Sour Gas boiler (pre-space material, 1.5kg/s sour gas out @ ~125C)

Build

I have been working on a sour gas boiler that can be made with pre-space materials. I view this project as an effort to move sour gas boilers closer to where petroleum boilers are currently. I strongly encourage folks share their own thoughts and builds about this and I figure that this can be something of a community effort. I want to especially thank u/Gamers_Handbook for providing lots of inspiration in this effort.

To keep things simple, I'm trying to get a 1kg/s of natural gas out of the whole system. I'm also making the build in stages with a boiler that produces 1.5kg/s sour gas cooled to around 125C and a condenser that takes that and produces 1kg/s of methane. This may not seem like a lot, but that's still more than 11 natural gas generators producing more than 8800W. This post covers the boiler stage.

I designed this system to take in 95C oil. I expect that higher temperature oil would be okay, but I see no reason to use oil in excess of 125C.

Sour Gas Boiler

https://preview.redd.it/sg9swidl6yj41.png?width=450&format=png&auto=webp&s=5f01cc8789d2f100983dcad9216d477dec6fa174

This is the primary build, but there is also a steam turbine portion that I separated out for demonstration purposes. I will get to the steam turbine below the explanation of this portion, but just know for now that it's there and that it's just a steam room heat deletion device.

Starting at the bottom: The heat source is currently a block of magma as a placeholder. You could certainly dump magma into a pool like this, or you could use any other heat injector that produces heat above 555C. After that we have a steel heat path from the magma (any metal that can survive your heat source should be fine) coupled to a heat buffer by a set of steel doors.

The heat buffer is a line of refined carbon on the bottom and a line of metal tiles on the top coupled by metal tempshift plates.* There are three thermo sensors embedded in refined carbon adjacent to and controlling their respective steel doors. The metal tempshift plates and metal tiles are steel, but could be any refined metal that melts above 560C. The refined carbon row was produced by placing a row of coal tempshift plates next to the doors and letting them convert to refined carbon followed by placing another row of tempshift plates above the refined carbon so they would be absorbed into the refined carbon when they phase change. This was repeated 3 more times until 4000kg of refined carbon was achieved in each tile. Only once that's done were the adjacent insulated tiles and the metal tempshift plates installed. The metal tempshift plates help draw the heat out of the carbon and into the metal tiles. The thermo sensors are set to "Above 555C" and function well to operate this buffer.

Above the heat buffer is a heat exchanger stage that is designed around gas elevators. From this point up, each section is designed to process 500g/s which means that it's possible that output could be increased by simply adding more segments. The metal tiles are steel, but could be any refined metal that melts above 550C. The height of this gas elevator was designed on its own to process 403C petroleum and is tall enough that petroleum dropped at that temperature was consistently boiled and returned at a temperature that hinted at an efficient heat exchange. However, the prior stage doesn't seem to be nearly as efficient in that respect since the oil enters this stage at around 177C. Nevertheless, the oil flashes to petroleum at the second row of metal tiles and lands above 450C.

Above the gas elevator heat exchanger stage is an open baffled heat exchanger stage. This stage is based on designs for gas cooling stages and is specifically designed to make sure the gas reaching the pumps is safe for steel pumps. The metal tiles and tempshift plates are both steel, but any refined metal should do well here. In this design, the gas is actually around 140C at the pumps and could even be safe for gold amalgam pumps in theory. This design might be more efficient by either making this stage longer or replacing one segment of this stage with a longer gas elevator stage.

(*disregard the steam in the heat buffer. I removed it after taking the screenshots because I started thinking about how it would be difficult to install it after the coal line was installed. As it turns out, that area works fine as a vacuum.)

​

Piping

https://preview.redd.it/gjynwuxhcyj41.png?width=900&format=png&auto=webp&s=1f5328ab29429ad13939e843c7746eb8b2d4f201

The gas piping is quite simple as seen on the left with three insulated lines leaving. The height of the exit is ultimately arbitrary, but is adjusted in this design specifically to align to a steam turbine processing stage. The sour gas exits this stage at around 138C.

