I can't seem to narrow down my issues...

Question

Been at this for about 6 weeks now.

My current setup:
Black straight-sided tumblers from Candle Science
6006 wax (no additives)
Minimal dye
8%-10% fragrance load
All fragrances purchased from either Candle Science or ProCandleSupply

My process:
Heat wax to 200 degrees
Add dye
Gently stir down to around 170 degrees
Mix in fragrance oil and stir down to around 160 degrees
Pour
(I leave extra to do a second pour to even out the tops)
Let them sit for around 24 hours, trim wicks to a quarter-inch and test burn.

My issue:
I've tested about every single type of wick Candle Science has to offer and I've narrowed it down to Eco wicks being my best choice - others either just didn't perform well or mushroomed like crazy.

Now my problem is sooting. We have a 1,200 sq. ft. showroom floor and two test candles smoked out the back half of the shop.

Eco 8 isn't giving me a full melt pool and soots and the Eco 10 soots like a chimney on Christmas morning, but it does perform marginally better than the 8 in giving me a better melt pool.

What am I doing wrong?
I've stepped down my fragrance and dye loads, wicked up, wicked down, tried different wicks and I just can't seem to hit a home run here. I'm running my test budget thin here...

Posted Mar 7, 2020, 12:26 PM UTC

211
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
kb2001OP•

Thank you for the information. I appreciate it.

2
Ayo1912•

Are the wicks prewaxed or do you wax them yourself? Just trying to get a bit more info

1
kb2001OP•

Prewaxed

1
flannelmike•

Try one without dye in it and see what happens. If you're using black tumblers, I'm not sure why you want to use dye anyway. When you say the other wicks didn't perform well, what was the issue?

1
kb2001OP•

A little back story: I'm making these for a company I work for. I was tasked with figuring this stuff out (I just wasn't anticipating some of the issues I've run into) and they're wanting to sell them in the shops.
The dye is minimal (one single drop per pound of wax) and just to add a little variance to each one. I see what you're saying about using the black jars...but it's out of my hands. If it was ones I was making for personal use, I wouldn't care about adding dye.

The other wicks either mushroomed horribly, cracked/popped/borderline-exploded when relit or didn't burn even enough (either too deep of a melt pool or too shallow/tunneling).

1
flannelmike•

Were you getting a good melt pool with the other wicks? It sounds like they may have been over sized. What types did you test? I'd still test one without the dye just to take out that variable. And was the dye made for candles?

1
kb2001OP•

The HTP wicks did give a good melt pool, but those were the ones I had the biggest problem with as far as mushrooming went (beyond being able to properly trim).

Full list of wicks I've tested so far:

  • LX 18, LX 22, LX 24, LX 26
  • CSN 26
  • HTP 105, HTP 126
  • Eco 8, Eco 10, Eco 12

99.9% of the supplies have been purchased from CandleScience at this point. The dye is from them and made for candles.

1
flannelmike•

I'm taking a guess and saying that the HTP wicks you used are way over sized for the container you're using. I use those wicks in the same container, although it's with a different, but similar wax and I use an 83. I haven't played with the other wicks you mentioned in a very long time, but a quick glance at the wick guide tells me you went in the wrong direction with the wicks. You wicked up and didn't try down. So I would give that a shot. How short are you trimming the wicks on the initial burn?

1