r/wilco•
SCWinner

Wilco cover band -- feedback requested

*** edited to add new Muzzle, new Handshake, as well as our latest best attempt at Spiders ***

Hey guys, I'm a big fan of the band... so much so that I've joined a Wilco cover band and we're currently woodshedding a bunch of their songs.

Here are five... any feedback appreciated... this is our second rehearsal (edit: and third, now)

Recording quality varies due to these songs being from two different practices.

Early stages for sure... we still have to iron out some chords and tweak tweak tweak.

Ps: headphones or speakers are always better than a phone speaker. Ha

https://clyp.it/oovrg3mg (Muzzle March 4)

https://clyp.it/22ixqx0o (Spiders March 4)

https://clyp.it/23nkbauo (Handshake March 4)

https://clyp.it/tdqk03zd (Shot in the Arm)

https://clyp.it/44e4idpi (Company in my Back)

Posted Feb 29, 2020, 11:45 PM UTC · edited

1819
cryptical•

Man. I'd love to start a Wilco tribute band. Anyone in NE Ohio game? I'll be either Jeff or John.

Sounds great for a second rehearsal for sure. Keep it up!

5
stabbedbyafork•

Send me a message if you are serious! I might be interested

1
SCWinnerOP•

Appreciate the comments very much and welcome any others.

The vocals were going through the mains (we rehearse in a bar on an off-night) but the recorder was behind the mains, so that would explain the muffled quality... it sounds much better in the room.

As for the acoustic, it's definitely slightly off-tempo in Muzzle, but is pretty solid overall through the rest of the songs. We have ten songs so far and will have 20 in the not too distant future. We'll definitely work on tightening up that acoustic tempo.

Also, the acoustic monitor was too close to the recorder... the sonics in general will be mixed properly for performance.

Really appreciate that you'd consider seeing this band. As a Wilco fan, unless the cover band completely sucked, a night at a bar listening to 20 live Wilco songs is a night well spent imo... though we are trying to set the bar a bit higher than that. Hopefully. Ha

3
kennymac61•

All sounds really good, nice job there. Where are you located, I’d come see you guys any night of the week.

2
SCWinnerOP•

Much appreciated! We're in Toronto, which I like to think of as the Chicago of Canada. (Not sure why)

Probably won't start gigging til June at the earliest, we want to make sure every song has been perfected (to our ability of course)

I've contacted the moderator of this sub and have been given permission to post details about our first "main" show closer to when it happens, aka when I have those details...

1
kimmeljs•

When you go touring, you'll have to go Via Chicago then... would be a tough crowd I'm sure

2
asu2021•

Great job! I don't know why people don't understand this is a recording of your band playing - and not a mixed master of an album.

Anyway... you guys have done a GREAT job of finding the right sounds of the instruments. The guitar tone and drum set up are spot on - thats really tough. The one thing I would say - is you have to decide are you a "Wilco cover band" that is mimicking the band's sound, or are you a "band that does Wilco covers" and open to your own interpretation. Your lead singer naturally sounds somewhat like Jeff, so if you can nail the register, tone and falsettos of the songs - you should sound a lot like them.

Anyway - I'm excited to hear you guys when you have a proper mixed recording, but keep up the good work, if I'm in Toronto, I'd love to see you guys - post the show dates here for anyone who would be interested.

Keep it up!

3
SCWinnerOP•

Really great feedback, thanks for this... as you suggest, I did lead with the disclaimer that it was a shitty recorder just placed in the room, but I understand that it's jarring for people who don't often encounter rough "practice recordings" of live bands rehearsing. They're basically just for reference, so the players can hear their parts and determine if they're correct.

To your point, honestly we're just trying to do whatever the best version of a song happens to be, that's also within our ability, and our instrumentation lineup. I know that's a cop-out answer, but there you have it! Ha. We certainly are not trying to re-invent or re-imagine these amazing songs. We want to follow them as faithfully as possible, as a general rule.