The liquid piping has two components in the form of a petroleum cooling loop directly cooled by the steam room of a turbine and the oil input. The radiant pipes are steel, but any refined metal would be fine. The oil input snakes through the metal baffles before being deposited above the mesh tiles by a vent. There is an input liquid valve set to 1500g and the liquid valves for the oil line that are inside the chamber are set so that each line only takes 500g.

I would normally show a power and automation stage at this point, but you just plug the thermo sensors into the doors that they're next to with automation and power the gas pumps. The doors weren't powered, but you could do that if you wanted to.

​

Steam Post Cooler

https://preview.redd.it/15jb7337eyj41.png?width=940&format=png&auto=webp&s=2285504f002513b7a3e534b1bcbabf1db761d4e0

The steam room is a basic steam room with 200kg (total) oil on the bottom and about 6.4kg/tile of steam. You could use more or less steam in the chamber. There are 6 metal tempshift plates and this design simply used steel for the tempshift plates and all radiant pipes. You could use other refined metals for similar results. The turbine itself is self cooling and outputs about 240W. The sour gas consistently exits this stage at a few degrees less than 125C.

You'll notice an oil line above the turbine chamber. This is in line with the boiler stage input and doesn't interact with this stage. This build was designed to align with the top of the boiler stage and to be capable of sharing the insulation on the left of the turbine and steam room with the insulation on the right of the boiler stage.

​

Conclusion and Thoughts

This is both a first attempt and a working concept. I would be happy to implement this or a double wide version (for double the capacity) of this in a base of mine. At the same time, I recognize that the heat exchangers could use some work. Overall, the system appears to be safe on startup, safe on shutdown, safe on pipe backup, and safe for 100 cycles.

The system has deliberately avoided space materials, but uses a lot of steel. However, the use of steel was mostly a convenience in building since I wouldn't need to change the material. Most refined metals would work well in place of steel and most would probably work better due to their higher thermal conduction. As for actually constructing this in a map, it's a lot of work in a vacuum and is relatively large, but the actual build elements don't strike me as overly complex except for the heat injector. If I were to build this in survival, I would create an entrance at the bottom, build the heat injector and refined carbon tiles, and then work up from there. Once those aspects are built, the remainder seems to be more a matter of patience and planning than anything else.

Startup for the system was as simple as turning it on with petroleum pooling on the metal tiles at the bottom until they got hot enough to flash. Once the petroleum started flashing, the entire system camp to an equilibrium rapidly (I'd say within a few cycles, but I wasn't paying attention and it could have been less than a cycle).

I had a testing problem where my test map power supply broke and the entire system lost power for 200 cycles, but the oil input kept going. The sour gas backed up in the pipes until the pumps couldn't pump. The sour gas built up to 667kg/tile at 138C in the baffled heat exchanger chamber, but nothing in the boiler section broke and the system was very happy to just keep making more sour gas. If this happened in a play through for any reason, it would be a simple matter to turn off the oil input and just restore power when I was ready to process the gas.

On the topic of cutting oil input. I did this several times during testing as an aspect of resetting for down stream elements (the condenser). I never let the chamber vacuum itself out, but I can say that this will take a long time. However, long before a vacuum is reached, the entire system reaches a very low pressure and the gas output slows dramatically. When the liquid stops, the gas elevator also stops which allows an unbroken gas channel from the hot tiles at the bottom to the gas pumps. However, this is a very long stretch of low pressure gas with a still running petroleum cooling loop. Even in this failure mode, the gas pumps and pipes remained safe.

Posted Mar 1, 2020, 12:48 AM UTC

1835
themule71•

This looks amazing. Can't wait to see the other half (the condenser).
Cooling down sour gas w/o supercoolant is going to be... interesting.

7
DeepBlue12•

You can do it with oxygen or hydrogen and thermo regulators. You can also use this method to liquefy a bit of methane and then run that through the aquatuners.

