BG3 art style has nothing to do with Baldur's Gate

Say whatever you want about the gameplay, the art style is anti-BG. Baldur's Gate had a dark atmosphere, and this was reflected in its environments. Compare the images:

https://preview.redd.it/7hxaqweq5oj41.png?width=1579&format=png&auto=webp&s=f0f23c27a5e41577c5d18f86dbee1c8bc786c935

https://preview.redd.it/eyi1ndqs5oj41.jpg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2bbba8e8c565a142daba516e2b8a2bc456c90791

​

https://preview.redd.it/h0dnt1x4hoj41.png?width=360&format=png&auto=webp&s=e597c1774624525f3e03ca6ad67d12010405d772

As you can see, the lighting and color is pretty muted, which is a core ingredient of the atmosphere of the game. Now, let's look at Baldur's Gate 3:

Cartoony blood?

https://preview.redd.it/c8q6yvfi6oj41.png?width=1919&format=png&auto=webp&s=d62371671b66c8665606d86436b5dca6500e0324

This bright, heavily saturated, semi-cartoony art style doesn't remind me of Baldur's Gate, and neither do the environments themselves. You know what they remind me of? Divinity: Original Sin 2. It's like they missed many of the elements, at least in terms of visuals, that would make this feel like BG.

I'm not a fan of the switch to turn-based combat, but the deviations from the BG franchise go much, much deeper than that. On top of everything else, this game has the crafting clutter of D:OS, which again is very much not in the spirit of Baldur's Gate. It just so happens that everything from Divinity: Original Sin is appearing in this game. It seems like Larian maybe treading its own tracks here a little too liberally.

But like I said, I feel that the art style is the biggest issue. Baldur's Gate is not supposed to be bright and colorful. BG has always been dark and gritty, and eschewing that is too sharp a change in my opinion as it is an integral part of the franchise's identity.

Posted Feb 28, 2020, 1:52 PM UTC · edited

469
Vyrosatwork•

you cherry picked screenshots to find dark ones in BGm there are plenty of bright environments. The circus camp. the temple district, the palaner stuff like the elemntal plane of air. etc.

9
MultihogOP•

I included what decent-sized and decent-quality images I could find. I added a photo of the Temple District to accommodate your wishes. It's not cartoony and colorful at all compared to BG3. Is it bright? Yes, because the sun shines, sure, but that's where the similarities end. Moreover, it's not only about color and brightness, it's about the general style as well. BG3 just doesn't look like BG.

The Divinity influence in BG3 is too strong.

-3
Vyrosatwork•

and the areas with bright red and organge balloons? the open fields with bright green grass and flowers and multi colored tents?

are you sure it;s not just the heightened graphical fidelity and processing power you're complaining about? did you expect them to make a game in 8bit with 64 colors?

2
MultihogOP•

Not sure what you're talking about, and it doesn't matter much when anyone can immediately tell the distinct difference in style between the games. It has little to do with graphical fidelity.

0†
Vyrosatwork•

it has everything to do with the graphical fidelity. I don't think you're really appreciating the limitations of 256 color VGA vs full spectrum graphics.

1†
Bladolicy•

your memories are wrong

-6
Vyrosatwork•

my memories from a month and a half ago? fuck off.

2†
Bladolicy•

Baldur's Gate is gritty game not colourfull candylike like dos. Seems your memories aren't too good if you can't remember how game from month ago looks. Seriously you should check your vision. Not kidding here.

-1†
Gdach•

Can't really believe people complaining it not being brown and grey. You know what most people complained about games at that time? GAMES BEING BROWN AND GREY.

And now we go full circle, dark games just don't look nice, remember everyone complained about fallout being dark and grey, what about kotor2? When they made sequel more colorful, nobody complained about that, because it's ridiculous thing to complain. Please remove your nostalgia glasses a little bit.

9
MultihogOP•

It's a case of the entire atmosphere being off, not just about it being "brown and grey" or not. The Baldur's Gate franchise always had a dark, gritty atmosphere. I feel that it was an integral part of the franchise's vibe. With that gone, it doesn't feel like Baldur's Gate to me.

It's not about nostalgia glasses. I don't even have nostalgia for the Baldur's Gate franchise as I only played it a few years ago for the first time.

3
Gdach•

Then you should also know that this is pre-alpha, lightning effects will be adjusted some placeholder items will also change. They stated in the interview other areas will be darker and so on.