I'm the lead singer... I'm beyond happy that you'd think I sound even somewhat like Jeff. The tone of Jeff's voice has impressed and intrigued me for years. I'm not sure I'll be able to do tons better than I've been doing, but I will say that I actually sound more like him in the full-voice higher range (think all of "hate it here" , as well as the middle ("I have no idea how this happens" lyric) part of "you are my face".

We are doing both of those songs and that's the register I think I do best in. Not illustrated here. I'm really trying to practice as much as possible, so my voice goes more naturally to the correct notes in general. I didn't realize how much muscle memory can be involved in vocals... I thought it was more a guitar thing.

Anyway sorry for rambling. I appreciate all the feedback and will occasionally update with our progress along the way. Cheers

2

Listened to muzzle of bees & company in my back. Not too shabby. Drummer sounds great. Whoever’s singing may need to project a bit more, however it could be the recording set up. The phrasing of the acoustic guitar in MOB seems just a touch off, but not too bad. I would come see you guys.

2
Colonelforbin25•

How many of you are in the band? The songs arent easy with all the layers to their music. But i think you sound good even if its early in the process. Keep it up! Its fun to do something creative and playing in bands is fun. Id go see it based on the clips. Sounds like fun!!

2
SCWinnerOP•

There are 6 of us... lead singer/acoustic guitar, electric guitar, electric guitar, keys, drums, bass.

For sure we won't be able to accomplish the depth of sound that Wilco achieves... or all that close to it. Basically we're trying to create as full a sound as possible with what we got. The guitars are doing a nice job of not duplicating/leaving space. With 3 guitars everyone really has to have some discipline, otherwise people are just banging away and it gets messy.

Keys are too low in this mix but they're there, and really help.

Appreciate the feedback, thanks for this. And yes it is definitely fun so far. To an obsessive degree... you can really get lost in the minutia and that's what we're actively trying to do lol

2
Colonelforbin25•

think it sounds great. I was just curious how many of you there are. Hard to tell. That is awesome! You guys totally have all the pieces with 6. The guitars do sound good. Wouldnt have guessed two rehearsals. I have been in plenty of bands that sounded worse after 5 practices lol. Keep it up and rock on!

2
tonyplush11•

sounds good to me!

2
kiwipizza3000•

Fuck! You guys are awesome! That shit is not easy and you all are killing it!

2
dondante4•

Great stuff. I'm in Toronto so I would definitely come see you if you were playing somewhere.

2
SCWinnerOP•

Perfect. Please bring your Wilco fan friends! Ha. We probably won't make a cent off this... doing it for love. Their music is so fun to play.

I'll definitely post here when we have a gig to announce. Probably June.

We'll likely have some sort of social media presence by then too I'd imagine. Band will be called Woolco, like the now-defunct department store.

1
rob__v•

Thanks for sharing, man! Can I ask you a favor? I'm going to jam with some people, and I was told we might do a few Wilco tunes but don't know specifically. What do you think are "classic jam-worthy" stuff?

For example: when I heard Willie Nelson, I'm thinking "whiskey river" or "blue eyes crying in the rain"...

BTW "A Shot in the Arm" is one of my favorites. Keep it up!

1
SCWinnerOP•

Thank you for listening!

Wilco shares its audience with a lot of jam-band fans... Phish fans, Dead fans. I'm a big fan of the Dead personally. It doesn't surprise me that you want to jam out to Wilco.

When I think "jam" I think "not a lot of crazy chord changes, nothing too busy or complicated, just something we can get lost in"

To that end I'd suggest "Spiders" as a good one to jam out to. Shot in the Arm is a good one too... you can extend those instrumental parts into infinity.

"Black Bull Nova" is a lesser known song but I could see that as being another great one to jam out to. Maybe "Kingpin" too.

Hope that helps!

2
rob__v•

Thanks for the tips!!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1