3
themule71•

I know, but still you need a very good counterflow. Methane is 4 times less efficient than SC and the temperature range to work with is slim. You can't go below freezing point plus 14. Which is -174C. You need -164C so it's possible but not easy.

4
DeepBlue12•

Well...you can't run it through the aquatuner if its temperature is below freezing point plus 14. But you can still cool it down past that point and then bypass the aquatuner until it's warm enough.

Regardless, since aquatuners are twice as power efficient as thermo regulators and since the SHC of methane is about the same as that of hydrogen, this is about as efficient as you're going to get until you have space materials.

3
themule71•

Yes in theory you can heat it up, before entering the AT. Still that uses power. I've thought about it, while exploring pwater loops for below -6C. The typical loop has the coolant bypass the AT when the temp is freezing point +13. So you can't cool something below that unless you get very complicated and add a warming loop.

2
psirrowOP•

I use reservoir cooling loops which let me take advantage of the 3 degree freezing margin to tune to freezing plus 11, but it's still not easy.

3
not_old_redditor•

Here's a novel concept: create some liquid oxygen using hydrogen and a thermo regulator, just enough to run it through a small aquatuner loop. The liquid oxygen cooling loop will cool a small room that you dump the sour gas into - this creates solid methane that you then conveyor out to a warm place and melt/evaporate into natural gas. I suppose you can use liquid hydrogen too, but that shit is so finicky, at least oxygen gives you a temperature range of about 35 degrees between freezing and boiling points, and its specific heat is not that bad.

2
themule71•

LOX has very low SHC, you'd use lots of power for very little cooling.

2
not_old_redditor•

Once you complete a sour gas boiler, even a small one, power is a non-issue.

2
themule71•

You need 8.4 LOX aquatuners to do the same job of one running SC. That's 10kW. The OP boiler produces nat gas for 11 gens, or 8.8kW. Granted, with a very good exchanger you don't need all that cooling, still I'm not sure you can go power positive. Methane is twice as good as coolant, but harder to work with.

2
DeepBlue12•

It's true that power is a non-issue, but since SHC of liquid oxygen is half that of gaseous hydrogen, and since the thermo regulator is half as efficient as the aquatuner, you may as well just run a hydrogen loop instead of dealing with the complication of liquid oxygen.

2
rattlebone•

Here I am just trying to manage all the Algae Terrariums.

6
DeepBlue12•

Algae terrariums use up so much duplicant labor that I never bother to build them.

I prefer digging big CO2 holes and dealing with it later :D

5
McBlemmen•

If this is for real i have 2 tips. 1 : dont use them and 2 : if you do use them just put them together at the bottom of your base. when i started i put them everywhere where dupes would spend time like bedrooms , bathrooms, etc but thats such a waste of dupe time to run around everywhere

1
rattlebone•

It was a joke. Not a good joke. But yes, good advice. :)

2
McBlemmen•

oh ok no i thought it might have been a joke but you never know

1
Gamers_Handbook•

Your ability to take some random testing results I had in my brain and turn them into a functioning build with your own completely unique design is freaking amazing! I absolutely love this, like every aspect is soo smart in how you put it together. The gas elevator, the refined carbon, the striped metal on the way down... I love all of it. I've sunk dozens of hours into this concept, and you're already leaps ahead of where I was.

It looks like you'd be able to swap this over to a gas elevator at the top if you wanted to in the future. Depending on your chiller setup, if you can use gas elevators to move the gas from stage to stage and keep thermal isolation until you make methane, that would save the pump wattage. I see this as more of an interesting efficiency experiment once the base design is done though.

One of my biggest things I try to do is allow my builds to be shut off-able. Now obviously you're the one with the sour gas boiler not me, and a small part of that is because I haven't found a good way to do shut it off. I wonder if it would be possible to use what you're doing here to create a 1 gas elevator wide, 2 condenser wide (next to the elevator going down), and taller setup. The idea would be to always put the base amount of oil into the gas elevator, and then to send large packets through the same line, but via a different liquid shutoff whenever sour gas pressures dipped low enough.

