Clone Wars Download: A Distant Echo
Posted Mar 2, 2020, 2:03 PM UTC
Posted Mar 2, 2020, 2:03 PM UTC
If there was still any doubt that it was Dave Filoni who decided to replace the Padme gunship pin-up scene, this should erase that.
Interesting to hear how the voice actress, Catherine Taber, was sad to hear that she wouldn't be involved in what became the last season, and this knowledge influenced Filoni's decision.
I'm glad that they made the change. It was heartwarming to see Padme supporting Anakin, and encouraging him to help his comrade/friend.
Nose art scene was funny but I'm not even mad, bc the one we got is far better, for different reasons ofc
Why oppose those two scenes ? It was perfectly possible to have both...
Okay, so think of it this way:
Imagine voicing a character who was an essential part of the main cast in the movies. For this popular cartoon in the same time period, your character's husband and best bud is getting some attention in the final season, but not your character.
And this season will be focusing on two other protagonists created for the show, so there's not much chances for yours to show up.
So, the director says, "You know what, let's give her a nice send-off". And your character has a sweet moment with her husband that shows how loving their relationship is, how loyal the husband is to his trusted right-hand man, and gave insight into why the husband doesn't trust his master and closest friend about his secret relationship.
And then, a few minutes later, your character's 'last appearance' was as a sexy pin-up for a joke.
Look, I get what you're saying , and I think the joke was funny too. But this joke was made when the arc was not originally part of the final season, and it added nothing to the story. If anything, it would probably make the new scene feel less impactful (especially since this might be the last time we see Padme). If I was the character or actor, I would not be pleased.
Also there's only so many minutes in the episode, you have to prioritize. Is the pin-up joke worth shortening other scenes in the episode? It's pretty packed full as it is, other scenes already had to be cut/shortened to fit the longer Padme scene in.
And then, a few minutes later, your character's 'last appearance' was as a sexy pin-up for a joke.
That fact you put last appearance in quote marks shows you kind of already know you're overthinking it.
The joke was fine, it's only funny when you know it was tasteless art. They got rid of it because they'd rather that wasn't all anyone was talking about. End of.
Well not really. It would've felt repetitive. The nose art scene covered many of the same beats as the new Padme scene. We get Rex knowing about Anakin's relationship and Obi Wan mentioning that the council doesn't approve of the mission. It also doesn't really fit with the new tone of the arc in the finished version. While the new scene is still humorous, it feels more character driven as opposed to a gag.
The sad thing is, some fans will bury their heads in the sand, and claim that it was Disney's decision to remove the nose art scene, and that Filoni is just a fall man (An actual argument I've already seen online)
Is it really that hard to believe?
Like, in terms of storytelling, this was a great scene. Way better than the original joke, which didn't add anything to the story (which was also part of the final season, not like they have much time to squeeze in everything).
For some people, yeah. They have to keep up their whole "Disney is evil" Shtick in order to keep pumping out YT videos.
No matter who made the call, it's a joke that doesn't play in the current climate.
Imagine the Air Force putting a sexualized version of a comparable young female politician like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on a plane. It wouldn't go over well.
I still think the joke works.
But with respect to Padme as a character (if this is her final appearance in the series; and likely in live action/animated media) I don't think her last reference should be a pin up model joke.
Nothing wrong with the joke, Padme isn’t the only female nose art in the show. Or poster. Or scantily-clad dancer. OUR climate is not theirs, and their military aesthetic is heavy on the WWII influences where cartoons, crude names, and women were on posters and painted on the nose of planes. Add in that clones are grown and raised in solitude around millions of men who look exactly like them, with the exception of kaminoans, a few bounty hunters, and jedi... they are likely not all caught up on social do’s and do not’s involving female interaction and even attraction.
Most importantly: It is just a joke. And it gave us a hint that Rex knows whats going on.
Was it ever confirmed in the show that Obi-wan knew about their relationship? If not that’s a big fucking moment right there.
