Learning Top with Renekton
I came back to League at the start of this year after about two years off. I decided to role swap from jungle to top for a variety of reasons that are irrelevant to this post. After playing around a bit, I realized that a playstyle I was very interested in developing was picking a winning lane to create early pressure and transitioning that pressure into teamfight victories that close things out in the midgame. Renekton seemed like the perfect champion for this, keeping in mind that I'm not good enough to play Aatrox well and Ornn is permabanned.
I'm a few dozen games in on the champ, and I just don't see it working. Sure sometimes my team wins around me and I just show up and get a decent scoreline, but I haven't had a single game where I felt like I positively contributed to the victory. It feels like Renekton doesn't win a lot of matchups these days in the first place (Darius, Sett, Aatrox, and ranged champs are probably more than half of games), and his "winning" matchups usually just translate into moderate cs advantages that become irrelevant as he falls off.
That's assuming you even win the advantageous matchups, since many of them have big outplay options for your opponents if you make a single mistake. Make a mistake against Jax level 1? Might as well sit the game out for how much you'll be able to participate. Fiora gets one read on your stun? Looks like her scaling came early, and diced crocogator is served. A single mistake completely removes your fleeting early advantage, whereas it takes repeated errors from opponents to give Renekton the opportunities to keep them down.
His fury mechanic is a huge obstacle to overcome. He needs empowered abilities in order to be able to trade favorably with most of the top lane roster, and the only way to get fury is to hit the wave. On one hand, this means that falling behind and getting zoned makes you about as scary as a lone Yuumi. You can't fight back into the lane because you don't get the opportunity to charge your resource. On the other hand, it means you can't really snowball an advantage because it means you're always shoving. Laying off the shove means giving up the threat you need to keep winning, but pushing to maintain fury just gives people the option to afk farm under tower. Sure you get maybe a ~20 cs lead, but that doesn't mean much when everyone outscales you. That's also assuming you don't get hard camped by the enemy jungler due to your constant pushing.
I can also never make a roam work. You often don't have fury when leading a gank, and it has not been realistic to extend E off of minions when coming in from an angle. This makes the ganks very ineffective, and it means every failed gank required you to blow ult for fury, which means you lose all pressure when getting back to top (in addition to the farm you gave up as a baseline in the roam). Sometimes you can steal from the enemy jungle later in the game, but people usually start outscaling you by the time lanes break to that degree.
The limitations on E as a mobility skill really feel like they shine in teamfights. A "good" teamfight usually involves trading flash with a carry and getting cc'd to death while praying that my team does something with the space I created. Not going in hard just means getting kited out and killed without accomplishing anything.
Anyway, I'm at the end of my rope with this champion. The other champ I've been alternating with Renekton is Shen, and it's relatively easy to hope your team wins and tag along with ults. However, I want to be able to create advantages myself, not just cross my fingers and support my team while they win for me. I did that for like 7 years in the jungle, and I can't handle that approach any more. I've spent several hours each week seeking advice and studying matchup VoDs, and while I've improved to the point of not straight inting every game, the immense amount of frustration at never managing to do anything right on this champ is starting to drive me insane.
Posted Mar 2, 2020, 1:10 AM UTC
“I don’t want to support my team all game and have them win for me like I did for 7 years on the jungle”
You’ve been playing jungle terribly wrong of that’s the feel you get from it, but aside from that I would suggest trying out malphite. Braindead easy to play, and great impact in teamfights with your ult. Also very easy to roam mid for a gank with your ult.
Generally you do get bullied pretty hard pre 6 in most matchups, but usually around lvl 9-10 when you’ve finished your first item and then some you start being able to 1v1 better.
Best part is you absolutely destroy annoying melee champs like fiora and tryndamere, and say goodbye to ever losing lane to Jax. and if they are unlucky enough to have a full AD team you can stack over 1000 armor and just be unkillable.
Maybe I didn't explain myself well, but your suggestion entirely circumvents the point of the exercise. Yes, I can play Malphite, afk farm under tower, and press R in teamfights to win games. I'm not trying, strictly speaking, to increase my win rate in the short term. I'm trying to learn the fundamentals of actually engaging with other champions in top lane, creating advantages, and winning through pressure.
I could have won more games by spamming Malphite, but I wouldn't have learned half of what I've learned with Renekton. The overall goal here is improvement, not hiding behind more tank play.
I’m not sure what you’re getting at here. The macro elements of creating pressure and advantages are not champion specific. You seemed to suggest Aatrox is too hard for you to learn, so I suggested an easy champ that can have a big impact on the game. What rank are you if you don’t mind me asking?
I'm not sure what you're getting at here. A champion like Kayle, for example, does not exert pressure or create advantages for herself because her early game doesn't exist. Obviously there comes a point when she starts to carry, but her condition for winning the game is surviving until she wins by default, not creating advantages or getting ahead. While I get that in a sense the idea of pressure isn't limited to a specific champion, not all champions have it as a win condition.
If I play Malphite, very little of what I do in lane really matters. I have no kill threat (unless they're really dumb). I have no capacity to zone or dictate the lane. I cannot really get an advantage or zone the enemy off of farm. If I have to step out of lane to assist my jungler, I'm probably going to lose a ton of creeps to tower. I can play the champ, take whatever cs the enemy can't punish me for taking, and win the game later by pressing R. However, this does not teach me how to lane correctly, and I already know how to be an ult bot in teamfights.
Again, I'm not looking for quick wins. I want to understand the fundamentals of top lane. I have nothing against playing tanks in the long run, but right now doing so circumvents the issues I'm trying to address.
EDIT: I haven't really taken to top lane in ranked (in other words, since I've come back). Usually placed low-to-mid gold back in the day, but never had the time to make a real push for plat. Always felt like I was awful at the game and needed to practice more before going into ranked and rarely did much beyond placements.
And Aatrox, from what I've read, has a lot of animation canceling shenanigans going on. I wouldn't consider myself skilled enough to play something like Riven or Yasuo, and Aatrox trends somewhat in that direction as far as I understand it. Could be wrong - haven't really played him much since the rework.
Well I’m not sure what to tell you. If you want to create serious advantages in your lane you’re going to have to play a champion with a decently high skill floor. That means learning stuff like animation cancelling. It’s very important because too lame is pretty much an island and you need to be able to out trade your laner
You say you don't want quick wins, yet you are limiting yourself to learning one playstyle that is completely feast or famine win fast. Your points about renektons fury are completely false. If you cannot maintain fury by last hitting you are trading too much. Renekton is specifically strong against scaling melee champs, killing the jungler if he ganks you, and setting up ganks/dives himself. You're having a hard time trading against champions and complaining that you always push because of it, that is because you are taking bad trades and losing because of if.
You want to learn a solo carry playstyle in a game that requires teamwork to win. In reality the only time you shitstomp a lane is when you are much better than the opponent in that game.