4
psirrowOP•

Thank you. This is still a work in progress on my end, but I figured I'd share what I had so far.

My biggest concern was that gas doesn't like to flow very fast, especially in narrow corridors. The gas elevator completely bypasses this and the top part has enough room for the gas to get to the pumps. The condenser I'm working on takes advantage of the gas being in pipes, but i would be concerned about maintaining flow in an open condensing stage. I'll definitely try it and see what it looks like later. It would still be useful to use a steam turbine between the boiler and the condenser though because a perfect counterflow between input oil and output sour gas puts the sour gas at 192C or more. Taking a bit of that heat away between the boiler and the condenser would definitely help things out.

That said, I'm testing out a new version of the boiler where the gas elevator has been extended to 10 metal stages and there are only 2 metal baffle stages (one for petroleum and one for counterflow). This new design had better counterflow and was only one tile taller. If the condenser could be made with open counterflow, the gas elevator would be a good method.

For shutting things off, there's some good news from how well this performs in failure. It would seem that you could put a pressure sensor near the pumps and use that to disable the incoming oil if the pressure gets a good deal higher than steady state. This would allow the system to gradually shut off if the gas backs up with limited build up.

I'm not sure I'm following you on the one elevator/two condenser aspect.

2
Gamers_Handbook•

I definitely wanna see your approach to a condenser once you have it ready. And I'd use the heck out of the steam turbines, they're great. In the hypothetical "sometime in the future and free flowing" idea, you can still use a steam turbine, it would just flow past it something like this.

The failure testing does sound very promising! Ya I noticed channel size does matter when free flowing gasses, both with testing this and with testing free flowing oxygen setups. High pressure and gas elevators can get you around it, but our atmo sensors also don't detect very high so it can get kinda cumbersome or down right impossible at times.

Not one elevator and two condensers (man I worded that badly), just a big "n" shape. Up is the gas elevator, and down is the rest of the process (basically heat exchanger that's 2 tiles wide). By going longer on a gas elevator, I hypothesize you could convert it all in one gas elevator instead of 3, as well as bigger packets for a more "on demand" type system (aka only add oil when gas pressure is lower than you want).

2
psirrowOP•

Yeah, I was thinking putting a contact cooler like that at the bend in an open design would be good. Possibly with temp shift plates and pipes or rails to help suck the heat out. I noticed that the gas pipes in my design ran colder at the bottom than the top, but I didn't really try to take too much advantage. I'll see about integrating a more deliberate taking advantage of that in the open design.

In the pumped design, the gas pressure is under or around 5kg/tile when running properly. This wasn't a thing I was testing for, but more something I noticed. It might take a little looking to get the right pressure, but a normal pressure sensor should do the trick to show when an anomaly occurs.

I think see what you're saying now. My early designs of this build tried to process all the oil from a single vent and didn't work well. I broke things down to 500g packets to make it easier to grasp this and arrived at this design. My concern at that point was maintaining good gas pressure at the pumps and good heat transfer in the open part, so there with of the pumps originally set the width. Considering all of that, an open design could possibly combine the gas elevator parts fairly well without needing that much extra height for good transfer.

I like the idea of sending all of the processed oil through a single vent, but I'm not a fan of sending larger packets than 1.5kg though the system. Sending larger packets than the system will process will make the system naturally pulsed which could reduce the effectiveness if the transfer stages. However, I did put together a shutoff valve contraption that can turn off the input without waiting for the valve packets to drain. This would let you still use sized packets while also letting the system shut off if it backs up for a more on demand operation.

2
Gamers_Handbook•

Wow 5kg is way lower pressure than I expected! Definitely readable by a sensor. Most of my experiments were about 10x that lol

Ah, I see why you went with 3 then. And if you got shutting off to work, then that's excellent news!

1
Ladderyank•

But to make sour gas even usable you need space materials to cool it down so the usability of such a build is very limited

1
themule71•

This is only the boiler stage of the build.

1