r/statistics•
0876

[Q] Help with path analysis (theory only, no numbers...)

Question

Just looking for your thoughts on this relationship I'm investigating. I have done a regression between two variables (effect of B on C) and found a nice healthy relationship as I expected. But I think that this effect is being overstated, because what's really happening is that unmeasurable variable A is actually causing B, and A is also causing C. So a lot of this relationship I'm seeing between B and C is actually the result of these strong relationships between A -> B and A -> C. Here's a diagram: https://i.imgur.com/Y1ti9b9.jpg

Because variable A is unmeasurable, I'm not looking for any advice on what to do with any numbers, but just looking for your thoughts on this relationship. Am I describing a mediating effect?

There is theoretical reason to believe that B does (at least a little bit) cause C, but there is also theoretical reason to believe that A strongly causes B and also that A strongly causes C. I'm thinking of calling B an "indicator" to predict C. Does this make sense? (It does cause C to some degree, but might be more useful to be thought of as "indicating" A, which is what's actually causing C)

Posted Mar 4, 2020, 2:11 AM UTC · edited

01
midianite_rambler•

This is called a latent variable model (among other terms). If you have domain knowledge that the graph should look like B <-- A --> C or A --> (B --> C) , then, yes, absolutely, you should structure your model accordingly and take that knowledge into account.

The results are going to depend on your assumptions -- my advice is to treat this as an exercise in Bayesian inference, to make it possible to quantify your assumptions and see what exactly are the consequences.

If you say more about the problem, people here can probably give more specific advice.

1