Holy shit you guys Twitter is wild

Holy shit you guys Twitter is wild

Posted Mar 2, 2020, 2:41 AM UTC

6450

As a bi person, I am tired of how toxic (biphobic) the lgbt community can be so I’ve stopped trying to have anything to do with it.

16
bobinski_circus•

try being asexual. Half the time they say we don't count or don't exist.

8

Yeah I’ve noticed for an “inclusive” community they try to do that shit a lot

4
bobinski_circus•

Sadly, the bullied often take on the tactics of the bully and often with even less self-awareness. It happens in everything - religion, nerd communities, careers, etc. People feel like if they're in the same group as you and that they will judged by you being in their group - they need to control that group and its perception, which is understandable. But it leads to segmentation and cliques. It takes a lot of strength to be welcoming and broad.

Heck, I disagree with other asexuals about how we represent OUR little tiny community and even there people are fragmenting off into obscurer and obscurer identities with longer and longer names, trying to define themselves precisely. I understand why they do it, but it becomes as complicated as the Marvel Comics Continuity and just as unwelcoming to newcomers soon enough. And it's not long until toxicity and gatekeeping follows.

2

I agree with you 100%. I have met and am friends plenty of LGBTQ+ who have been wonderful (including my own sister) but the community as a whole, especially what I see online (which is most of what I see because of how subdued the community is where I live) seems very iffy for me. I know for a fact there are some very good parts of it (ie. The Trevor Project) that I support and I try my best to focus on that. I know that this is why people are turning to the GRSM community.

Also this is off topic, but is your username from Coraline?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
VexingMadcap•

A lot of the biphobia can be attributed to performative bisexuals. I'm not saying it's right at all, just pointing out where the toxicity originates.

-9
tenkei•

Saying that biphobia is the fault of bisexuals is like saying racism is the fault of black people. You're just plain wrong.

3
VexingMadcap•

Sorry I think my statement was misunderstood. I don't agree with it at all, that's what I meant by "I'm not saying its right at all". It was something I've heard people say before in regards to their biphobia and thought it would be something to mention.

1
HarbingerX111•

How is anyone supposed to keep up with this

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2†
[deleted]•

Yes, no one that is relavent is saying you can't be straight male. That's a perfectly valid identity.

4
Sarcastic_Troll•

No, no one relevant is saying it's wrong. But I have been attached by random Redditers for it lmao

Then again, I was told I should die and was followed around by a group of ppl getting harassed for a week for the sin of having content make it to the front page on Reddit so the bar is really low here...

-3
[deleted]•

I'm having a hard time taking you seriously given your username

2
tenkei•

Yeah, I'm calling bullshit on that.

1
emma_does_life•

You said you are male, therefore you identify as male and you are male. There you go!

1
Sarcastic_Troll•

I think my point got lost. Was tryna go for the humor, and in it lost all sense

0
Sarcastic_Troll•

This has reached a point where no one knows what they're supposed to be anymore and everyone is just gender confused

Edit: I was actually told... Oh it had to be on Reddit, y'all can go scrolling thru my year worth of comment history, go have fun... But, I was told that identifying as a straight male was incorrect. That, both those terms are out of date and politically correct, and suppressed those trying to fight gender equality?

Apparently I'm part of the problem. Because, yanno, I don't identify as some cis gender something something....

This is my fukin generation and I don't understand half of this shit anymore.

And it's worse if you ask them to clarify. Like, ok, sorry I don't know what any of what you just said is. I can't keep up. There's too many catagories now.

TL;DR: Does anyone else think that for ppl who claim to not want to be labeled, they sure as hell fight for their lable?

Edit 2: See, downvoted. I don't get it.

6
TimeCubePriest•

I'm not in other people's heads but I'm pretty sure the people who don't like labels and the people who really like labels are different people

3
Sarcastic_Troll•

I dunno man. It's like, ppl wanna be non-binary cuz they don't wanna put a label on their sex and sexuality.

Sure tf sounds like a label to me.