Don't really want the game to be fucking broody all the time, because it's just bad design. What makes good design is contrast between light and dark atmosphere. If everything was dark it would become new norm so you will phase out, it is also really tiresome and really not impressive if we want to up something.

3
MultihogOP•

I agree about environmental variety being desirable to avoid monotony. But style involves more than that. It's the overarching vibe (visual and otherwise) in the game. I feel that that doesn't evoke an atmosphere characteristic of Baldur's Gate.

Could it change more into that direction? Yeah, but we'll see. Often assets in previews such as this are final.

2
Imakemyownjerky•

This is pre alpha and sven literally said before he started playing there was lots of placeholder assests.

2
nihilistonion•

What about screenshots like this, this, and this?

It certainly looks like Baldur's Gate 3 has plenty of darker, "grittier" looking environments in store.

A modern game is not going to match 1:1 the visual "style" of a game from 20 years ago - the increase in visual fidelity alone (and the fact that the game is not Isometric) lends itself to sharper assets, which in turn will boost the colour contrast of a whole scene. That's why people are seeing this as "cartoony" and "colourful". That strong contrast, which makes colours "pop", is Larian's style. I personally would like to see some of the later environments tone that down, but some of those screenshots of areas we didn't see in the demonstration look promising.

Also, the "feel" of a game won't be down to just the art style alone. The visuals, the music, the familiarity of locations, the story; all of this will combine to create a "vibe". I don't think we have seen enough of the game, its script, and its environment to truly make a decision on whether it hits the mark.

But my my do some of those screenshots look pretty. And creepy.

8
MultihogOP•

I definitely agree that those screenshots look more promising.

A modern game is not going to match 1:1 the visual "style" of a game from 20 years ago - the increase in visual fidelity alone (and the fact that the game is not Isometric) lends itself to sharper assets, which in turn will boost the colour contrast of a whole scene.

It's not expected that it would be 1:1, or even desirable, but it is expected that it would have a similar style that evokes the atmosphere of the older games of the franchise. This "Larian style" that you mention doesn't do justice to the franchise, as far as I can tell.

Also, the "feel" of a game won't be down to just the art style alone. The visuals, the music, the familiarity of locations, the story; all of this will combine to create a "vibe". I don't think we have seen enough of the game, its script, and its environment to truly make a decision on whether it hits the mark.

Absolutely correct. The problem extends to these aspects, however, as the environmental interaction, animation style, UI style (for now at least), overwhelming crafting item clutter, and general mechanics are all blatantly lifted from Divinity: Original Sin 2. Anyone who has played D:OS2 can see this at a quick glance. This further pulls it into the "Divinity 2 copy/paste" direction. Even if the lore will end up being BG-like, that only goes so far when artistically and mechanically the product is almost identical to Larian's other products.

3
nihilistonion•

Here's hoping that first area we saw is just indicative of that one area. I'm not against Baldur's Gate 3 introducing some variation into the environments in terms of style either, certain parts of Faerun would be colourful and open, but it would be a shame to totally gloss over that dark art style.

I certainly agree with the UI, I'm hoping that is placeholder for the moment and will be changed. Especially little touches like the cursor and font being the same from Divinity - I can understand using them just so it's workable for the pre-alpha showcase but I would hope that the final release has something that fits the unified style of the game and series.

The crafting clutter is an interesting one. I'm currently playing D:OS2, and you do pick up A LOT of shit. Streamlining the crafting would be an excellent evolution for the game, though I don't really think there being a few odds and ends to make things out of is really gonna destroy my immersion. If I'm not feeling the crafting, I just won't bother picking them up. Though my DnD player intuition is to loot EVERYTHING off the bodies so....

The animations I have 0 problems with. BG1&2's animations weren't exactly a staple of the game considering the technical limitations, so a different "style" of animation won't bother me. And they seemed to be really quite nice when they were working.

To me it seems like the mechanics of the game are the biggest bugbear (pun intended) for people. It's a huge departure from the previous games, and uses Larian's distinct flavour of TB combat. Personally, I really love their combat system - I prefer it over the classic RTwP style - so I personally think it's an excellent fit. But I can understand that if you aren't super into that system, it can interfere with the Baldur's Gate "feel". I'm hopeful that it won't play too much like a D:OS clone though, as they really seem to have gutted the old system and based on DnD5E rules. Divinity's basic skeleton, with 5E rules, skills, and interactions.

