r/BmwTech•
TheMigDig

2013 BMW X1 x35i won’t start clicks once

Just replaced battery 4-6 weeks ago.

Drive to Home Depot to return some stuff.

Parked it.

Returned stuff.

Got back in to go home.

It’s not turning over.

Just a single click when trying to start.

Tried starting with battery charger and jumper cables.

Nothing helpful coming up on the onboard computer and diagnostic screens. Acts normal just doesn’t start.

Leaning toward starter issue.

Any tips on hours of labor it will take to replace?

Update:

Starter replaced.

Back on road within 24 hours and $535 out the door at a local non-BMW (but more importantly) trusted shop.

Posted Mar 2, 2020, 1:53 AM UTC · edited

512
ijustbrushalot•

Likely starter. But try attaching the jumper cable from the block to the ground point in case it's just a ground cable issue (common).

Starter labour is 3-4 hours.

10
TheMigDigOP•

Do you mean connect the battery ground terminal to a grounded point in chassis?

Sorry I’m not understanding what sound like the more technical terms you are using.

2
ijustbrushalot•

No. Clamp the cable onto the engine block (somewhere near the exhaust manifold, anywhere you can clamp bare metal) and the negative jump point on the strut tower. The starter needs a good ground from the engine to the chassis and often those ground cables rot away and prevent such a connection.

4
TheMigDigOP•

Thanks.

2
mickd66•

Same thing for me, starter motor. Independent fixed it for £270.00.👍

2
konjoko•

The exact same thing happened to my old 2012 528i. Ended up being the starter. Cost me about $1100 CAD to get replaced at the dealer.

1
pickled_horse•

Have you tried hand cranking? My E32 did the same thing it was vapor/hydro locked

1
AnonymoushipopotomusE36 M3/4/5, E46 M3, E39 M5•

Sounds like a starter. Probably in the 850 range

1
Vildabeck•

Since this happened within 4 weeks of replacing the battery, I wonder if you got a battery that was sitting on a shelf somewhere for months and months, slowly discharging. Then you bought it and if you don't drive it enough to fully charge it but instead take many short trips, it will eventually lose enough power where it won't be enough to turn the engine over. I killed my original battery when I bought my car new, from taking short trips all the time. I've since been using a Deltran battery tender and my batteries last over 8 years now. I would get a Deltran (around $50) and trickle charge for 24 hours or so and see if that happens. Much cheaper than replacing the starter, unless you are sure it is the starter.

Keep us posted at to the outcome please.

1
TheMigDigOP•

Update:

Starter replaced.

Back on road within 24 hours and $535 out the door at a local non-BMW (but more importantly) trusted shop.

2
Vildabeck•

Thanks for the update.

1
talltatanka•

https://www.bimmerfest.com/threads/engine-ground-cable.820543/ I had this problem on my X1 2014 with rotten ground cable. Replacing the starter will only ignore the problem of all of the exposed ground cables that corrode over time. Mine couldn't pull codes, and failed to start, and two garages later, it was found and replaced. it was a pricey adventure.

1