0
TimeCubePriest•

Some people see it as much of a label as one would see "agnostic" as a religion. It's treated as a term that indicates a distancing from the system. I guess in that case you can argue that the absence of a condition within a system is in itself a condition. I don't think anyone would argue against that, it's pretty mathematically sound.

That's not all of them though in which case they're not against labels but that I don't think much about that cuz I'm not non binary

3
Sarcastic_Troll•

I guess in that case you can argue that the absence of a condition within a system is in itself a condition.

That's exactly what I'm arguing.

I also think we now have too many labling. You can't have this many, it's just canceling each other out. And if you get a special lable, then everyone else wants there own special lable, and you start lableing the most ridiculous things, and nothing gets done.

It would be like having 20,000 different ways of classifying a spider. Well, we have a new spider species, go divide it among 20,000 boxes? You've now stopped species classification, because I gotta go make sure it matches every single one of my 20,000 choices.

I was once part of a thread that was talking about these ridiculous gender reveal parties, and how out of control they were. And one girl came on and said we shouldn't pick a gender at all, that the reveal comes to when the child is old enough to tell us what gender they are.

It sounds ok, until you realize that diapers are specifically designed to extra protect where the pee comes from, and buying diapers absorbant in the front is a terrible idea if you have a biological girl. And vice versa.

So, at what point does this just start to become ridiculous? Or is the alternative to go back to horribly uncomfortable diapers that just makes every baby unhappy?

2
Rivscis•

This is way overgeneralizing, just call people what they ask you to call them lol. It not that they dont want a label (self labels can be good for explaining and self expression to sort if label how you feel inside) but rather they dont want to be stereotyped or misinterpreted. It can be frustrating if you have a negative reaction with a person on reddit, but it’s literally someone on reddit and one bad experience is in no way indicative of an entire diverse community of very different LGBT+ groups and people. Just be patient and have an open mind.

2
Sarcastic_Troll•

Yeah, no, I'm okay with it. Be whatever you want. I do find I get yelled at if I ask ppl to clarify tho. So, I stop asking. I ain't tryna be mean, I just dunno what a cis genderfluid demi-girl is. And yes, I ran into that once. That's the encounter I'm kinda pulling from.

But sometimes too many catagories can make the field too cluttered. I feel like we have too many options, and that's a bad thing. Just coming from a science standpoint, and classification, too many options can cancel each other out. It clutters the area and nothing has a meaning anymore.

I also think sex, sexual identity, and sexual attraction are three different things. Sex is what you are biologically born with. You wanna border sexual identity and gender together, that's fine, I would argue that gender is more biological than existential, but maybe I'm wrong on that. So, for argument, let's equate gender and sexual identity as one thing. Then sexual attraction, or orientation, is another thing entirely.

But then I get Non binary Q plus non binary plus Q plus (I think that's it. I'm confirming with my friend and I think I got it now. I may edit again)

No no, that's a real thing. That's Native American God gender attraction.

Yeah, god gender attraction.

The non gendered spiritual energy possessing non gendered you is attracted to the non gendered spiritual energy possessing the non gendered partner

So, yeah, this is getting out of hand.

0
Rivscis•

You say you dont really care, but then you say its getting out of hand. Just say you care, then you can acknowledge and care in a constructive way. Listen of course its complex there are a metric fuckton of people on this planets and each and every single one of these people is different. Im just going to try to ignore the obvious gender strawmen as well, that no one is identifying as. On top of this you mention science but science has been and continues to be on additional genders side here. Sex is what youre born as male, female, intersex, gender however is a social construction so go figure thats more complex. Sexuality is what youre attracted to,and get this, sexually, meaning it can get pretty damn specific, because thats what youre into, sexually. Now gender is something you identify with which makes sense as gender is a social construction which ascribes different roles and characteristics to the person. Now non-binary people simply feels they dont fit into either category and thats it thats the end of the story they just dont consider themselves male or female and that in and of itself is enough. You may not understand it but thats because you dont feel that way youre not non-binary. Biology is incredibly complicated and if it wasnt we wouldnt be having this discussion at all, so Id recommend from now on to not treat science as if it were so binary because its not and all of the above is scientifically accepted and I dont want you to misinterpret how complex human identity really is.