Unfortunately, I think that "feel" will be lost for a lot of people - WotC and Larian's focus on "modernising" and bringing Baldur's Gate to 5E isn't going to match people's expectations. Considering the aim, however, I think Larian have done a bang up job. The character design for some of the races they showed got me very excited, and the mechanics look like a great port of 5E. And overall, I enjoyed BG1&2 for the story and the characters, not the mechanics - it's a chance to enter the world of Faerun. If Larian get those beats right, I'll be very happy.

2
MultihogOP•

First of all, thank you for being reasonable and civil.

I'm not against Baldur's Gate 3 introducing some variation into the environments in terms of style either, certain parts of Faerun would be colourful and open, but it would be a shame to totally gloss over that dark art style.

Me neither. My intention wasn't to argue that the entire game should be 100% depressing and gritty in terms of environments. I just feel that they failed to capture the overarching style and instead went for what they know from Divinity: Original Sin. You could almost say it feels lazy. Everything they showed feels familiar from D:OS, like they took the easiest route by treading their old tracks.

The crafting clutter is an interesting one.

I don't have an extremely strong opinion on it, but it's yet another thing that points to them having copied elements from D:OS, which in turn makes the game feel like D:OS3.

The animations I have 0 problems with. BG1&2's animations weren't exactly a staple of the game considering the technical limitations, so a different "style" of animation won't bother me. And they seemed to be really quite nice when they were working.

Yes, not terrible, but I saw some animations that looked like they were lifted straight out of D:OS2, such as sheathing your weapon after combat, though these could be placeholders. Yeah, this is minor.

To me it seems like the mechanics of the game are the biggest bugbear (pun intended) for people. It's a huge departure from the previous games, and uses Larian's distinct flavour of TB combat.

It's one more thing that pulls it more in the direction of D:OS, but I don't know if it's fair to hold the fact that they went turn-based against the game. You could even argue it's more faithful to be D&D source material, which was always important to the franchise. It definitely, again, feels like D:OS because the skeleton, as you said, has that distinct D:OS feel to it, but we'll see how it turns out eventually.

Unfortunately, I think that "feel" will be lost for a lot of people - WotC and Larian's focus on "modernising" and bringing Baldur's Gate to 5E isn't going to match people's expectations. Considering the aim, however, I think Larian have done a bang up job. The character design for some of the races they showed got me very excited, and the mechanics look like a great port of 5E. And overall, I enjoyed BG1&2 for the story and the characters, not the mechanics - it's a chance to enter the world of Faerun. If Larian get those beats right, I'll be very happy.

Yep, I enjoyed BG2 most for its characters as well—companions mostly, to be precise—and if they can capture that feeling, that will already be a major success in itself. I'm a bit worried, however, that the game will end up feeling like a D:OS3 instead of a BG3, that it will be BG3 in name and lore only, and mechanically it will be a Divinity game.

It makes you question why it's even called BG3 in that case; it makes you wonder why they revived an old franchise if their new entry isn't at all reminiscent of said franchise.

2
nihilistonion•

First of all, thank you for being reasonable and civil.

Same to you, and no problem at all! It's nice to change the style of narrative that is currently being had surrounding this game.

I can understand the trepidation towards the game feeling more D:OS than BG. I can see some of the world assets looking very similiar to D:OS, they have a certain look that I can quite put my finger on... beyond my initial thoughts on colour contrast and sharpness. I'm holding out hope that as the game progresses we will see darker environments (maybe some interplanar travel?) that will give the game the opportunity to strike out in a different artistic direction to Divinity. Or at least offer some environments that are visually interesting enough to lessen the impact of the similiarities in assets.

I'm also hopeful that the new dialouge system will keep this game from feeling to D:OS. I reckon the cinematic dialouge will give the game a more personal feel that the conversations you had in D:OS. And the character design is a whole world away from Divinity's - which should help balance that lean towards feeling too D:OS.

In the end nothing will stop the combat feeling like Divinity. Maybe the 5E implementation will help it feel distinct enough for people, but I'm not sure how much of a difference it will make. I too hope Larian can capture the character and companion feel from BG. I didn't mind what I saw from the dialouge in the presentation, nothing mind blowing but that's not to say it won't improve further in.

It makes you question why it's even called BG3 in that case; it makes you wonder why they revived an old franchise if their new entry isn't at all reminiscent of said franchise stylistically.

