BG3 art style has nothing to do with Baldur's Gate
Say whatever you want about the gameplay, the art style is anti-BG. Baldur's Gate had a dark atmosphere, and this was reflected in its environments. Compare the images:
As you can see, the lighting and color is pretty muted, which is a core ingredient of the atmosphere of the game. Now, let's look at Baldur's Gate 3:
This bright, heavily saturated, semi-cartoony art style doesn't remind me of Baldur's Gate, and neither do the environments themselves. You know what they remind me of? Divinity: Original Sin 2. It's like they missed many of the elements, at least in terms of visuals, that would make this feel like BG.
I'm not a fan of the switch to turn-based combat, but the deviations from the BG franchise go much, much deeper than that. On top of everything else, this game has the crafting clutter of D:OS, which again is very much not in the spirit of Baldur's Gate. It just so happens that everything from Divinity: Original Sin is appearing in this game. It seems like Larian maybe treading its own tracks here a little too liberally.
But like I said, I feel that the art style is the biggest issue. Baldur's Gate is not supposed to be bright and colorful. BG has always been dark and gritty, and eschewing that is too sharp a change in my opinion as it is an integral part of the franchise's identity.
Posted Feb 28, 2020, 1:52 PM UTC · edited
you cherry picked screenshots to find dark ones in BGm there are plenty of bright environments. The circus camp. the temple district, the palaner stuff like the elemntal plane of air. etc.
I included what decent-sized and decent-quality images I could find. I added a photo of the Temple District to accommodate your wishes. It's not cartoony and colorful at all compared to BG3. Is it bright? Yes, because the sun shines, sure, but that's where the similarities end. Moreover, it's not only about color and brightness, it's about the general style as well. BG3 just doesn't look like BG.
The Divinity influence in BG3 is too strong.
and the areas with bright red and organge balloons? the open fields with bright green grass and flowers and multi colored tents?
are you sure it;s not just the heightened graphical fidelity and processing power you're complaining about? did you expect them to make a game in 8bit with 64 colors?
Not sure what you're talking about, and it doesn't matter much when anyone can immediately tell the distinct difference in style between the games. It has little to do with graphical fidelity.
it has everything to do with the graphical fidelity. I don't think you're really appreciating the limitations of 256 color VGA vs full spectrum graphics.
your memories are wrong
my memories from a month and a half ago? fuck off.
Baldur's Gate is gritty game not colourfull candylike like dos. Seems your memories aren't too good if you can't remember how game from month ago looks. Seriously you should check your vision. Not kidding here.