would not look right. A physical action is made between the ground, the mouse, the movement into the inventory. This is what gives value to the item, it's believability. An item holds no value if it's just a number in your database.

​

if the animation does not load: https://i.redd.it/6llhftpy4nj41.gif

- This rectangle background makes the item look like an Hearthstone card. The image is supposed to be the item. It's not supposed to represent it, it's not an Icon. You have to make the distinction when to use icons, and when to use actual images. In the past 15 years, graphic design, motion design, advertising fell into the trend of using icons (The reason being Web 2.0 and the phone technology).. This cost-efficient way to communicate became over-used and artificial, reducing consumer trust who now seek more authenticity.

Different sizes of items bring more advantages

- The reason why you displayed the new images of the items so big, is because we simply cannot distinguish the details with such small icons in the inventory. It could be the reason why you don't show the new icons in the inventory.

- It is insane, you now draw such high quality weapons and armors, and you are not able to display the details.

- With big enough images, you don't need to draw a second icon of the item to display it bigger. Everything is simply functional.

- You seem to seek convenience when saying "To avoid interrupting gameplay"[...], we’re not planning on bringing back different-sized items". Excuse me but, in order to play quickly, how can you differentiate a dagger from a sword without different sizes? How do you differentiate to equip a ring from a circlet?

- You say pockets of inventory management disturb gameplay, but why would different sizes disturb gameplay since you add tabs that sort object types? It's actually the opposite: once you have every item type sorted, you can more quickly visually locate items with different sizes.

- Different sizes simply make the game more believable and immersive.

Inventory looks too flat

An inventory is an ancient instrument of storage. It's a physical objects with shifting boxes and spaces. We must be able to see the depth of the boxes, we need an inventory (like every panel) that LOOKS like a physical tool. With micro shadows, bumps and sense of materiality.

Though, Items images now half 3d rendered/painted/lighted are now good.

​

https://preview.redd.it/awan3rei4nj41.jpg?width=3275&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1048b3d1f3bce6c7bb4f0e4d8cf4f59a3e24b870

Miscellaneous

- The (work in progress) co-ops interface artstyle and structure look scary, especially backgrounds and banners. Talents icons look good.

- Various behaviours of monsters are most welcome! It encourages spell decision making in combat, in place of forced spell diversity driven by cooldowns.

- Monsters tone, art, animation look sharp, very convincing and appealing.

Posted Feb 28, 2020, 10:25 AM UTC · edited

2821
Lokhe•

- You seem to seek convenience when saying "To avoid interrupting gameplay"[...], we’re not planning on bringing back different-sized items". Excuse me but, in order to play quickly, how can you differentiate a dagger from a sword without different sizes? How do you differentiate to equip a ring from a circlet?

More importantly, they don't recognize the fact that stopping and evaluating items and rearranging inventory is not "interrupting the gameplay", it's part of the god damn gameplay loop! >_< They're boiling it down to "green arrow good, red arrow bad" again and it's maddening :/ It's fine if that's the experience you're looking for, but I'm not, that's for sure.

13
lightshelter•

Yeah, this frustrates me and concerns me as well that they see it this way. It really makes me concerned that they don't understand that the core of what made Diablo fun is the items, not the combat. The combat is just a means to an end, and a way of testing out your cool ITEMS and BUILDS to get more ITEMS to complete that other cool BUILD. From everything I've seen so far, they seem to be focusing on combat systems, world bosses, questing, and endless dungeon grinds etc. and this is not the formula that made Diablo popular.. or fun.

4
Is_Always_Honest•

Dumb it down for the lowest common denominator. It's been the Blizzard standard for at least as long as the Activision-Blizzard merger. It's "good business" as executives say. But it makes for trash products.

1
Lokhe•

I mean they're not trash products if they sell well but, from yours and my point of view, they have no value yeah :/

1
Is_Always_Honest•

That's not true at all. Just because a product is sells well, does not make it a good product.

1
Lokhe•

It does from the point of view of whomever is selling the product, is what I meant. And that's usually the idea of selling a product, having as many people as possible buying it.

1
Cr4ve•

You should post this where Blizzard can see this. Good Post

7
BigBess7•

I think Blizzard said they check every forum / subreddit and much more. They take "everything" into consideration

2
feeling-supersonic•

Hope D4 developers will see this post!

I really like what you said about the inventory not feeling like a real inventory. Blizzard wants to simplify way too much the game; Sorting the inventory it’s part of the arpg genere, those moments when you have to decide if it is worth to drop a 2x2 cells item for a really good 1 cell item, or go back to town to sell.

6
SheetShitter•

I agree with much of what you’ve presented here. The different sized items, no colored backdrop on items, icons need to be buttons, your thoughtfulness in the GIFs and images provided; however, I think looking at the comments “It’s amazing you don’t understand this” or the various other comments made, it comes across a bit insulting and considering that this is an open letter to the devs, you probably will get a better response or more consideration without those side jabs included

3
tablo2OP•

That makes sense. Thank you I'm going to adapt it a bit

3
don-niksen•

I agree on most points, but can you please explain:

"- Stop drawing icons when you still have to write near it "Life" "Defense" "angelic", t makes no sense. Remove superfluous icons, I know it's work in progress but they look cartoony. Icons must ideally convey action, and be BUTTONS."

2
tablo2OP•

Hi Don Niken,

Thank you for your comment. Sorry I'm not a native english speaker. I mean that icons are meant to be self explanatory. When you need text to explain an icon, it means the icon is not clear enough, so I would just stick to text.

My opinion is that Icons make sense when they are buttons, when they convey an action. Because icons are symbolism, as opposed to an image.

But text + icon at the same time that aren't clickable make no sense.

7
claudclaud1•

I really love this idea, it's sad blizzard will likely just autopilot all of their decisions :')

2
Ulfhogg•

Very nice post but Activi$ion is not going to give a single fuck for what gamers want, after WC3 Refunded unless Blizzard will be the good old Blizzard they will mot get my money, and guess what, good old Blizzard is gone.

1
mobofob•

The design of the UI is far from final. As they said, the game changes all the time as they go through the design process, so naturally the UI does too and there's no reason to polish it with fancy art yet

1
tablo2OP•

D3 UI's artstyle did not change between 2008 and 2012. It was exactly the same brownish and wowish D3 windows and pop-ups. Cliché and cartoony.

1
mobofob•

That doesn't affect D4 in any way though.

1
KurtiZ_TSW•

Icons do not have to be action buttons. Humans can read shapes and images much faster than words. Icons act as a comprehension and orientation aid.

If using icons next to words to aid comprehension and orientation wasn't a good idea, we wouldn't be seeing so many if the successful modern businesses using it.

Other than that agree with everything nice writeup

1
tablo2OP•

it is true. That being said Diablo is a world in which, how people imagine hell matter, how they imagine evil and the world during the dark ages. Even UI must have icons and communication that adapt to this time of time. Icons were different symbols. This is why I don't criticize Blizzard for the talent icons tree (that look right and coherent)

1