I think the proper answer is, unfortunately, "marketing". Baldur's Gate is WotC biggest success in the video game market, which is set in the Forgotten Realms - considerably more commercially successful than their other settings from how I see it. "A new DnD" game won't gain traction as much as "Baldur's Gate 3".

My optimistic self sees it more as a continuation of the lore, the themes, the types of story, and the setting. Like when Fallout switched development teams and become an FPS. Different play style, keeping the same lore, redeveloping the look to match the new visual style. That change led to New Vegas, which was excellent. I can only hope the same for BG3.

2
felathar1985•

I'd have to agree. Too shiny

4
MultihogOP•

Without knowing that the screenshots are from the upcoming BG3, I wouldn't have any idea. There is nothing in them that evokes feelings of Baldur's Gate.

4
felathar1985•

I'm going to install BG2 and play it again. And get this one on sale.

4
MultihogOP•

Yep, I did the same. I may or may not purchase BG3. We'll see.

1
ViciousImperial•

This is easy to fix with ReShade.

3
MultihogOP•

You can't fix an entire game's art style with some ReShade filters. Besides, even if you hypothetically could, you shouldn't attempt to excuse any shortcoming of a game with "mods!".

It shouldn't be up to every individual player to go out of their way and apply some heavy filters through third party applications just to make the game look a bit more like the source material.

0
commodoreJexton•

Also man have you seen blood in real life? That shit is bright red when it comes out.

3
Guaaaamole•

bad graphics do not equal dark atmosphere. Also, did you even play DoS 2? Larian is very much capable of creating a dark atmosphere the same way they can create shiny environments. How much did we see of the world so far? 5%?

2
MultihogOP•

Bad graphics? The backgrounds of BG2 are actually very well made and not "bad graphics".

Yes, we didn't see much of the world in BG3, but I doubt the art style will suddenly make a 180 and turn into something else. That would result in a serious inconsistency problem.

-3
Guaaaamole•

Did you even play DoS 2? They have several environments that create a dark atmosphere. It‘s not an inconsistency. It‘s that the world looks different depending on where you actually are. Larian is capable of both, bright environments with highly saturated colors and dark, grimy environments.

If you haven‘t played DoS 2 look up some Gameplay of the Bloodmoon Island. It gives you a general idea of what Larian is capable of doing in that direction.

3
MultihogOP•

I did play D:OS 1 and 2 (yes, the acronym is D:OS, not DoS). That's the very reason I'm aware of BG3's similarity to D:OS. I'm a fan of both of those games. The issue is that I expected to get a BG3, not Divinity: Original Sin 3. The similarity is just too much across the board.

0
Guaaaamole•

Please take a look at Pre-Alpha gameplay for DoS 2 (Yes, I don‘t care what the correct acronym is) and tell me that it looks anything like the finished product. UI, Environments, Assets are bound to change during development. How far are we away from a Release? 2 years? I would be surprised if the game gives off as much of a DoS 2 vibe upon release (which it currently very much does, I agree. But I think most of it comes from the UI).

I also expected a different game than God of War 4 but it‘s one of the best games I have ever played despite it‘s differences to the first games. People were upset about it - I was upset about it - but in hindsight it was an overreaction fueled by nostalgia. I think it‘s detrimental to a game series if every game has to play exactly the same. I‘m sure Larian will make appropriate changes to BG3 to give it a different feeling compared to both BG2 and DoS2.

2
Gdach•

I talked about BG2 a lot with people and you know what put them off, Graphics. Don't pretend that it's actually good.

1
velmarg•

I just disagree completely. Larian is taking their style of role playing game (D:OS) which was in itself a loving homage to Baldur's Gate and have earned the opportunity to continue the Baldur's Gate series with it. It was always going to be more a Larian game than a Baldur's Gate game.

And that is fine. The writing is great. The combat looks great (as it was in D:OS). Everything looked wonderful, even with the abundance of bugs.

If you walked away from everything heartbroken because the color palette didn't meet your expectations, you're a hell of a lot more pedantic than the average cat out here and may want rethink your own expectations for a sequel to a game that came out 20 years ago.

2
MultihogOP•

It's just that why call it Baldur's Gate 3 when it's Divinity in every aspect but name and story? Seems odd to me. It's like it's an outlier in the franchise.

1
velmarg•

It's an RPG set in the same world, a large portion of it takes place within the titular city - the developer desperately wanted the opportunity to continue a series they were obviously crafting the spiritual successor to anyway...

Lots of reasons, I guess.