Now to answer what a cis genderfluid demi-girl is (a strawman). Cis means your gender identity is what you were born as sex wise, born male identity is male. genderfluid means your gender is not consistently the same and you can feel differently at different times, as you can see no one is identifying this way as in the first two words it already contradicts itself a genderfluid person is not cis. Demi is someone who experiences sexual attraction after they form emotional bonds, all it is is just how they experience sexual attraction, thats it. Then girl would mean you identify as a girl as a gender which obviously theyre not if theyre genderfluid.

Granted Im not a member of the LGBTQ+ community but I am making attempts to understand here and I think if you keep an open mind here you will too. The reality quite frankly is, people have always felt like this and will always continue to now they just have the environment and opportunity to be true to themselves and others. Its not getting out of hand its getting honest about how complex we are as people and as a society.

Thank you for reading my short essay best of luck to you.

2
Sarcastic_Troll•

Lol. I don't really care. I'm caring as far as this conversation goes. At the time I wrote that, I had a raging toothache, was up alone, pissed I couldn't sleep, and just came out with this passive agression passion because anything is better than focusing on a toothache lol.

Now it's during the day, and I feel a little better because, I dunno, you always feel a little better when life is bustling around you, IMHO. That doesn't mean my tooth isn't fuck all hell. I just wish it would stop.

But the insurance company has to approve anything, and it could take up to two weeks. Bout to pull the tooth out myself if even slightly touching it didn't cause agony, so can't figure out how I'd get a string around it.

I'm also very hungry. I can literally only somewhat (somewhat) mash things with my tongue. But if my tongue touches my tooth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1
kingofthebunch•

I don't wanna be called queer anyhow. Its a slur. They can have it, I guess.

3
TimeCubePriest•

Finally, some real fucking gatekeeping

2
PBandJammies•

This just in: gay people are no longer considered gay!

2

There's some irony in that queer (at least back in my youth) was used as an umbrella term. Apparently now we're gatekeeping it? Wild.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thanks for your submission, Human3000!

Please remember to censor out any identifying details and that satire is only allowed on weekends. If this post is truly gatekeeping, upvote it! If it's not gatekeeping or if it breaks any other rules, downvote this comment and REPORT the post so we can see it!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
bobinski_circus•

This is likely some kid who's way too deep into tumblr deep lore and has completely lost touch with reality...and the English language...god I hope it's a kid, then there's a chance they grow out of it.

1
come_on_anarchy•

Wow gate keeping identities only 4% of population uses.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1

Absolutely! I honestly believe that most people who behave that way will eventually grow out of the behavior and that they will make excellent friends and allies, it’s just difficult to be around them while they act the way they do. I am also lucky to have never been in a situation where I have felt unsafe or oppressed because of my sexuality. It may just be because I don’t disclose that information to most people and it may also just be because most people in my area have a stereotype of how members of the lgbt community behave/present themselves and I just don’t fit the description. All of it definitely affects my disposition. Also this has been a wonderful conversation and it has brightened my evening, so thank you!

1
Secret-Agent-Ninja•

Gatekeeping an inclusive community... you have gone too far

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
VexingMadcap•

Lemme translate for you my friends.

Queer: someone who doesn't fit the cis normative. Example, a guy that wears lots of make up. That doesn't make him gay or bisexual. Just queer.

This is what they want it to mean I believe. It's a simplistic example but the easiest to make.

-1†
Coolsebas65•

Idk why the lgbt community is so toxic amongst themselves and others. Now it’s denying basic biology and doing shit like this

-2†
iaia93•

Denying basic biology? What does that mean?

1†
Coolsebas65•

Inventing new genders and terms to garner attention like in the post above and expecting everyone to accept it as fact.

-2†
TimeCubePriest•

I don't know how to tell you this but gender has nothing to do with biology

2
iaia93•

Like beyond just female and male, you mean?

0
Logandanielsboi•

Nope either man or women simple as that

-2†
Shitposterman69•

Or perhaps a bit braindead, in your case.

-1