He says in S6 something along the lines of “I know to a degree what’s going on” and he regularly gives Anakin little looks when Padmé stuff comes up
It's been implied that he knew they loved each other. This episode was just the one where he expressed his suspicions.
This Quora page has some examples: https://www.quora.com/Did-Obi-Wan-know-Anakin-and-Padme-were-together
But like Filoni said in the video, Obi-Wan just never realised that they went as far as to get married.
It is strongly implied that Obi Wan knows that Anakin is having some kind of romantic affair with Padme. He never outright says “I know you and Padme are together” but it’s downright obvious that Obi Wan knows about their relationship. He’s the epitome of the bro that doesn’t necessarily think it’s a good idea but is also a good enough friend to never rat him out.
I get so sad when i see Obi Wan try to talk to Anakin about it because I truly do believe that he would’ve understood in the end. It’s tragic.
Yeah, I’m glad that this was confirmed. I don’t mind nearly as much if it was a creative decision instead of a mandate. While I still wish they kept it, his reasoning does make sense and as a Padmé fan her new scene was a treat
I haven't seen this mentioned anywhere, but have we seen the Techno Union droids that appeared in this episode before? (In the story reel or anywhere else)
They look so flimsy/goofy! But it's still a great departure from the regular B1 droids and they gave the Techno Union some unique flair.
Yeah they appeared in the unfinished version of this episode
[removed]
I think we’ve only seen them in the Bad Batch story reels. This episode marks their first official appearance
i never noticed that the voice actor for obi-wan was tidus as well.
i'm gonna go play with my pet rock now.
I’ve grown to love Rex and his clone buddies more and more over time. They’re some of my favorite characters now.
[removed]
I hate how Disney is retconning stuff, it was never fully stated that Obi Wan knew exactly what was going on, and now with that one line it basically confirms he knows about their relationship.
Even in Clone Wars before Disney, Obi-Wan has a private talk with Anakin due to Anakin's jealousy over Amidala's past with Clovis.
To paraphrase, Obi-Wan tells Anakin he has a pretty good idea of what is going on. He brings up Satine and reminds Anakin that he and Satine were once involved. Anakin angrily insists he and Amidala are only friends.
Hell, Obi-Wan pretty much knew from AotC when Anakin flipped out screaming that he needs Amidala.
That talk reveals that Obi Wan thought Anakin had a crush/was falling in love with Padme.
He “had a pretty good idea of what is going on” in the sense that Anakin had feelings for Padme, not that they were in a relationship. Not once was it implied Obi Wan knew about the relationship.
Yeah, but Obi-Wan isn't stupid. Anakin and Amidala are together way too much, Anakin has a habit of disappearing to go see her. A deleted scene in RotS would have shown Obi-Wan's visit to Amidala where Obi-Wan calls Amidala out on the relationship. The scene was deleted, but Padme still references the visit when Anakin asks if Obi-Wan had been at her apartment.
Obi Wan not knowing about the relationship only helps the story by strengthening the fact that the Jedi were blinded.
Deleted scenes are deleted for a reason. In RoTS, it’s obvious that Obi Wan only knew about the relationship in RoTS, not before. It’s been like this for years. This is just a failure in creating consistent writing on Disney’s part, as usual.
It was also never confirmed that he didn't know.
It was heavily implied that Obi Wan didn’t know in RoTS, otherwise then it would’ve made sense for George Lucas to include dialogue in RoTS making it clear that Obi Wan knew what was going on.
Disney retconning a gray area that leans towards Obi Wan not knowing is just sheer incompetency
Can you just shut up about Disney for bleeping second. Filoni is writing this show not Disney and everything he’s learned is from George. He even said in an interview he made calls with George while making this final season.
Uh-uh, they censored some stuff.
Agreed.
not a leak
Page hasn’t posted leaks which matter since December. It’s essentially just a less filtered r/starwars until something significant rolls around again.
Who the fuck cares.