3
Darkpockets•

When I think of terrain in the original Baldur’s Gate, one of the first things that comes to mind are gorgeous meadows full of picturesque, hand-drawn trees and flowers. They might be full of slavering gnolls, but they’re pretty as hell.

When I think of BG2, I think of the colorful and bustling city of Athkatla, with its calming aquatic temple district and garish circus tents; the emerald forests of Suldanessellar; the quaint and charming town of Trademeet.

Cartoony blood? Doesn’t strike me as any more silly than a long sword shattering hobgoblins into a shower of meaty gibbets.

To each their own, my friend.

2
commodoreJexton•

I do hope the tone is a little more grounded as they build it out, but I like what I’m seeing so far from a mechanics perspective.

A couple of thoughts on your bandwagon rant though:

  1. I remember an identical conversation around diablo 3

  2. we’ve seen a single area in detail, likely something they pulled over from previous work in the engine (divinity). It isn’t necessarily indicative of the full experience with the additional context of the finished game. That’s how software development works and why they make statements at the beginning like “this is buggy and not finished”

  3. if you want to play a game that much like the original in a specific visual style...play the original. Or play a souls game that’s also extra heavy on the bleakness that seems to be what you value in the game. Things change over time. Future iterations on original works may not necessarily appeal in all the same ways as the original. That’s ok and allowed. You can state a preference, but you don’t get to say what is or is not baldur’s gate.

1
MultihogOP•

A couple of thoughts on your bandwagon rant though:

That's a pretty unfortunate opener from you. There is no bandwagon rant here as I made this thread immediately after watching the preview of the game. I wasn't even aware there was such a "bandwagon".

I remember an identical conversation around diablo 3

And this matters how?

we’ve seen a single area in detail, likely something they pulled over from previous work in the engine (divinity). It isn’t necessarily indicative of the full experience with the additional context of the finished game. That’s how software development works and why they make statements at the beginning like “this is buggy and not finished”

Okay, fair enough, but from my experience, when something is shown in a preview, it will also be in the final product. It's very unlikely that they would put together an area, complete with many motion-captured cutscenes, and then cut it out from the game completely. The likelihood of that is minuscule, and even that may be generous.

if you want to play a game that much like the original in a specific visual style...play the original. Or play a souls game that’s also extra heavy on the bleakness that seems to be what you value in the game. Things change over time. Future iterations on original works may not necessarily appeal in all the same ways as the original. That’s ok and allowed. You can state a preference, but you don’t get to say what is or is not baldur’s gate.

I would argue that it's a problem if a sequel is stylistically so far from the previous installments in the franchise that it's unrecognizable as being part of said franchise.

-1
commodoreJexton•

Lol I think everyone can see how wrong that is on multiple levels so I’m not going to bother writing out why

1
Imakemyownjerky•

Yeah I mean sven told us a lot of stuff was just placeholder assets and had lots of bugs but naaaaaaah, games done and ready to ship.

3
MultihogOP•

Okay, have a nice day then. Thank you for your contribution.

0
KRE1ON•

You're absolutely right. Regardless of turn based combat (which is really good) the game is essentially a copy paste of Dos 2 assets and colour palette.

Baldurs gate is D&D, which means dark and greedy. Also the characters need to be more distinctive.

1
Imakemyownjerky•

Who said dnd has to be dark and gritty constantly? Do you not remember dos2 when you first enter fort joy? Yeah that scene was way too bright....i mean to be fair it was daytime on a tropical island.

1
de1Orbit•

Yes, I feel the same way. Original Divinity Sin 2 was way too colorful and saturated for my taste, it basically looks like it's a perfect summer day all the time, and even on the contrast toned all the way down, it's just so bright. I was hoping BG3 would have a much darker tone, but alas we are back to summer again.

1
dvoidis•

Yea, agree

1
allnamestakenlol•

I'm very much looking forward to the game, but I do hope it doesn't have any (or much) of the typical Larian colorful/cartoony goofiness. I generally love their games, but BG is [aesthetically] a different beast entirely, imo. Haven't watched more than half a minute of any of gameplay footage to date so as not to spoil anything. =x

1
MultihogOP•

I see you've arrived from Google, searching for this exact thing, as this thread hasn't been active for a good while. Haha.

1
allnamestakenlol•

Nailed it. Lol

1
Bladolicy•

Because all of this is just Original Sin III. Lets be honest and don't pretend it's something it isn't xD

0