Ever sence the ST, I find it really hard to feel excited about new content because I know everything that happens right up to 6 amounted to nothing in a plot reset :(
disregard everything after the mandalorian then
Yeah in my head i've been trying to split the timelines...
no clue why you got downvoted for this lmao. just said your opinion respectfully
Reddit I guess :(
This is downvoted but I heavily fucking agree. People get shit on for criticizing what should be seen as a glaring issue of uninspired storytelling. I’ll take the hit, Star Wars ends at RotJ in my opinion. Everything else is simply just anthology material to me which I consider about as canon as the EU. Canon is arbitrary anyways.
It's all fiction, pick and choose what you like. I don't see why people need to get so melodramatic about it. Don't like the new content, ignore it. Prefer the old content, more power to you. Literally none of it matters.
Pretty much summed it up for me.
Normally I love the animated side series but I intantly lost interest in resistance now that I know the story is pretty pointless :/
I feel the same way, but only in regards to IX. I loved TLJ.
The Rise of Skywalker made me feel the same way Batman V Superman made me feel. Just so... uninterested.
At least we'll always have the other movies/TV shows.
Well my friend, I think you need to accept that you don’t like Star Wars anymore.
But...I dont want to :(
It’ll be easier for you and the rest of us if you do.
Well you should.
Filoni hits the nail on the head again. I love how he just gets it.
I saw a tweet the other day which basically said imagine the feelings Obi-Wan must have been going through, to know that Anakin was having this secret relationship with Padmé but didn't trust Obi-Wan enough to confide in him about it and instead snuck around behind his back like he does in this episode. Even when Obi-Wan is dropping little hints that he knows like, "I hope you said hello to Padmé for me (by the way I know you're in love with her and I'm here if you want to talk about it)" Anakin still keeps it a secret from him, but not Rex. For your best friend to have so little trust and faith in you must have been absolutely crushing for Obi-Wan. It's really heartbreaking to think about.
I don’t know, I like that in theory but it didn’t really work for me. I like the S6 scene where Obi-Wan heavily hints at it and tries to talk to him but Anakin just becomes frustrated and defensive, he was a little too casual and playful about it here and seemed like he understood Obi-Wan would understand. I also feel like it makes Obi-Wan know the relationship was actually pretty serious instead of something minor
It’s still a good scene, just conflicts with what my interpretation was
Do you feel there is a little tonal issue on your interpretation? I felt that obi-wan says “i hope you say hi to Padmé for me” out of frustration that has been brewing (which we see in season 6) because Anakin won’t confide in him about the relationship.
Also, i do think obi-wan knew it was at least somewhat serious, as they’ve been around each other for so long. The season 6 scene is him trying to probe, and his outburst in this episode just pretty much gave him confirmation that Anakin and Padmé are serious based on his reaction.
I think Obi Wan knew Anakin and Padme were seeing each other and obviously had feelings for one another, but as Dave said, he didn't think it went as far as marriage and having a child.
I actually like in this scene how Anakin is casual and playful about it until Obi Wan mentions Padme. Then he looks back with a sort of annoyed, almost angry expression. Really shows the growing resentment Anakin had with Obi Wan and the Jedi Order more broadly.
Honestly don’t think a lil relationship bothers him too much. Obi Wan has an emotional relationship, though not active, with Satine. He cares for her very much, but chose the Jedi life and is not attached. He can be fine with Anakin having a similar thing, it’d be hypocritical if he weren’t...
But an active secret relationship? marriage? A child? Thats running a lot of risks of attachment for someone with Anakin’s issues and past.
This is the largest area where I get upset with the prequel films for having such thin writing and character development. The Clone Wars totally does this this right though, it's so nice to have Filloni broadening the strokes overall.
I disagree, I think the prequels had plenty of character development, the problem was how the dialogue conveys that information. Clone wars fills that out and conveys those ambiguities creates by the sloppy dialogue.
Such as anakins disillusionment,
How the Jedi played a legitimate role in his falL
the friendships feel more genuine, among many other things... but I don’t think they ever steer from the intent of the films, they just use much better dialogue to convey those same things
If I had to guess, the reason he trusts Rex and not Obi Wan has to do with Rex not being on the council that voted against Ashoka in S5.